Nursing Incivility Case Study

Superior Essays
Nurse to Nurse Incivility and How it Affects Performance
Clinical Question
Problem description The nursing profession has high rates of cases of incivility among the profession. Uncivil behavior at the workplace entails violence at the workplace, intimidation, withholding of critical information, public humiliation and intimidation and stealing credit for work not done (Casale, 2017). Despite the nursing profession being based on ethics and values of respect and integrity, it has been reported that more than eighty-five percent of registered nurses were victims of nursing workplace incivility (Casale, 2017). Nursing incivility has severe impacts on the affected nurses and the quality of care that is provided to the patients (Casale, 2017).
…show more content…
The world health organization classifies it a severe threat to the health of the public and affects the safety of the patients (Laschinger, 2014). It also affects the productivity of the affected nurses which has severe implications for the safety of the patients and the quality of care of the patients (Laschinger, 2014). A study done by Kerber et al. reported that incivility in the nursing profession is rampantly spreading and has serious implications for new nurses in the field. The issue caused significant distress to the victims as it causes depression anxiety and stress and affects their overall performance (Kerber et al., 2015). The study confirmed that nursing incivility towards others nurses compromised the patient care by delaying and impeding the work done by the victims of incivility (Kerber et al., …show more content…
The study also showed the effect of the issue on patients’ safety due to the compromised performance of the affected nurses (Kerber et al., 2015). The findings were based on the thematic classification of the responses from the participants.
The study by Casale demonstrates the effects of leadership on reducing incivility and its impacts on performance by statistically illustrating the inverse relationship between the two variables. Using the evidence matrix table and detailed analysis of the research, the purpose of interpreting the two articles is achieved.
The next step for our group project will be to compile all the individual articles and choose the most relevant articles that to our clinical question. Another task that we can do as a group will be thoroughly searching the articles to identify the articles which will provide the most evidence to understand the nursing issue of incivility and its impacts.

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Lateral violence can occur at any time, with the surveys being disseminated quarterly the nurse may forget minor lateral violence occurrences or down play an incident that occurred a month or so ago. The sample focuses on nurses in Intensive Care Units within two contrasting healthcare organizations. This small sample will limit the results. A lack of diversity within the sample may also limit the study. Participants may also be a limitation as nurses tend to transfer in and out of units on a regular basis. Some nurses leave the profession all together. With the duration of the study being a yearlong process, this may impair the data. Time may also become a limitation as it is a known fact that nurses are sometimes so busy they are unable to use the bathroom let alone complete a survey. This is also why the surveys will not be distributed more than quarterly. Lastly, perception of an occurrence of lateral violence may vary between…

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When a group or team is put together, it is each individual’s duty to put an effort into upholding these traits. But, when if even one individual promotes incivility or exhibits negative behaviors, it prevents the entire group of further achieving a goal. Without the full cooperation of each individual the group will be unable to strive further or become successful at the task at hand. An example of negative actions of one person affecting an entire group can be how nurses often treat each other those of experience towards those who are new to the career. This is expressed in the photo to the left where a more experienced nurse is mocking a new nurse and pointing out how they aren’t smart enough to realize they made a mistake. This is uncivil behavior that needs to be changed in order to maintain a healthy work environment. This is described in Stopping the Culture of Workplace Incivility in Nursing when the author states, “Nurses will have to work together to ensure that communication between veteran nurses, new graduates or novice nurses, and other members of the healthcare team is collegial, respectful, and helpful” (Khadjehturian, 2012, p. 639). This illustrates how without the respect and civil behavior occurring throughout all members of the healthcare team, that proper patient care is unable to be performed. Although the actions of one individual seem to be…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Horizontal Violence

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages

    2).Moreover, horizontal violence has an impact on patient care and would likely be the cause of errors and mistakes (Anderson,2011,p.28) and would be the reason for ineffective communication , thereby, compromising the patient’s safety (Granstra,2015,p.254). I also believe that as graduate registered nurses, they should be familiar with professional boundaries and their scope of practice , to avoid role confusion that results to fertile background for bullying, harassment and miscommunication regarding division of responsibilities (Eagar, Cowin,Gregory,& Firtko, 2010,p. 94).For me, I have often wondered how should I respond to situations where lateral violence is present. I also thought about what appropriate actions should I take if this happens to me or to my co-workers. From the discussions and the strategies we developed in the toolkit (Appendix A) . I now know what my responsibilities as a GRN are in relation to horizontal violence. As part of the healthcare team, I must be knowledgeable about my professional boundaries and the policies that govern professional conduct in my workplace and be able to take actions upon horizontal violence by being assertive. (Becher, &…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Horizontal violence has become a way too familiar in the nursing profession (Weinand, M. R. (2010). Approximately 80% of nurses stated being bullied and around 75% have been harassed or been the victims of aggressive and intimidating behaviours during their careers (Hader, 2008; Hutchinson, Wilkes, Jackson, & Vickers, 2010). Horizontal violence can be defined as …………..The Joint Commission notes that in an unhealthy environment where nurses and nursing students are the victims of horizontal violence their level of stress is higher, they have a decrease in job satisfaction, and clinical outcomes are compromised (2008). When the environment is unhealthy it can increase costs of caring for patients due to medical errors and will…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Workplace violence is a serious issue in healthcare and the causes are multifaceted and varied. Violence is not only limited to physical abuse, but verbal and emotion abuse as well. Over the years, there have been many committees that have proposed different guidelines and legislation to combat this issue. Seeking solutions to this issue must involve a multidisciplinary effort and the use of evidence based interventions. Specifically in nursing, management and leadership is important for the safety of the patients and staff.…

    • 1543 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Horizontal violence can have an effect on the quality of patient care as nursing is a team effort. The patient may not receive the quality of care due because of the horizontal violence victim being afraid to communicate with other members of the treatment team due to the feeling of low…

    • 216 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Certified Nursing Aide

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages

    While civility builds a healthy environment, incivility breaks an environment. In the workplace, especially a hospital, whether a patient or co-worker, people always come and go. So the environment constantly changes. Though in some cases this may result in a positive outcome, in others, it opens up room for conflict. New employees often create bias and prejudiced in the working environment. Each team formulates opinions about the other, the judge without facts, and favor one team or style over another. The new employee perceives the old as feeble, inferior to their new and high-tech way, and the old see the new as hazardous. This impacts communication, interpersonal relationships, and overall professionalism, thus affecting how the hospital or station functions. In this case study, due to the opinions and gossip, created the four new RN’s, it brought distraction and confusion. Also, their behavior influenced others to portray the same character causing separation of the young and old. A study conducted by the Iranian Red Crescent Medical Journal states, a person’s emotional state, has the ability to affect the quality of service given… and job satisfaction. Meaning, your demeanor affects the way you perform your job. As a hospital employee, your job is to provide mental, physical, and emotional care to patients. In doing that, there needs to be communication (between and…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Horizontal violence in workplace has significant effects on new graduate nurses, the patients, the organisation and even nursing profession. It not only threatens new nurses' physical and mental wellbeing; but also impact patient outcomes. Horizontal violence is also an important contributing factor that causes the low retention rate of new nurses. Actions should be taken to eliminate horizontal violence in workplace in order to maintain the wellbeing of new nurses and preserve the precious nursing human resources. Strategies like cognitive rehearsal, transition program, authentic leadership, mentorship programs have showed effects on prevent and reduce horizontal violence. The targets, witness of the horizontal violence, the unit manager and…

    • 135 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The problem of interest that I chose to discuss is lateral violence (LV) in nursing. LV is a deliberate and harmful behavior demonstrated in the workplace by one employee to another, it is a significant problem in the nursing profession…LV is the same thing as bullying someone. Studies estimate that 44% to 85% of nurses are victims of LV; up to 93% of nurses report witnessing LV in the workplace.Lv can affect the victims physical health and mental health, it can also affect patient care and safety, is also detrimental to the work environment. Because LV is often perpetrated by nurse managers and directors, it can be difficult to report.…

    • 762 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gantz, F. D., Levy, H., Khalaial, R., Arad, D., Bennaroch, K., Kolpak, O., ... Raanan, O. (2015, August 11). Bullying and Its Prevention Among Intensive Care Nurses. Journal of nursing scholarship, 47(6), 505-511. Retrieved from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com.ezproxy.ttuhsc.edu/doi/10.1111/jnu.12167/pdf…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When asked to describe nurses, the public may use words such as “kind”, “caring” and “healing”; however a peek behind the curtain of a career that requires so many positive attributes, may lead to the discovery of behaviors that go against the ethical duties of nursing. This troublesome issue is commonly known as horizontal violence. Horizontal Violence may be defined as ““hostile, aggressive, and harmful behavior by a nurse or group of nurses towards a coworker or group of nurses via attitudes, actions, words and/or behaviors” (Becher, & Visovsky, 2012). Other words used to refer to this issue include “lateral violence”, “bullying” or “nurses eating their young”. This behavior is of increasing interest because all nurses are susceptible to…

    • 1995 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Incivility In Nursing

    • 206 Words
    • 1 Pages

    My concerns related to a relational aggression and incivility in nursing is the way it impacts my patient. Being a victim of relational aggression and incivility can be costly to organizations. Nurses put in less effort, produce lower quality, and can even burn out. incivility is a safety issue, and issued a standard on intimidating and disruptive behaviors at work. Relational…

    • 206 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the American Association of Critical Care Nurses, “eighty percent of medical errors are actually caused by communication and coordination problems amongst medical team members” (Munro & Savel, 2015, p. 372). One of the biggest challenges for registered nurse, Karen, was learning how to communicate in a high stress, face-paced cardiovascular intensive care unit. The CVICU, according to Karen, “attracts strong personalities; whom which are confident and pushy especially when you are starting out and do not know much,” (personal communication, October 1, 2015). Sometimes their intentions can be misinterpreted or come off mean, but they are just being themselves and that’s the environment these people are attracted to. For Karen, a line had to be drawn when her preceptor humiliated her in front of a patient and the patient’s family. Being shamed for not knowing the right answer is a type of bullying in the workplace among co-workers termed lateral violence. According to Potter (2013), lateral violence “has an adverse effect on the work environment, leading to job satisfaction, poor retention of qualified nurses, nurses leaving the profession, and poor teamwork” (p. 316). Lateral violence in the workplace affects patient care because it “decreases the likelihood that a nurse will report a near-miss, question an order, or take action to improve the quality of patient care” (Potter, 2013, p. 316). In order for a patient to receive the best outcome, healthcare providers need to learn how to respect each other and brainstorm more efficient ways to communicate as a…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Lateral Violence Essay

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Behaviors that often accompany lateral violence continue to be a current problem in the literature for over 20 years” (Embree, 2010). As described in literature, “the origin of LV refers to a phenomenon known as relational aggression which can be defined as any behavior that is anticipated to hurt an individual by damaging or manipulating relationships with other individuals” (Simmons, 2003). Actions related to relational aggression are most often driven to overtly isolate the targeted individual while also increasing the social rank of the oppressor. Current research shows that the average percentage of voluntary nurse turnover in general is 8.4% and for first year nurses this average increases to 27.1% (Stanley, 2007). The financial side of lateral…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A few years ago, I responded to an article published by a nursing school in the mid-west stating that we needed to stand up for ourselves as a profession and assertively demand civility with each other to expand the nursing profession. I responded and described how nurses can be bullies to each other, and standing up for oneself can make your situation worse. The requirements in nursing in the hospital means taking care of patients with higher acuity, administering many more complicated medications, monitoring procedures that may require conscious sedation or medication drips, along with completing tasks such as cleaning patients and beds, cleaning rooms and being responsible for nutrition and feedings. Because there is not enough staff on the unit, nurses group together to try and maintain an "easier" day. Especially a group of charge nurses protecting each other when interchanging responsibilities. Many times one or two nurses are bullied because someone has to take care of the more complicated patients that need total care. And if you complain, it makes it worse; the patient assignments are patients no one else wants. Those who are bullying convince the management that those who are being bullied, somehow deserve it. Following my response, the nursing school called me and stated 95,000 nurses responded with the same scenarios and explanations in bullying.…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays