The issue is whether there is sufficient evidence to prosecute Agnes for theft given that she left a shop in possession of a handbag for which she had not paid. To determine if there is sufficient evidence it is necessary to consider the likely defence case and bear in mind how likely the defence case is to affect the prospect of conviction. The defence is likely to argue that there is no evidence to suggest that Agnes was the person that placed the handbag in her bag prior to leaving the…
wrongly convicted him for Hae Min Lee’s murder, the prosecutors used testimonies from suspects that were inconsistent and they attempted to vilify him to make him out to look like a bad kid. As I said before, the state 's argument against Adnan was based on inconsistent testimonies. This unreliable testimony occurred mainly with Jay who was Adnan 's weed dealer. Adnan was known to smoke weed with him often. When Adnan…
reliability factors against the corrupting influence of the suggestive procedures to determine whether the identification is reliable and therefore admissible (Couch, AFRICAN AMERICANS WRONGLY CONVICTED 7 2013, p. 1536). Eyewitness testimonies are still used to this day even though the reliability of this source of evidence is not as good as the Supreme Court believed. It’s a wonder why this is still being used as much seeing as how it is the number one cause of false…
All of the above concerns regarding forensic testimony presents a significant problem in our courtrooms where the negligent action be extremely high. Juries give undue attention to the testimony presented by forensic scientists and the above issues can pose a significant threat to the resulting judgment. Any ethical forensic examiner would not mislead the courtroom but as depicted above, this is certainly not the case. Thompson & Dioso-Villa (2008) argue that many areas of forensic science are…
specifically eye witness testimonies? Eye witness testimony has been the bases of many research studies, an eye witness is someone who give their account of an event that they has witnessed. Eye witness testimonies are widely used in court as a means of evidence, making it crucial that the witness has a reliable memory. Eye witness testimonies use to be a very damning piece of evidence. As time went on and as more research went in to looking at the reliability of memory an eye witness testimony…
As stated in Psychology, a definition of eyewitness testimony would be "a legal term that essentially describes when a witness or victim is recounting their firsthand experience to another person or to a court" (Psychology Glossary,2017). Eyewitness testimonies are reliable, mainly in court hearings full of eyewitnesses who might have seen an incident happening. However, eyewitness testimony is hard to believe because although a person's memory is quite incredible, it is also imperfect. Our…
the evidence such as DNA evidence that they have found on the crime scene and eyewitness testimony to the judge before he decided the outcome of the trial. [1] This makes us wonder about the possibility that these DNA evidence and witness testimony could be wrong and which one is more superior compared to the other in solving crime cases. I would like to discuss the value of DNA evidence vs witness Testimony in the next few paragraphs. DNA evidence refers to DNA samples that are taken from a…
Before DNA evidence an eyewitness testimony was a pivotal turning point in a case and often the only evidence offered to identify a suspect. The most common method of identification of an eyewitness’s account is a line up. These come in different forms from: verbal, pictures, to actual people present in a room. The idea behind these varied forms of identification allows less bias if someone had only had one sense to identify a suspect. For example: someone who was blindfolded could use a verbal…
Science of Humanities University of Ontario Institute of Technology Oshawa, Ontario Dr. Karla Emeno Davut Akca March 27th 2016 Introduction Eyewitness testimony has been a very important aspect towards forensic psychology and convicting offenders. This paper will be argued towards the aspect of how new research has applied to eye witness testimonies and its importance towards dealing with future cases to prevent wrongful convictions. The first section of this paper covers the topics of the…
be facing the problem of extinction in the context of survivor testimonies. According to Holocaust studies critic Thomas Trezise, this phenomenon is the “anxiety of historical transmission” and accounts for the large part acceleration of testimony production in the past three decades. Through the establishment of the different documentation and archives of written memoirs, the question on the fate of these Holocaust survivor testimonies entirely dependents on the reception by those who “were…