Collins Hiring Process

Improved Essays
The rigor of the hiring process that Collins (2001) covers in Good to Great is what sets good companies apart from great companies. The hiring process is never an easy process from either perspective the interviewer or the interviewee. Trying to get to know gauge how people will fit among an existing team is a difficult task for any manager. As hiring is a difficult task, Collins brought up three practical disciplines to ensure that you hire “great” employees and not just good employees. The first of these practical approaches that Collins (2001) conveys that a manager should know about is, “when in doubt, don’t hire” (p. 54). What sets great companies apart from good companies is their ability to attract and retain the best people for the …show more content…
56). When you as a manager realize that there is an employee that is the wrong fit for a role, act. It could be as simple as finding them a new role within the organization or unfortunately terminating them from the company. When you let the wrong people sit in the wrong position for too long, you as a manager lose credibility with your employees and inevitably your employees will lose the motivation to excel. Employees can see that they have a co-worker that is not pulling their share of the weight and as a result the rest of the team is forced to pick up their weight and you as a manager have sat idly by and done nothing. Great companies realize that people may not be in the right role and quickly identify the situation the work with an employee to find the great fit for them. Which is some cases may take a few attempts, or unfortunately if the employee is just not the right fit for the organization you may have no other choice but to let them find a new opportunity to flourish outside of the organization. Overall, don’t wait to make decisions. Just because a decision may be difficult, uncomfortable, or strain your team resources, don’t wait. You would have lost more credibility as a manager due to waiting than if you had just acted when you realized you had a …show more content…
58). In short, this means that your most successful employees should be placed in roles that challenge them and help them to grow as an employee. If you have an area of the business that you are looking to grow or expand because it is currently only a small fraction of your portfolio, you must present them with the challenge to grow the business because you know their potential based on past performance. As a manager it is crucial to communicate that this is a reward as they have shown great leadership and you’re placing a great deal of trust in that employee for their success in the role. Sometimes great employees don’t make the most money for an organization, but they are able to grow their share of the business into a profitable larger stake within the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Management Style Analysis

    • 3751 Words
    • 16 Pages

    The manager wants things done just like it’s told without any questions, says Jackson (2013). He includes this may make skilled workers full of ideas feel resentful. It can also make less skilled workers always rely on you for an answer, never developing their skills. As you can see this style can generate either a positive or a negative outcome. Autocratic management could lead to employees losing motivation because they have no say in what is happening in the company, they are not able to be innovative or intuitive.…

    • 3751 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most of us have been there. You just landed that job you’ve been hoping for, but on your first day when you’re trying to learn the ins-and-outs of the new job, your manager is completely useless. Your boss either doesn’t understand your area of work, or completely lacks the ability to explain your duties and provide training. Incompetent bosses can be detrimental not only to your life and work, but they can also have a lasting negative impact on your career. When inept bosses misdirect you in your job, it creates extra work and it also potentially points the blame to you, which might even cause you to get fired.…

    • 812 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1). Mr. Span identifies the issues that a lack of trust in leadership can impact their employee’s performance. According to Mr. Span (2015), “Trust is the foundation of any successful relationship, both personal and professional, and when it’s broken, it is extremely hard to repair. When employees feel they can’t trust leadership they feel unsafe, like no one has their back, and then spend more energy on self-preservation and job hunting than performing at their job” (p. 1). The company then experiences high turnover and a lack of growth from a lack of high performance.…

    • 781 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When all these negative points add up for an employee, they lose motivation to want to succeed in the company. This scenario is very unfortunate because now Joe blames these actions on the supervisors who were supposed to do a better job than how Joe would have liked them to do. A company culture like this where the workers were scared of telling the supervisors feedback just meant that they could not take feedback. This is a perfect example of why Joe should fire the two supervisors since they are not willing to improve and also assume they know everything about the role, which they clearly do not. Joe needs to go back to the drawing board and manage the team he hired himself like he used to.…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ineffectiveness of a manager tends to reflect in low employee productivity, limited contentment and increased drive to leave the company. Whenever an employee considers their relationship with the manager to be limiting and poisonous, the only option usually available is to move on…

    • 1274 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Most if not all employees feel as though some people should not be in management positions due to lack of experience, lack of respect for subordinates beneath them, or too much micromanaging or lack thereof. Poor leadership can lead to failure to produce proper productivity from an employee. According to (Johnson & Media, 2016) “micromanaging and dictating to employees instead of motivating them can cause a decrease in employee productivity”. Once an employee feels as though their voice is not heard or being taking seriously; their morale for the job and their work deteriorates. Respect in the workplace gives employees the morale to work even harder to maintain their ratings (Oscar, 2015).…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Low Morale

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Be sure not to jump to conclusions and misdiagnose employees as people with low morale, for they might just be having an off day. In order to indicate an employee has low morale is through a series of patterns of through both behaviours and attitudes over time. As the manager of the company there is a great deal of “tells” that you should be able to identify within the company that could cause low morale. For example if employees see that there is no room for growth within the company it’s likely the worker will not be motivated to put extra effort into their work, and could easily be discouraged and disloyal to the company. This means that the company could lose valuable employees to a competitor which would be a sad site in our eyes.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Perfect Pottery Case Study

    • 2008 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Both the employee and employer are being impacted in a couple of ways. The problem employees would face with having poor morale is it would be hard for them to get a job and easy for them to get fired. It’s just not a good idea to have bad attitude at work, it doesn’t help anything in the business. It’s okay if employers are mean sometimes to their employees to let them know that they need to start doing a better job. Employers would need to start getting on their employees so that way they know that they’ve been rude to the rest of their…

    • 2008 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hobby Lobby Case Study

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Hobby Lobby may have difficulty pinning down the source of their management issues; however, Hobby Lobby must deal with the situation before it results in negative publicity and their business is hurt in the long run. Managers must make more of an attempt to reconcile employee issues. According to Glassdoor.com, bleak reviews show the main problem with the Hobby Lobby management system is favoritism. Unfair managers give better hours to employees they like and if the company’s sales are not successful managers often cut full-time workers’ hours down to those of part time work. Other employee reviews expressed disdain for being talked down to when seeking management assistance concerning store problems.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Wal-Mart is doing their best to keep most part-time or temporary associates to eliminate most of their fulltime associates. What has changed at work? The happy work atmosphere has changed. Associates no longer enjoy their jobs. They feel as, if they are working a production line.…

    • 1660 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays