Analysis Of Free Community College Is A Bad Idea By Carol Roth

Improved Essays
Education For Everyone Education is something that everyone should be able to have. Knowledge is not something that should be for sale. Everyone should be able to have equal opportunity. This is why there should be no cost for receiving a college education. The general argument made by Carol Roth in the article “Free Community College Isn’t Free...and it’s a Bad Idea” is that saying that college will be free when it really won’t, and it will cause more problems and evidently not solve any current problems. She states that nothing is really ever free because there has to be someone paying for the programs that the schools are offering. In addition, Roth claims that the taxpayers will end up paying it off at large; as well as the supply and demand effect where just because college is being deemed “free” the more of it you offer the more cost will increase. To support this idea she specifically writes, “ Someone has to pay for the costs of the program and those paying for it will be the taxpayers. That means that both the people who opt for free community college will pay for it — as well taxpayers at large — at inflated prices down the road” she also mentions “ It 's basic supply and demand. If you put more demand into a fixed supply of colleges, costs will increase. Although Roth does not say so directly, she apparently assumes that deeming community college as free will obviously not solve any current problems the government has caused us, and it will also won’t benefit our country in the future. Basically, the essence of Carol Roth’s argument is that community college might not be as free as it seems and that it is altogether a horrible idea due to the fact that it will cost taxpayers more. In my view, Roth’s argument is valid because the easy money will increase demand in the fixed college supply system and before we know it …show more content…
Although this topic might seem relevant to a select group of individuals, it should in fact matter to anyone concerned about the issue of the government causing more money to be taken from taxpayers. “Truth be told, we have myriad educational opportunities available online for an incredibly low cost- and in many cases for "free". With discipline, anyone can learn more on their computer from the comfort of their home” (Roth 1). This statement makes the author’s argument stronger because she is explaining that there are other options other than college that still offers quality education, and fairly cheap. This is strong because she includes it towards the end of the article to provide readers with options after she bashes the idea of free community college. All in all, it is my goal to try and persuade you to agree that everyone should have equal access to the same amount of knowledge. That way they can always make the decision to accept the free education if they think it fit for them, or they could do something else with their life that does not involve needing a college education. Free education means that there could be more job opportunities for people. There won’t be the struggle of having to put your life on hold in order to pay off student loans. You would be able to save more money and spend it on whatever you needed to make your dreams come

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Vedder argues that free collage is an illusion because the funds used to support education in collages is paid by an individual. He points out it is imperative students to pay for the educational services they access in collages because they are the end beneficiaries. In his article, he acknowledges that any student from a middle class family can afford education. “But the true dropout rate is almost certainly greater than the graduation rate”(401). Vedder is critical on why free tuition should be introduced in colleges.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In article “As He Promotes it, Some Question Obama’s Free Community College Idea”, written by Joanne Jacobs, the proposition of free community college in America is met with some reasonable hesitation. While Barack Obama plans to give out free community college, students like Felipe Bezerra do not see the reason why President Obama would do this and disagrees with Obama’s plan stating that “‘Tuition shouldn’t be free’ for those who could afford it”, And frankly I agree with him. There are multiple reasons why this idea should not come to light, for one main reason that would affect everybody is money. The White house estimates that if free community college does become reality, it would cost $60 billion dollars over the course of 10 years.…

    • 489 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He states, that a nationally supported, but locally controlled, tuition-free education system from kindergarten through four years of college is possible. It is not likely for it to happen soon, but adding two years to the existing free education model is digestible financially. He adds this is the kind of national investment that will pay off in ways immeasurable. Better-educated people tend to get better-paying jobs, adding more fuel to the nation’s economic engine, and is benefiting to our nation providing better-informed and more-engaged electorates.…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “As he promotes it,Some question Obama’s Free Community College Idea” by Joanne Jacobs we learn about the pros and cons there is to having a community college free. In the article we learn about the good things in having a free community college as well as the negative parts of it. Although there is many opinions to both sides my opinion and the side I am choosing is that a community college should not be free. I believe a community college shouldn’t be free because it's unfair for those who attend a 4 year university and have to pay the double amount of what a community college is normally. In the article Michele Siqueiros says “The promise of free tuition cold make the problem worse by drawing more students to already crowded…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Boen Wang, a sophomore majoring in engineering science at Penn State who was featured on The Daily Collegian’s Wednesday column, wrote an article called Reasons to make community college free. He insists that making community college free is possible and could potentially reshape higher education. He pinpoints one of the effects of high tuition and presents, “Lack of financial resources is one of the major reasons for such low graduation rates” (Wang). This should worry the college’s staff simply because one of the school 's purposes is to get everyone to graduate. With these low rates, students wanting to apply for the school will not feel confident and are going to assume the institution cannot deliver academic support.…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Community College Should Not Be Free President Barack Obama and Bernie Sanders have been discussing making two years of community college tuition free, one hundred percent free on the student’s part. Is it actually free for the students? Doesn’t the United States already have programs that are supposed to help low-income students afford their tuition? How could it affect the taxpayers or even taxes?…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In order to obtain jobs, one needs more than twelve years of education and money in able to pay for that education. Universities and private institutions are steadily increasing their prices causing students not to attend college due to their financial situation. Which is why, free college tuition should be enforced in America…

    • 1483 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Why should college be free for people with low income? If college were free, there would be a higher percentage of people who graduate from college. Everyone should get a chance to get a higher education without paying. If students have been going to school for free, they should not have to start paying for school when they graduate.…

    • 1654 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    It must have been a daunting prospect at the time - paying for the education of so many children for such an extended period of time, transferring a potential workforce away from productivity for an investment like schooling.” If free education for all high schools could be achieved, even if it’s still being ironed out with it’s problems, then why not do the same for college education? College students should be given the chance to make the most of their…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Importance Of Free College Education

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited

    For students to understand the investment of an education shows a maturity that they developed by taking out loans. It is required for students to undergo a seminar about loans and how it should be monitored. This helps students understand the real life aspect of adult hood and money management ("Huffington Post" ). If college were to be free, yes students would not have to take out any loans whatsoever but many would not develop the maturity needed for life after college. It is understandable for students to disagree with the argument and refute that college is something that should be free to anyone.…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    By making all public colleges free in America it would roughly cost between fifty and thirty billion dollars, which may appear like a mountain of money, specifically taxpayers money; but the government is spending a substantial amount of money on profitable colleges which have extremely low graduation rates (Samuels, 2014). Higher education can be seen to improve the economy immensely. If all 18-24 year olds were enrolled and active in college unemployment would reduce by 2 million people (Samuels, 2014)! A higher educated America would also allow us to become more competitively economically and academically on an international level. Also a more educated work force and educated society would reduce criminal activity, and ensure greater success for the future of America.…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    New Republic is opposed to it saying “The main problem with free college is that most students come from disproportionately well-off backgrounds and already enjoy disproportionately well-off futures, which makes them relatively uncompelling targets for public transfers.” Many disagree, saying “College should be free to all students. Just like students have a right to elementary and secondary education, students should have a right to obtain higher education. If a person has a desire to learn more, they should not be forced to stop learning after high school due to a lack of money or connections” (Academic OneFile). Students that have been raised in the middle or lower class may not have the income, work, and time to support them in top well known colleges.…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Free College A college education has become a necessity in today’s society. What if college was miraculously free. It would be like going to your public high school with out paying that horrendous tuition fee. A lot of people say that free college is a dumb idea because it could potentially flood the market, and Others think it’s a great idea though because more people would end up going to college because they don’t have to worry about financially paying for it.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    School is a necessary system worldwide to invest in a society 's future. The primary argument as to why educational institutions should be free in the U.S. is not to give everyone the equal opportunity to education as stated by Lawrence (a professor of History emeritus at SUNY Albany) although it is one of the reasons, the primary reason is to increase the number of educated workers to hopefully improve our economy. It is stated that an “educated work force has become an essential component of economic growth and competitiveness (Student Aid Alliance). However, college tuition filters out those who are not willing to pay for their education and also funds universities so that they are able to function and upgrade their facilities. College should not be free because it would lead to tax raises, the value of a degree would decline, and the overall quality of the educational environment would decrease.…

    • 1088 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “A study from 1.8 million high school students graduating in 2013 who took the ACT said 95% wanted to continue education, only 59% immediately enrolled in college” (Take). People need to get a higher education and making college free would help people have a chance to get their degree. Therefore, more people would attend college, if it 00………….was free. Consequently, college should be free for everyone. There are three reasons why college should be free everywhere and for everyone.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays