Argumentative Commercial Analysis: Haagen-Daz's Argument Commercial

Improved Essays
Haagen-Dazs Argument Commercial Reflection Paper

The commercial starts with an Italian man entering his home with some groceries and flowers. He says “Hello, my love” in Italian. The skinny Italian woman in the kitchen turns around and smashes a dish to the ground. She yells out “I’m leaving” in Italian with which the man responds “Not again”. The woman then proceeds to throw down the towel in her arm onto the floor. The floor already has pieces of the broken dish. She walks closer to him and yells out “I’m going to find a man who can love someone beside himself” accompanying it with hand gestures. The man and woman keep getting closer and closer to each other’s face. The man yells out “Go live with your mother, she’s the only one crazy enough
…show more content…
The commercial seems to rely on a negative stereotype about Italian-Americans such as that they are loud and aggressive especially when they are fighting. The woman is not only screaming at the top of her lungs but she breaks a dish onto the floor and proceeds to throw down a towel that she was using. Italians are also known to use a lot of hand gestures especially when they are talking and the commercial reflects that with the woman waving her arms around and the man doing a lot of pointing. While the commercial does rely on negative stereotypes, it did have some positive reflection on Italian-American culture such as family. It is not a single person experiencing the gelato but a couple. The couple reflected the tension between the couple, but also made sure to show their unification due to gelato. Food is another vital concept to Italian-Americans. Many Italian-Americans gather at the table daily to eat their meal instead of eating separately and at different times. They believe that food is best when it shared especially with one’s family. Overall, the commercial heavily emphasized that the couple was Italian that makes sense considering that gelato is Italian in origin and Haagen-Dazs is a New York-based company. In order for people to overlook the fact that the company isn’t Italian, they tried to emphasize that Italians enjoyed their gelato even when Americans made it. Haagan-Dazs used Italian with English subtitles and …show more content…
First, there is the producer’s preferred reading that subscribes to the dominant values, trends, and norms of society. The producer’s preferred reading is that the viewer should buy Haagen-Dazs gelato in order for it to provide unity in the viewer’s family like the man in the commercial. Apparently, the sight and taste of their gelato is so good that it will fight all of the fights that occur in a person’s family. Second, there is the dominant reading of the viewer when a viewer fully accepts the message that the commercial is trying to portray. The viewer’s dominant reading is that they should also buy Haagen-Dazs gelato because the gelato could help bring my family together by stopping the fights that happen on a daily basis. Third, there is the negotiated reading of the viewer where the viewer only partially shares and accepts the dominant value. The negotiated reading for this commercial would be that while food can bring a family together after a fight, my family won’t stop arguing simply because I bought some gelato. Finally, there is the oppositional reading which understands the dominant values but advocates for an alternative. The oppositional reading would be that while some fights between family members can be resolved with food, most fights will not. The gelato is a temporary bandage and if the fight does not get

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Making another suggestion shows that you aren 't just there to stand around and take orders but to show that you care about their needs. Once new drinks are brought to the table remind your guest about any dinner specials occurring and always suggest three of your favorite entrée 's because they want to know what 's good and what 's not. When describing a dinner entrée, the same formula when suggesting appetizers should be used. Use words such as savory when describing a steak topped with a caramelized onion sauce or juicy when suggesting a burger. When dinner is ready to be served be sure to always serve children first because they are always the hungriest followed by women and men.…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each of them has its own benefits and costs. In the case of Weight Watchers, the company provides purchasable dinner, snacks, and desserts. Also, customers are taught on how to control food portion and allowed to select their own foods. However, the customers must pay for the membership and the food. Time is also wasted because it is said that the most successful member is to attend the group sessions and meetings.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Then have typical conflict scenarios and observe the nonverbal language displayed: It is dinnertime and you want to go out and eat sushi but your partner wants Italian, how would you typically solve this issue? One partner always does more household chores than he other; how would you ask your partner to help more? One partner spends more money but at the end of the month the funds barely pay the bills, how would you discuss this with your partner? These experiments can show an insight of the participant’s relationship and dynamics; by observing how they communicate it would be easy to identify their nonverbal decoding and encoding skills. The scenarios and questionnaire will give an opportunity to measure the relationship between effective nonverbal communication skills and relational satisfaction.…

    • 893 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mod Pizza Case Study

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Each pizza is given individual treatment, which creates a connection with each consumer, because the brand cares about the outcome of each individual’s experience versus cooking in mass conveyer belt style. Although it may be quicker and more convenient, it chooses to produce each pizza individually to build relationships and consumer loyalty. Much like Chipotle, Mod is passionate about where its food comes from, it is environmentally conscious, and it is mindful of animal ethics as well (Mod Pizza About us). Mod only does business with suppliers that are just as passionate about their product and the process of processing as it…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Because Oreos have been around for over a hundred years, the marketers who create advertisements have taken advantage of Oreo’s seniority in the food business in sending the message that Oreo as a friend that has always been there to save our unappetizing lunches. Also, the advertisement consists of logical appeal because of the phrase "Two biscuit snack pack. Ideal for lunchboxes" (Nabisco). The people in charge of the advertisement know that parents are constantly busy with their daily schedules, so the advertisement basically claims that it will make parents ' lives easier because anyone can grab a pack of Oreos and toss them in their child 's lunchbox. The juxtaposition of the scrumptious chocolate vanilla creamed cookie and the joyful lunchbox make Oreos extremely tempting to purchase.…

    • 1996 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    So why not just cook at home, it may take up a little more time but it would be worth it and your body will appreciate it later. David Zinczenko, “ Don’t Blame the Eater.” states that “Fast-food companies are marketing to children a product with proven health hazards and no warning labels.” meaning fast food companies know that these young adults are so vulnerable and will eat just about anything if it 's right there in front of them. Which isn 't the right thing to do on these companies part, Businesses should step in and collaborate with the fast food companies in to making the food more healthier, and say what 's really in the food being produced and sold world-wide. Some companies put extra chemicals into their…

    • 1758 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cheez-itz are that perfect snack with just enough cheese to hold off that mid-afternoon craving. The ad did its job which was to make me hungry and show both a common sense, and humorous side of what it was trying to sell. From pathos we see the emotional appeal with mainly joking fun as a normally inanimate object telling jokes to an inspector. This can affect how much attention is actually given to the ad just by incorporating comedy. In addition the viewer also sees the logical side or logos side as we want real and matured cheese for our cheez-itz and nothing else.…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Zinczenko believes that with the lawsuits against the fast-food industry, the fast-food industry should fix their problems so people can make informed choices about their products and parents will be informed of how much calories their children are eating. In my view, it is the parents who are to be blamed for their children’s obesity, not the fast-food industry. Although many parents work long hours, there are other alternatives besides eating fast food. There are many restaurants or places where you can eat for an affordable price besides fast food chains. Furthermore, food can be prepare in advance so the children can eat it at a later time.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In China’s collectivistic culture, it is important to maintain harmony; thus direct confrontation should be avoided. However, it is the opposite in the US’s individualistic culture, where speaking one’s mind is a characteristic of an honest person and individuals are expected to have learned to take direct feedback constructively (Hofstede, 229-236). These different ways of communicating cause cultural misunderstandings and this can be clearly seen in The Joy Luck Club. One example is when Waverly’s boyfriend Rich meets her family for the first time. At dinner, Lindo serves a “steamed pork and preserved vegetable dish” which is her specialty and she always serves it “with special pride” (178).…

    • 1919 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The culinary triangle that Levi-Strauss explains to us help us to better understand the society in which food was prepared. In my family I can see the blend of the old and the new. On those rare occasions that a traditional Italian meal has been prepared, I feel the old world influences even when it is done in a more modern fashion. But for the most part, my analysis shows that I eat in a traditional American way, which is quick and fast and without any regard or concern for the preparation. This is the direct reflection that I see American food and food preparation having on American…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays