Ethical Dilemma In Nursing Case Study

Improved Essays
As nurses we will face numerous dilemma or conflicts in the line of duty. Dilema can come in various form for a nurse, be it from family or between colleagues and supervisors. To handle such situation, there have to be a framework of ethics and law that have to be considered before any decisions are made. According to (Hall, 1996, p.2), “Good nursing practice is good ethics is good law”. With this statement in mind, one can practice with confidence as what they do is within the guideline of ethics and legal under the eye of the law. An example of a dilemma in a clinical setting would be in the decision making process of a patient who is unconcious. Sometimes the physician want the best for the patient but the family thinks otherwise or vice versa. This will be explored in the essay on the proper way to handle such dilemma if faced by a nurse.

As illustrated in Appendix A, this case scenario involves establishing the mental capacity of a particular patient according to the Mental Capacity Act. The basic principles in guiding ethical dilema will also be discussed that is autonomy, beneficence, normalificience and justice.

In Singapore, patients are protected with an act called “Mental Capacity Act”. This act explains that one shall be assume
…show more content…
What this means is that the patient have the rights to be informed regarding his treatment options so as he can make the right decision for himself. As the nurse in charge of the patient, one should also provide the patient with additional information if required by the patient at any cost. The nurse in charge should also respect the patient’s decision to accept or refuse any care or treatment. For this instance in the case scenario, nurse Tan should informed the patient about the decision made by the primary team and not keep it to himself. Indirectly nurse tan have violated the ethical value of non-malificence to his

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Contexualism In Nursing

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The second component is identifying the morally relevant facts which include the key players, the newly hired nurse, the senior member of the nursing staff, and the patient. There are also legal and medical implications in this scenario. As the nurse, I would evaluate the ethical problem, by examining the dilemma and knowing what is right for the patient by using the key principle of justice and nonmaleficence (Hood, 2013, p.72). As a nurse, being taught a way that promotes patient safety is always of priority, although having conflict within the workplace could potentially hurt my career. I would then need to identify and analyze the action alternatives and determine if with the path I choose, what could be the potential outcome (Hood, 2013, p.70).…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should an RCP criticize a physician if he/she will not change a drug order that is clearly in the best interest of the patient? Yes, but in a professional manner. Duty and virtue oriented ethics can be applied in this scenario. I’d applied duty for the simple fact that we are doing our jobs based on the rules. Virtue on the other hand reflects the RCP’s character and morality.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Safeguarding: A Case Study

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Furthermore, it is highly crucial that nurses in charge of the shift comprehend the guidelines and constraints established for training and delegation of tasks (NMC,2015). Also, acceptance of accountability for registered nurses is paramount when commissioning activities while being knowledgeable about up to date evidence for practice, legislation or limitations of the practice (NMC,2015). However, it is also argued that regardless of legal status or employment hierarchy it is important to note that the healthcare setting is inter-professional, and an individualistic work ethic is not advised (Curtis et, al. 2011a). Additionally, the NMC (2008) has recognized philosophies that have to be implemented in the practice.…

    • 1316 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every aspect of these values needs to be upheld with regards to supporting a patient with advanced directive choices. First concept in these values is client well-being; the client has the right to choose quality of time spent while still functioning over the quantity of time spent. The patient and their families may decide that prolonging life is not worth the pain and suffering that would come to the person. Nurses must ensure family and patient are aware of the options but refrain from proving personal input on the choice. The next concept, client well-being, is described in this paper as putting the quality of life they wish to have over what you or other professionals view to be appropriate such as tube feedings and respirators.…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    a) What are the ethical issues? This scenario exemplifies an ethical issue where there is an ethical dilemma between respect for autonomy and beneficence and non-maleficence Respect for Autonomy Autonomy can be defined as the person right to make an informed decision about the treatment and other decision in regards to their care. In this scenario, the hospitalized patient wants his partner to be involved in his care. Although this decision may have serious consequences ( such as an increased risk of spreading the infection), it is the duty of the nurse to educate patient about the risk and benefits of their decision thereby promoting their autonomy and informed decision making. Nurses need to be sensitive to the decision of their patients even when they feel that it goes against their values, the nurse should explore the culture of the patient in regards to the importance of family/loved ones in order to provide a more culturally congruent care.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Conclusion Professional nurses are should be able to apply professional judgment into the dynamic medical field. All of them are expected to be accountable in the practice in that any actions and gaps left will be questionable. With all regulatory bodies put in place, they are expected to practice epitomes and excellent decision making in the best interests of the legally entrusted party. This will put to drop in litigation of medical practitioners under common negligence law. References Cox C (2010) Legal responsibility and accountability.…

    • 1814 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As nurses, we sometimes get ourselves in situations whether or not to respect the client’s wishes when they are against the medical orders for care. In Burkhardt and Nathaniel (2014), ethical dilemmas are when there are conflicting morals happening with a patient. To help guide the nurses, ethical dilemmas require them to think critically about situations and figure out the appropriate decision to create the best outcome for their patient and patient’s family. According to Murray (2010), nurses require moral courage, which requires to them to stand up for what they believe in when it comes to providing the safest and ethically care for a patient. No matter how a situation conflicts with an ethical aspect, being able to speak up for the patient and knowing their best interest makes for better nurses.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is important that a client is able to feel comfortable with their health care professional in order to reach the best outcomes. Research argues that a person who is in need of nursing care is a vulnerable human being. This vulnerability shapes the nursing care process from the beginning and transforms it into an ethical process (Gastmans, 2013). The ethical essence of nursing is the provision of care in response to the vulnerability of a human being in order to maintain, protect, and promote his or her dignity as much as possible (Gastmans, 2013). Nurses should provide care in response to the client’s vulnerability in order to provide the best care.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through obtaining the consent of the patient and their family, it is ensured that the intervention that is being provided or will be provided is selected on agreed terms. As per the standards if any adult that is not mentally challenged and is competent is being touched without the prior permission, they can sue for trespass against that person. Therefore it is necessary for the nurses to gain the consent through the transparent procedure and this also demonstrates their capability and competence as professional. As per Sully & Dallas, (2005), it is better to gain the consent for from the patient in writing because as per the legal perspective, it is the best form. As per the nursing working standards, no specific procedure has been mentioned which should be adopted by the nurses to get the consent of the patient.…

    • 1093 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Nurses are accountable for practicing nursing in accordance with the various sources of law affecting nursing practice” (Wissman , 2010, p. 22). Accountability is an ethical issue, but it is also a legal matter. It is imperative to know the nursing laws in the state and facility that you practice. Not only are nurses ethically responsible to their patients, but also they must answer to the law. Medical professionals must protect themselves by practicing with in the confines of the law.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays