(May 12th lecture, 2016). The drawbacks of restorative justice include the fact that is not, as of yet evidence based. We rely on correctional theories that are defined by scientific evidence, and proven methods for reducing recidivism. Restorative justice relies on relationship building, to make reoffending less likely (Kurbin & Stucky, 2013, p.274). This can go counter to the desire for justice as well (Kurbin & Stucky, 2013, p.275). Further, the restorative approach is at this point…
Gianna Jordan Ms.Logan AP language- Period A 2 April 2024. The 57 Bus Restorative Justice is a new approach to crime, and it works to address the dehumanization frequently experienced by people in the criminal justice system. Restorative justice is more popular now and it is another way to work toward rehabilitation and lower imprisonment rates. Although some may believe that people old enough to commit a crime should face the full punishment of the crime, others believe that young adults have…
In recent years government leaders have begun to address the expanded use of zero tolerance policies in schools. In 2012, the State of Michigan Department of Education (MDOE) published a resolution to address school discipline and issues impacting student outcomes. This resolution reinforced what research has already shown in regards to the negative impacts on students who are suspended or expelled and strongly urges schools in Michigan to “adopt discipline policies without mandated suspensions…
Restorative justice is a process that aims to repair harm caused by criminal behavior by involving the victim, the offender, and the community in the resolution of the conflict. It is a victim-centered approach that prioritizes accountability, healing, and reintegration of both the victim and the offender into the community. Violence prevention efforts are important because they seek to reduce the incidence of violence and its impact on victims, families, and society as a whole. Restorative…
makes them more prone to committing crime. The crime isn’t necessarily violent like today. It could be as simple as not conforming to beliefs like Socrates. No I have never been exposed to pro crime definition; I grew up knowing the basis of the justice system of innocent until proven guilty. The element of commitment in Hirschi’s theory supports school failure-delinquency link. Students who are committed to education are less likely to involve in delinquency. In order to do well in school…
Restorative conferences A restorative conference invites the opportunity for large groups to discuss challenging matters, harmful incidents, and misconducts within the community. More specifically, “A restorative conference is a structured meeting that brings more people into the conversation in order to deal with the wrongdoing and decide how to best repair the harm” (Winslade, Espinoza, Myers & Yzagurrie, 2014, p. 26). The main focus of a restorative conference is to recognize the damaged…
much of the inequalities and poverty that plagues Latin America. Because of my experiences in both countries, I have always felt in my heart that my duty as a citizen of the world is to grow in every possible manner, and to study peace and social justice diligently so that I can one day join efforts…
just to be released with the skills to put them right back into the prison. Mass incarceration is caused through tough on crime which is put to the extreme when looking at the United States, who’s incarceration rate is 6,851,000 inmates (Bureau of Justice Statistics). Mass incarceration does nothing to deter crime but does lead to overcrowding in jails. As pointed out by Eleanor Goldberg in her (2015) Huffington Post article, “overcrowding means less access to rehabilitative programs”, such…
Impact of Restorative Justice on Disadvantaged Populations In the Canadian criminal justice system, justice is equated with fair and deserving punishment for deviant individuals (Griffiths, 2011). However, this does not necessarily happen to be the case for Aboriginal people who are drastically over-represented in all aspects of the system. In fact, the Supreme Court of Canada called the over-representation of Aboriginal people as a “crisis in the Canadian criminal justice system” (Rudin &…
Examples of socially just intuitions include “a non-partisan judiciary, an effective civil service and an appropriate legislative structure” (Bloomfield, pg. 21). Philpott argues that because “political reconciliation is a form of justice”, that “building socially just institutions is [an] entirely fitting…” part of the process (Philpott, pg. 176). Building such institutions after a government has violated the rights of its citizens “redresses…the lack of respect and legal guarantee…