Ethical Controversy: The Same-Sex Marriage Debate

Decent Essays
Same-Sex marriage, this controversy has been going on for years, with a complex history. The problem with this falls within what people believe in. Those for same sex marriages usually are fighting for civil rights, while those against it are arguing for moral ethics. Congress should pass a law that would overturn the US Supreme Court same sex marriage decision, is the new debate regarding gay marriages. To understand all sides of the argument it’s essential to be aware of others beliefs. Those in favor of same sex marriage believe that “an individual’s sexual orientation- like a person’s race or gender- does not constitute a legitimate basis upon which to deny or withhold legal rights”(ethics book). Most of the allies of gay marriage, are …show more content…
Utilitarianism is a normative theory that we ought to concern ourselves with the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people. Homosexuals believe that by achieving marriage they will have a greater happiness, which makes up for the unhappiness of their opponents.
Opponents of gay marriage hold the view that gay marriages go against either religious or natural law. One of the theory that are held by some opponents are Divide Command Ethics, which is a theory that ethical norms are ultimately based upon the authoritative decrees of God. The bible says that a man and a women should marry to become one.
The different opinions about gay marriages, are not the only thing to be considered when thinking about whether or not Congress should act against the Supreme Court. Another import aspects, would have to be the history of gay rights in the United States. One of the earliest acts involving the case of gay marriage was signed into law by Bill Clinton, who was president at the time. The act was called the Federal Defense of Marriage Act. Clinton signed this act in 1996, which defined marriage as being between one man and one women. The act as stated that the word spouse only referred to a person of the opposite sex who is a husband or wife (ethics book). This law made it so that states didn’t have to recognize same sex marriages, or provide these couples with federal benefits. Some examples
…show more content…
Windsor case. The Court came to the conclusion that the act made it so that same sex couples, were less worthy than other couples, which made the act unfair. By treating people differently, it violated the due process rights that every citizen has.
Individual states have made their decisions about whether marriages of same sex should be allowed. California is an example, since The California Supreme Court ruled that gay marriages were constitutional. The opponents decided to ban together to get the proposition 8 included into law. Proposition 8 was all about putting the traditional definition of marriage into the California’s constitution (Schubert and Flint, 2015). Other states have also worked to modify their constitutions to either get same sex marriages ban or allowed.
In recent years, more politicians have spoken up for gay marriages. For example President Barack Obama made the statement “that the journey toward liberty and equality would not be complete until our gay brother and sisters are treated like anyone else under the law” (ethics book). Obama wanted to make the point that we are equal, and love should be equal as

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    The gay marriage debate is very controversial. Those against same-sex marriage often cite religious viewpoints and concerns about pro-creation. They argue that same-sex relationships are immoral and against God’s will. Those in favor of same-sex marriage often argue that mutual love is enough for people to get married, regardless of their sexual orientation. Christian groups who argue for same-sex marriage tend to believe that lesbian and gay people were created as such by God and should have the same right as others (History and Debate of Gay Marriage).…

    • 1804 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The fight for them was just beginning, but their battle would do much for the future of gay marriage. In fact, gay marriage changed from the pressure coming from people’s opinions on same-sex marriage, which prompted some states to change their laws, while others had chosen not to; the controversy caught the attention of the Supreme Court, and in time, was…

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Bennet, it goes over the different things that are in support against gay marriage. First, it talks about the Hawaii Supreme Court discovering the legal union of same-sex couples and says that Hawaii will become the first state to sanction the union of same-sex couples and that other states will follow. Next, it talks about a conservative argument, allowing marriage in order to promote faithfulness and monogamy, and says that that is an intelligent and politically shrewd argument. Also, Bennet says that he believes that overall allowing same-sex marriages would do significant, long-term social damage. It says that it would be the most far-reaching step ever to be taken in the deconstruction of society’s most important institution and that we should not take that step.…

    • 1241 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Gay marriage or same sex marriage is considered the union of two people of the same gender. It is one of the most popular, political and social issues of our time. Typically, those who support gay marriages argue that two people of the same sex have the right to be married and those who oppose argue that gay marriage is immoral and unconstitutional. It has been argued repeatedly about whether or not gay marriage should be legalized and accepted amongst society. This topic is so controversial it has gone far as being considered an infringement.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The hot topic I will be summarizing is the same-sex marriage. This video talks about two lawyers that once went against each other in the case of Bush v. Al Gore. Now there teaming up together to get same-sex marriage approved. This issue was brought up when California had passed the same-sex marriage bill. Certain people were not happy with it and sadly proposition 8 was formed.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    • Previously, the tradition still wary when talking about gay issues and gay marriage, the right day, the issue of gay received sympathy and encouragement from the mass media. The dahoat active in equal rights for homosexuals were the newspapers, TV channels reported regularly in an effort to call for the support of lawmakers and the public. • Legalization of gay marriage is something urgent. We want to create a fair society in all respects. That is, the gay and not gay people should have equal rights.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    1). People want marriage to be between a man and a woman but the government cannot define the word marriage. Same-sex couples feel discriminated by all the negatives they say about it. Many support the idea of civil unions rather than full marriage between gay couples. Civil unions are not fully equivalent to marriage and withdraw same sex couples of equal rights.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Hodges case landed in the hands of the United States Supreme Court (Chappell 1). This case’s decision would determine the national law on recognition of gay marriages (Chappell 1). Previously, the issue had been largely a state by state legislative decision, greatly polarizing the nation and resulting in many lawsuits where gay couples would marry in a state where gay marriage was legal and move to a location where their marriage was not recognized. On June 26, 2015, in a 5-4 final decision, the Supreme Court determined that all states shall recognize the legal marriage of same-sex couples (Chappell 1). One important piece of information to note in this decision is that this was in no way a sweeping victory within the Supreme Court.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Pro Homosexual Marriage

    • 1098 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Lots of individuals within the United States of America believe that gay marriage may be a sin or shouldn’t be legalized as a result of it wasn’t “god set up.” In the Article “Why "Gay Marriage" is Wrong” They state “Same-sex “marriage” destroys the integrity of true marriage by turning traditional marriage into a species within the marriage genus” The legalization of same-sex “marriage” and its placement on equal footing with traditional marriage subverts and destroys the latter.” With that being said the gay marriage is a human right according to Article “What are the reasons for and against gay marriage” and the United Nation of Human rights, “human rights are rights inherent to all human beings, regardless of gender, nationality, ethnic origin and religious view etc. Everyone has the same right and freedom to do what they want, as long as it does not cause harm to the society, and decision made by others should be respected. Gay marriage is the matter of civil and equal rights, and the decision to get married should belong to the couple in love, and this should not be regulated by the government.” Even though many of people around the world don 't seem to be comfortable with homosexual relationships, the equality and dignity of gay couples…

    • 1098 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Should Gay Marriage Be Legal? Introduction According to the ruling by the Supreme Court in the case Obergefell v. Hodgesin the United States, it is noted that the prohibition of same-sex matrimony is unlawful. Innately, the jury iterated that the Fourteenth Amendment provides equal protection through a due process that should be respected the judiciary, which should protect the rule of law. The United States has long experienced a struggle between people supporting each side of the argument since it is impossible to provide a compromise between them (Lipp). Importantly, the proponents of gay marriages indicate that the world, through its judicial systems, is attempting to limit their rights to wed. Contrastingly, the opponents of the act state that it is against natural law that advocates for heterosexual relationships.…

    • 1481 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays