Justification for Law-Breaking Essay

between patrol officers and motorists. When motorist were asked to pull over for traffic violations, their reactions vary, such as the usage of sympathy, justification, mitigations, ignorance, and remorse. In addition, it was noted that police officers tend to depersonalize their personal discretion to the responsibility of the police hierarchical bureaucracy, in order to avoid negative social sanctions from the public. In past studies, the Criminal Justice system has analyzed the social functions between accounts in offensive behaviors. These institutions such as police and correctional services have researched the descriptions about speech acts (4). When exploring the social functions,…

In the short stories, “Letter from Birmingham Jail” by Martin Luther King Jr. and “Civil Disobedience” by Henry David Thoreau, both of their circumstances were the same, which was to make unjust laws just. I do believe that both writers were justified in their actions because they both were doing something for the people. I believe that Martin Luther King Jr. had more justification than Thoreau did because if Thoreau had more justification what he was protesting for would have stopped all of…

There were many times in history when breaking the law has been justified. Great men like Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King broke the law and changed the world to a better one. However, there are numerous philosophers that have argued that because it involves breaking the law, civil disobedience needs special justification. In this paper I will argue how an act of civil disobedience would be valid when a person goes against their country’s laws to do the right thing. First I will discuss…

As well as the unwillingness to consent to England’s tyranny, laws and acts enforced upon the colonists only added to the already large resentment and feelings of rebellion among the people. For instance, Document 2, excerpts from ‘Letters from a Farmer in Pennsylvania’ by John Dickinson, illustrates the stamp act as “unconstitutional, and . . . destructive to the liberty of theses colonies.” The Stamp Act was conveyed as an unjust law and enforcement against the colonists, being that they had…

Crato’s last argument more weighted than the rest. Not only Crito mentions that escaping takes bravery, and a good father-is a brave father, he also mentions that remaining in jail would be the easiest thing to go through with. These more substantial arguments were unsuccessfully presented with the ideal goal of getting Socrates out of his cell, but all the efforts were senseless in the eyes of Socrates. Socrates’s responses weren’t very pleasing and didn’t get Crito’s approval. His first…

On April 12, 1963, eight clergymen released a letter addressing the recent events in Birmingham, Alabama concerning the civil rights movement. They first acknowledge the positive, yet slow steps being taken by citizens through the court system. This is followed by them discouraging citizens participation in recent demonstrations “directed and led in part by outsiders” condemning them as “unwise and untimely.” The letter also expressed their shared belief that all racial issues in their city…

false justifications that allowed the institution of American slavery to continue to grow. True ideas of democracy allow and celebrate each individual’s freedom and pursuit of happiness. These ideas of democracy were nonexistent on American plantations in the period of slavery. Slaves were not only denied their freedom and legal position, they were subjected to a life of suffering. Douglass’s narrative details his experience with the widespread immorality in the south and gives an insight to…

the nature of justice and how one should act in the face of injustice. Crito offers to help Socrates escape prison to evade execution, yet Socrates argues it is wrong for him to escape in response to the injustice he has been dealt. Dealing with the relationship between an individual and a state’s laws, this dialogue is the foundation for inquiry into arguments for being a law-abiding citizen, whether law breaking is justified and the purpose of the state. This shall be explored, however the…

Civil Disobedience Are government laws always fair? In the past, laws that were unfair to people were broken without using any violence. Civil disobedience is a common act that consists of ordinary offences, different ways of justification, and many effects. To this day, there has been three major influencers for this act: Henry David Thoreau, Mahatma Gandhi, and Martin Luther King Jr. Civil disobedience is the breaking of a law that is believed to be unjust. It is a,“form of sociopolitical…

the course of history, human beings have seemed to have a yearning for their fair organization in their communities. However, as communities evolved into societies there seemed to be a clear division amongst citizens: the law abiders and the criminals. Different societies and cultures eventually assigned punishments to crimes committed that seemed fit to the circumstances, ranging from theft to murder. Many would agree progressive countries in today’s modern world have modified different…