Pros And Cons Of Federalism: The Right To Privacy

Improved Essays
When regulating the right to privacy, federalism faces certain limitations which include the following. First, the probability that it might lead to discrimination from a person’s skin color, race, religion or political affiliation is high (Bellia, 2008). People in positions of leadership at the state levels are likely to dominate those they lead by hiding critical information from them. Or stop and frisk policy require that the police detain suspects and sometimes even civilians temporarily for questioning and searching for weapons and other illegal materials (Avdija, 2014). This policy became very controversial because of the Floyd v. New York case where they prove the authorities where just stopping African Americans and Hispanic individuals …show more content…
The positive and negative impacts of federalism with regards to privacy rights are essential. For quite some time, we have fought to maintain our individuality which comes in the form of our privacy rights. We are made up of different cultures, and we have the right to privately or publicly conduct our traditions and not be told what to do. The Patriot Act makes privacy seems, not a right but a …show more content…
This means that the minority group’s interests are protected under civil rights, and they get to enjoy rights that the majority group enjoys (Horowitz, 2006). For instance, women who are majorly considered as minority groups have the right to abort under the civil rights provided the pregnancy has reached a particular stage. In the case Roe v. Wade where it established that women had the right to privacy that was adequately protected by due process and the choice to determine if they wanted to give birth. Roe has been deduced to prohibit the government from accepting and passing laws that unjustifiably saddle the right to abortion. The court held that the fourth amendment provided the required freedom that afforded the right to privacy including particular areas of

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The Nsc-68

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Many Americans feel as though the Patriot Act interferes with our 1st and 4th amendments; which are the right to free speech and expression, as well as protecting the citizens of unwarranted search and seizures. The authority given to the government to violate individual privacy crosses the boundaries set in the Constitution. The U.S. Constitution (specifically the Bill of Rights) guarantees every American certain Individual rights. Several critics have claimed that the United States of America no longer protects these rights. From the government’s warrantless wiretapping, obtaining personal info from NSL’s or National Security Letters, emails, and phone records or unconstitutional surveillance of the citizens of the USA, free thinking, speech, and typical American lifestyle cannot…

    • 739 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some of America’s finest minds got together for the Philadelphia convention to figure out which form of government would be best. The Federalists were formed by Alexander Hamilton and its other well-known members were Benjamin Franklin, John Jay, George Washington, and James Madison. Federalists desired a secure central government and feeble state governments, preferred the Constitution to aid the amount owed and stress of the American Revolution, were against the Bill of Rights, and were supported in large urban areas. Meanwhile, the Anti-federalists were composed by Patrick Henry, John Hancock, Richard Lee, George Mason, and Mercy Warren. Anti-federalists insisted that power in the states not in the central government, picked the Articles…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Patriot Act can sound scary. This idea that this big monitering, force, knows everything about you, and can access all of your information at the click of a button. Thats a power that can be easily abused. But has it been? Has it hurt anyone?…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Josh Rozdolsky Saleh The Patriot Act United States History What would everyday life look like when the government can look through everyone's private information? The Patriot Act violates Civil Liberties and is Unconstitutional by restricting the First Amendment and Fourth Amendment rights of Americans. The Patriot Act violates freedom of religion and speech.…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In her book, The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness, Michelle Alexander discusses the legal mechanisms used by the criminal justice system that contribute to the mass incarceration of African American males. Among sentencing laws and prejudice in jury selection, Alexander (2010) identifies stop and frisk policies as a discriminatory practice that allows police to racially profile African American men when stopping and searching them in the streets at higher rates than White individuals. Though stop and frisk policies are constitutional under the law, as decided by the Supreme Court, these policies can also be discriminatory in practice when police officers disproportionately target people of color in stops and searches.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ever since the incident on September 11, 2001 we had an act that was passed in haste only 45 days after the attack. We had an act that was passed by George W Bush in a time of fear and unease . Even though we 're trying to protect American liberties from enemies, it is wrong to take away individual rights. One act before the patriot act was Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1968 Also called “Wiretap Statute” which restricted the government 's ability to listen to private conversation, both was controversial because it was signed in 1968 and we did not have the technology we had back then like laptops and cell phones which could be used in very bad ways to hurt or even worse kill people (Patriot)But it also could be a burden for the innocent people who have the government listen on to their private conversations which would take away their constitutional right to privacy. So too little of not listing and to much of listening in on peoples conversations is a bad thing, that 's why we should find a balance between the two so we don 't change the principles we have as a country .…

    • 1025 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the New York Times one of the judge of the federal district ruled” that the tactics underlying New York City’s stop and frisk program violated the constitutional rights of minority citizens”. Based on the statement made by this judge we can see how those police officers who work in those area did not fallow the rule when they were entitle to stop someone. Also this professional prove the point that we tried to make about Stop, Question, and Frisk, that this program did not have any positive effect in New York City. The purpose for this program was to reduce crime, and make our communities safe by, stopping people with a reasonable suspicion, but instead it made the people believe that police officers only stop some people, and the crime rate still the same. Stop, question, and frisk was not the best program that the city could invent to fight crime, they know that this program was not the wright move, because officers would stop some instead of everybody that look…

    • 620 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    4th Amendment Essay

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages

    With this, the government can go through any source of information and violate people’s privacy. For these reasons, the Patriot Act violated the Fourth and First Amendments by the government not showing a warrant of why they are searching the private properties and not notifying others about the information of those search warrants, where no secrecy is even necessary. This act was one of the most serious issues for the country because it violated people’s privacy and breached the First and Fourth…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Patriot Act Research Paper

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Natural rights, privacy, and security are all superior within the Patriot Act. America, now-a-days, are terrorized by foreigners and out-of-state citizens for the control and power over the United States. By reading the primary source documents and commentary texts, it helped to show how the Patriot Act has a relationship to the Bill of Rights because of the reasoning to find a proper balance between national security and individual rights, explaining how the Patriot Act and privacy goes hand in hand with each other, and trying to find a solution to the debate over the Patriot Act. The Reason to finding a proper balance between national security and individual rights is so that the government doesn’t infringe on American rights. On September…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Racial profiling is a common law enforcement practice that happens in many different places in American society. It often focuses and singles out different races, religions, ethnicities, or skin color of people. Many professionals question whether it can be justiciable under certain circumstance where it could prevent a massive amount of people from being harm or to apprehend criminals before they commit crimes. Others protest that the practice is unnecessary and causes more harm than good. This paper will examine if racial profiling is an acceptable law enforcement practice by looking at how it is defined, the history, the common ways it is used, the challenges it purposes, does it work, and statistical data.…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Americans had experienced this privacy invasion with the British many times. Before the revolution, British claimed the authority to issue Writs of Assistance allowing officials to enter private homes in search for evidence of smuggling. Writs of Assistance never expired and were transferable. The federalists violate the fourth amendment on a daily basis. When federal agency collects our electric data, emails, phone calls, and other private information, that violates this amendment, if they don’t have a legitimate reason.…

    • 590 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Racial profiling is highly disliked by many people, especially in the United States. Fauchon (2004) defines racial profiling as stopping and searching people passing through public areas solely because of their color, race, or ethnicity (p. 1). Racial profiling is looked down upon in the United States, however, many people, specifically law enforcement, do so to this day. It’s demeaning to people and it goes against what the country stands for. According to Fauchon (2004), by singling out a group of people by their race, we violate their equal protection.…

    • 169 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to the United Nations, privacy is basic human right that should be protected by law. The United States Constitution also implies a right to privacy in the Fourth Amendment. Recent laws passed by the government have raised questions about whether the government’s actions infringe upon a citizen’s right to privacy. The USA Patriot Act was the first of many laws that increased the powers of government organizations such as the NSA and the FBI. The law allowed these agencies to access private records of US citizens without the need of a warrant or judge’s consent.…

    • 716 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to the American Civil Liberties Union “The Patriot Act increases the Government 's power to obtain information from wiretapping and surveillance. ”(www. ACLU.org) The Patriot Act was developed to keep the citizens of America more safe from terrorist attacks. There is also a disadvantage of this Act because this an infringement of the Fourth Amendment.…

    • 1280 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without these two Acts in place today in our country who knows what our privacy would be like when it comes to gaining access to records. These two Acts almost contradict one another because for The Freedom of Information Act it allows a much easier access to government information in executive branch agency records. This Act also goes beyond that and will give one permission to get access to veteran’s military information of veterans who were deceased on duty. The Privacy Act then makes it harder for an individual to obtain someone’s personal privacy records. This Act protects your privacy which can be great under certain circumstances.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays