Tracy And Thia Cooper Analysis

Improved Essays
Both Steven Tracy and Thia Cooper deal with the issues of abortion though they stand on opposing sides. Where Tracy announces his pro-life stands Cooper vocalizes her support for legal abortion. In theory the two authors should disagree on most points, but this fails to be the case. Both argue that the main problem camouflaged within this debate remains the social injustice society inflicts upon its mortal pawns. Both find faults with the entire abortion debate not just the opposing opinion, and both spend time criticizing both the pro-life and the pro-choice arguments. Many of the critiques make the same points and most of their evidence builds beautiful off the others article. In fact, the only point of contention appears to be their personal …show more content…
There were many points made throughout both articles that I agree greatly with. The first being when Cooper say, “Because of the history of oppression of women and of women of colour in particular, abortion has a much broader impact than simply on whether to end the pregnancy” (Cooper, 233). Abortion does not just affect the pregnant women and the unborn child, but this fact often gets overlooked. Because of the neglect of this fact many other political issues and social injustices that abortion impact gets forgotten in the shuffle. Cooper later reintroduces this fact by stating, “A woman does not get pregnant alone and does not raise a child alone” (Cooper, 239). Whether the woman decides to keep the child or not the lives of all those around her as well as any lives that may come in contact with her or her child are affected. Because of the large impact just one life can have society has a civic duty to support her which is an issues addressed in Tracy’s paper, “Social support is a pivotal and complex need often misunderstood by those who have little experience working with women facing an unwanted pregnancy” (Tracy, 31). Another issues that both Cooper and Tracy bring up with which I agree is, “Rather than aborting fetuses with a trait that is ‘not preferred’, could we rethink the way society prioritizes some over others?” (Cooper, 234). Tracy addresses this issue at the beginning of his article by stating, “‘Pro- life’ means the valuing of all human life whatsoever, giving particular attention to the care and protection of the weak and marginalized. Yet all too often it means ‘valuing only the lives I deem valuable’” (Tracy, 27). Cooper and Tracy bring to attention the issues of how

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    While others believe it is a sick and twisted way of not owning up to your problems. Since abortion is mostly discussed over opinions I cannot provide facts over whether it is moral or immoral. In hills like white elephants Jig has to decide for herself whether she believes abortion is right or if it is wrong. Abortion is an individual decision over beliefs someone withholds. But just as it says in this article by Robert P. George and Ramesh Ponnuru, Abortion is wrong and unjust, but neither the women who procure abortions nor the abortionists are typically acting out of malice.…

    • 2014 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author, Razib Khan, talks about the abortion stereotype and the differentiation between men and women. Of course things such as religion and politics also sway people 's opinions, but he still mentions that views have been altered over time. This article discusses how women feel more strongly towards pro-life, while men could care less. Some women feel strongly than other women, and the same with men. I find it unsuitable to mention that men and women, especially those with different backgrounds, to have completely opposing views.…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Roe V. Wade Case

    • 1961 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Although the outcome of the case made so it that abortion was legal for women in America, state government officials were allowed to decide whether or not abortion would be legal in the state they governed. This created more hoops to jump through for women who were seeking abortions, especially when states severely limited access to the reproductive health care of women. However, making abortion illegal did not end the practice of them; many illegal abortions were performed then. Women knew about the severe danger and possibility of death when receiving an abortion during this time, yet many women still did seek abortions. Similarly today, access to abortion and reproductive health care for women is limited and controlled by the state more so the decision made during Roe versus Wade, which should not be the case.…

    • 1961 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    American women have a gift of growing up with little to no limitations; however, women from other cultures cannot say the same. Women in other cultures cannot get a decent education, cannot drive or possess anything under their name. In some cases, women don’t even have the right to feel pleasure because in some cultures female genital mutilation is prevalent. These are just a few of their worries. There are countries where Honorary Killings are not only allowed, they are encouraged!…

    • 1833 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abortion: Pro Life

    • 2004 Words
    • 9 Pages

    I do think that all abortion is wrong, but my dogma is mostly targeted at those who have an abortion because they made a wrong choice and simply do not want the child. I think that the lines would become more difficult to determine in a situation where I or someone I love was pregnant and had no say in the matter. Experiences test our…

    • 2004 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a modern world the issue of abortion is one of the most controversial because people usually have opposite views about it. From one point of view, abortion is considered to be a sin, murder, and it is condemned. They feel as though each human has a right to live. From the other side, people recognize the right of a woman to manage her body, her life and to decide to birth a baby or not. Some people consider a fetus to be a rightful human being that should be respected, and some people are sure that during the initial stages of pregnancy, a few cells cannot be considered as a real human, and that’s why abortion should be allowed.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion Term Paper In every topic there is always two different sides which are the pros and the cons, one group is for it and one group is not. Abortion is a heavy topic that many people have an opinion about. Abortion is the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy, most likely in the first twenty one weeks, which some people do not abide by and sometimes is after the said time. Is abortion a bad thing or not? I feel that there is no right or wrong way to feel about it because everyone is different and has been through different things and situations to make them feel the way that they do pertaining to abortion.…

    • 1266 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To a person who is pro choice the argument that relies on this view is that the zygote is not a human being and that it is not considered a real life. The argument is that a clump of cells isn’t necessarily a living life, instead just a cell. A person who is a pro choice would also argue that if a girl was rape she has 100% of the right to have an abortion. Abortion is a right that many people fought to have it legalized. Though not every place allows an abortion many of the women who fought to have abortions still are looked as a role model to those woman who are not ready for motherhood.…

    • 867 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Why Is Abortion Important

    • 2868 Words
    • 12 Pages

    They claim that obviously there has to be come kind of after effect that women are enduring because of these abortions. Not to mention the unexpected repercussions of having so many abortions could damage the women body and possibly the ability to further reproduce. Although the argument presented by those who oppose abortion clearly has great substance and weight to it, it refuses to take into consideration several alternatives. First, although possibly more women are prone to abort more frequently, it is not as if they are making the decision against their will. And who is to say all women would go on an “abortion spree” now that they have the right to decided whether they want to keep the…

    • 2868 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion is a very heated topic. Throughout the United States, abortion is heavily advocated against due to various moral and ethical reasons. Anti-abortion media portrayal is also not uncommon, nor is it hard to find. N.L Stotland, a researcher who has been published in Archives of Women’s Mental Health, has performed several studies on abortion and the views surrounding it. In one study, he wrote, “A woman who aborts a pregnancy is perceived as wantonly and selfishly sexual” (27).…

    • 1866 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays