Argumentative Speech On Tablets Vs Textbooks

Improved Essays
Topic: Tablets vs. Textbooks
Specific Purpose: To persuade my audience schools should consider using tablets instead of textbooks in K-12 schools.
Thesis Statement: Tablets help students learn better than textbooks.
I. Introduction
A. Attention Material/Credibility Material: According to the FCC, schools spend more than $8 billion dollars on outdated textbooks a year. This has become a major problem.
B. Tie to the audience: With all the outrageous expenses including paper, ink, and technical support costs that go towards printing textbooks, schools should consider using tablets instead of textbooks for students to use. Buying tablets would make it more affordable and convenient for schools to receive new information with digital textbooks.
…show more content…
Top K-12 publishers such as McGraw-Hill, Pearson Education, and Houghton Mifflin Harcourt who are responsible for most of the K-12 content in the U.S. are creating textbooks that are available now on the iPad.
a. Digital textbooks contain many hi-tech features that cannot be found in textbooks such as the ability to highlight and edit text, write notes without ruining the book for the next student, and a built-in dictionary.
b. Digital textbooks are much less expensive than textbooks. For example, McGraw-Hill offers more than 900 of their textbooks in digital form and for 50 percent less.
3. Tablets allow teachers to better customize learning. There are thousands of educational apps for students to use, so teachers can complement different learning styles. There are more than 20,000 education apps available on the iPad alone. a. For students with disabilities, the App Store on the iPad has an amazing collection of apps for every need — from sign language and communication to life skills.
B. Tablets will help prevent backpack-related injuries.
1. Backpack-related injuries are caused by overloaded backpacks, as well as lifting and carrying them incorrectly. Students are carrying more than 15-20 pounds of books and other school supplies in their
…show more content…
Doctors recommend that students carry less than 15% of their body weight in a backpack, but the combined average weight of textbooks exceeds this percentage.
C. Tablets increases motivation and creativity among students in the classroom.
1. When using tablets instead of textbooks, it gives students a reason to take part in something fun and motivating.
2. It was determined that 77% of teachers found that using tablets increases motivation and engages students to focused to learn better.
3. Also, tablets help students better prepare for a world that uses creativity for everything.
III. Conclusion
A. Brakelight/Transition: Teachers feel as though tablets are a huge distraction in the classroom. Students would feel the need to go on to websites such as Facebook or Pinterest. However, all schools would have to do is block these websites.
B. Summary: Schools should replace textbooks with tablets in K-12 schools. Tablets will help students improve their learning by providing hundreds of digital textbooks and educational apps, prevents backpack-related injuries, and increases motivation and

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    “PBS Kids, in partnership with the US Department of Education, found that the vocabulary of kids ages three to seven who played its Martha Speaks mobile app improved up to 31%” (Lynch). It is clear that certain applications can help students learn, but the use of this technology also helps students focus. “When self-reporting, 54% of students say they get more involved in classes that use technology and 55% say they wish instructors used more educational games or simulations to teach lessons” (Lynch). Students get more involved in lessons when they are using technology, which is important. Let alone the thousands of free applications that provide lessons and practice that can help the student’s learning.…

    • 713 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tablets can show progress reports to teachers and parents allowing them to see where the student is needing help or is succeeding. As Logan mentions in her article, researchers suggest that tablets and apps can improve learning, improve test scores and students attendance. In a reading app students have scored higher and vocabulary scores have increased by more than 20 percent (Logan). This has shown how learning on a tablet has been effective. Teachers also have concerns about the tablets.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission reports that backpack-related injuries sent more than 7,000 people to the emergency room in 2001 alone” (“Backpack ...”). It would be better for students to carry only one tablet instead of heavy textbooks in their backpacks. People would argue that if schools provide tablets to students, then it will cost even more for the technology and electric bill. However, printing all the homework assignments and buying textbooks for students every year will cost more money than to buy tablets for students. In New York times, Daniel Brenner, the Roslyn superintendent, said that “the iPads would also save money in the long run by reducing printing and textbook costs; the estimated savings in the two iPad classes are $7,200 a year”…

    • 818 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It would also lighten the load of books and paper work students have to carry to and from school. Technology today has far exceeded our expectations. With it being in almost every household, why aren’t we using it at school? Tablets should replace textbooks because they can easily be updated with current information, and they eliminate the need for carrying heavy textbooks to and from school. Tablets are able to store many different types of media, as well as assignments that could get lost if left floating around in a school bag.…

    • 1392 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    High School textbooks have an average cost of $70 each. This means that if Jefferson City School would have purchased a textbook instead, it would have costed them $140,000 (Hilgedick,Kris, Textbooks vs. tablets: Schools begin exploring transformation in learning tools, News Tribune). When a school uses a tablet, they would also need to purchase other things with the tablet. Some of the important things are the purchase of hardware and software. Generally, the Apple server software cost about $19.99(True Cost for Ipad Program,Think Write).…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Approximately 81 percent of U.S teachers think tablets can enrich classroom learning, and 86 percent of students believe that tablets can help them to study more efficiently. In just one year, test scores of children that use technology in classrooms have increased by 20 percent (“Use of Technology”). Technology affects everyday life for everyone in the world. It is everywhere and it is beneficial in schools and helps children learn how to work at their own pace. Not only does technology give positive effects in education, but it also helps kids be more independent and learn how to be more responsible.…

    • 1187 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Think about a textbook that is customized for each student’s needs and interests and includes opportunities for interactive practice and collaboration with others. That is the potential of tablets” (Karen). iPads and tablets should be included into the learning of a student even though there could be some major future issues. Tablets are the tool of the future because modern technology is evolving and opening opportunities of doing work faster. In school, tablets can help hold over hundreds of textbooks on one device, including worksheet handouts, homework, quizzes and tests, and other educational files, eliminating the need for books and classroom materials.…

    • 2283 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    87% of responders had a positive reaction saying that using tablets “improves understanding of topics, digital skills, creativity, independent learning and motivation” (“Digital Tablets Improve Classroom Learning”). Marquès also discovered that 73% of students used the tablets at home, and the use of tablets took up 30% of weekly classroom time. Lastly, Marquès realized that 45% of the technology used was owned by students (“Digital Tablets Improve Classroom…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Providing Technology to Students Imagine walking around for seven hours, with a textbook for almost every class along with notebooks and binders to go along with it. It was found that students are carrying backpack loads that weigh 15% more than their actual body weight (“Study: School Backpacks Too Heavy”). This can damage the body along with their posture. If these physical textbooks are replaced with digital textbooks on computers or iPads, that will take off a great load of weight, thus improving children’s health. Education systems all across the country are switching to digital textbooks and electronics to replace paper textbooks.…

    • 1644 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    the Leading Education by Advancing Digital (LEAD) Commission, has already revealed that moving to a more digital model for student textbooks... will save schools about $250 per student per year, adding up to over $12.2 billion per year if fully implemented (MacNN Staff).” The transition from textbooks to tablets has been proven to be extremely efficient, especially since tablets can constantly update textbook versions unlike textbooks. Schools would be saving several thousands of dollars if tablets are purchased rather than paper textbooks. “Electronic books obviously cost less than their print versions, meaning the same amount of money can be used to buy more textbooks. With billions of dollars being spent on textbooks annually, the cost savings benefits here is obvious. Even though the initial price of a tablet may be prohibitive, they are not that expensive and their prices are continually falling (Schumacher).” As tablets are becoming more popular throughout the country, the prices are drastically decreasing due to the high demand of supply.…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays