Arguments Against Supported Decision-Making

Great Essays
Sometimes people with a disability, including mental illness, require assistance to make decisions. Supported decision making provides assistance to the person, enabling them to fully exercise their legal capacity. The United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities 2006 and the Victorian Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities 2006 encourages the use of supported decision making to ensure people with disabilities have access to basic human rights, freedoms, respect and dignity enjoyed by other people. Denying people the right to make decisions or restricting the type of decisions they make is potentially denying them their human rights. With supported decision making, mental health consumers are able to participate …show more content…
Regardless of supported decision making, there may be a time when a person’s capacity to make decisions for themselves is compromised. Substitute decision making occurs when decisions are made on their behalf by a person officially appointed by law. Safeguards are put in place to protect the person’s human rights, decision making ability, safety and quality of life. According to the Mental Health Act 2014 “persons receiving mental health services should be involved in all decisions about their assessment, treatment and recovery and be supported to make, or participate in, those decisions, and their views and preferences should be respected”. Victorian Charter of Human Rights and Responsibilities 2006 has influenced the recovery model used in mental health care in Victoria. The Mental Health Act 2014 has been legislated to provide a guide that will allow and support compulsory consumers to participate in decisions that will contribute to their treatment and pathways to recovery. The Mental Health Act 2014 includes the presumption of capacity to give informed consent, an advance statement to identify the consumer’s preferences, nominated persons to support the consumer and the right to a second …show more content…
Everyone has the right to make decisions about the things that affect them. It is presumed that people with disabilities, including mental illnesses are capable of decision making, however sometimes they require assistance making these decisions. Supporters of decision making are invaluable in assisting people with a disability to comprehend, consider and voice their decisions, and build on their decision making skills. The Mental Health Act 2014 promotes supported decision making for consumers, allowing them to have more choice when it comes down to their treatment. The Mental Health Act 2014 provides safeguards such as independent advocacy and the Mental Health Tribunal, this ensures consumers rights and dignity are respected. Reflecting on experience working in an inpatient mental health setting highlighted some tensions and benefits to implementing supported decision making principles. This proved how supported decision making can have a positive influence on the treatment outcomes of consumers. Putting the principles of supported decision making into practice ensures maximising of autonomy, retention of legal capacity and exercising

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Price’s purpose for writing this article is to inform her audience about the different definitions of disability and also to rework the definition itself. Her main argument is that there are many words one can use to describe “impairments of the mind”, but there is not one correct word to use to describe them (298). One must acknowledge the different definitions and decipher which one fits to the situation at hand. However, the definition that a person chooses must be more inclusive and expressive of individuality. She gives the readers about seven words to choose from when defining mental disability and gives examples as to how those words can be used.…

    • 1363 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Test Item #2: The definition of the word autonomy means to be self-determined or to have free will. Patients, who are competent and are of an appropriate age, all have the ability to be autonomous when it comes to making decisions about their healthcare.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Rosny Bus Mall Essay

    • 2341 Words
    • 10 Pages

    This safety risk to the public included risks to vulnerable people within the community which included the mentally ill, as defined in the Mental Health Act, Tasmania (Mental Health Act 2013). This paper will discuss the previous of initiatives…

    • 2341 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A person’s autonomy is a privilege that is earned through the knowledge gained through life experiences. For children, the right to decide is withdrawn because the parent’s are thought to know what is best in the circumstances concerning their children. The ability to understand and comprehend the severity of illness or the consequences of decisions is lacking in adolescents. They are deemed incapable of making informed decisions thus incompetent; therefore, the parents are given the authority to provide or deny consent on behalf of their children. Similarly, elderly who are experiencing deteriorating illnesses may have an altered competence due to being in denial or having fear of the outcome.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    - Users of health and social care services should be consulted and allowed to make independent decisions about their health and treatment. If for example a person should be taken to a theatre for an operation, he should be allowed to make the decision independently after being informed. It is important for organisations that are working in partnership to enable their clients make informed decisions. Individual should be taken step by step on the kind of treatment they are required to undergo. The underperforming nursing home does not give clients an opportunity to make informed decision and this has affected its performance because clients prefer going to nursing homes where they are allowed to make their own decisions independently.…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Personal Values and Attitudes Every person is unique and has a different set of personal values, attitudes and beliefs that shaped their way of living. As a Disability Support Professional (DSP), I am going to support individuals with mental, physical and intellectual disabilities, who may have a different set of values and beliefs as compared to my values and beliefs. As a DSP, I should keep in mind that the person I am going to support has his/her own values and beliefs and I should respect his/her perspective and the ways that they want to live their lives.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction The following critical review will investigate the introduction and implications of Consumer-Directed Care (CDC) for disability care and services in Australia. This will be achieved through evaluation and critique of Consumer-Directed Care as a service innovation and brief examples from the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS). The aim of the critical review will be to assess the strengths and limitations of consumer-directed care – especially in cases where an individual may not be considered able to make decisions about their own care as a result of cognitive illness or impairment. The main findings of this review are that CDC as an innovation can be highly effective in creating a sense of independence and autonomy…

    • 1598 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is seen being highlighted in constitutions of a few countries, for example, the South African Bill of Rights (1996 South African Constitution), or even in global contracts, for example, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR 1948) which ensure a man's entitlement to life, respect, and not to be liable to savage or uncaring treatment. This highlight in lawful instruments, for example, these do not separate in the middle of persons and all things considered they apply to and ensure all persons paying little heed to their qualities. Atterbury is right in expressing that recovery oriented practices are an examination between the professionals and the administration client's in how the administration client ought to be dealt with and what his or her treatment objectives perhaps. This methodology advantages the business in that it is seen to be recognizing that each and every individual is distinctive and the sum total of what people have been subjected to diverse circumstances which have formed them and all things considered specific consideration must be paid to every person. In this manner psychological wellness care suppliers are not just specialists who power administration clients to recuperate, by applying a limited rundown of answers for help…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Explain how national initiatives promote anti-discriminatory practice Discrimination occurs worldwide. In every country there are many forms of discrimination and in order to prevent discrimination there are legislations, codes of practice, charters and organisational policies. Sometimes these are not always followed through and some people break these national initiatives and are forced to serve consequences. Some of the legislations only occurs in certain countries for example the European Convention on human rights and fundamental freedoms act of 1950 is not eligible in the US or Asia. Legislations are a political act that has been turned into the law and they are to maintain health and safety.…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Safeguarding Reflection

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Dimond (2011) states that mental capacity is a person 's ability to make their own decision, and this must be always kept in mind in safeguarding adult. Department of health (2009) has set up guideline for people working in health and social care following Mental Capacity Act, to protect vulnerable adult. Mental capacity act is underpinned by five key principles, every adult should be thought to have capacity, individual should be given all the required help before he or she is thought not to be able to make their own decision (Smebye, Kirkevold and Engedal, 2012). Every person has their own value and beliefs therefore, they cannot be treated as someone lacking capacity for that reason (Department for Constitutional Affairs, 2007) . Anything that is done for the person lacking capacity should be done in the individual best interest (Department of health, 2009).…

    • 1829 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Impaired decision-making capacity includes an inability to understand and retain information and an inability to communicate one’s decision or decision-making process (Eriksson, 2012). People who experience impaired decision-making include those who are suffering from “dementia, stroke, schizophrenia, or traumatic brain injury; people that are comatose; and others with mental or cognitive disorders” (Eriksson, 2012, p. 15). Cohen, McGarvey, Pinkerton, and Kryzhanivska (2004) examined individuals in a psychiatric inpatient facility to determine their ability to decide whether to participate in research and to assess the level of risk a research study presents. They found that patients with schizophrenia demonstrated equal impairments in decision-making…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Abstract: The mentally disabled community is often at risk of being victimized because of their vulnerability, dependency of others and their role in society. Throughout the years new legislation have been written in order to protect the rights of the mentally disabled. Still with these new legislation many of often victimized due to their lack of knowledge.…

    • 57 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Participation in mental health care poses many challenges for mental health service users and service providers. Consideration of these issues for improving the integration of service user participation in mental health care can help to inform integrated care within health care systems, broadly. This paper argues for practicing greater empathy and teaching it, stigma reduction, changing what we measure, valuing the intrinsic aspects of care more, employing more people with lived experience within mental health services, raising the visibility of service users as leaders and our teachers within services and redefining integrated care from the service user perspective. Participation in mental health can mean individually focused collaborative, respectful inclusion of mental health service users in care decisions within their interpersonal encounters with service providers and systems. But it can also mean engagement with the notion of having a mental illness and seeking or accepting support.…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Nature caused us all to be born equal; if fate is pleased to disturb this plan of the general law, it is our responsibility to correct its caprice and to repair by our attention the usurpations of the stronger” Maurice Blanchot (Ainlay, 1986) In United Kingdom alone, statistic records show that in 2014 There were over 11 million people with a limiting long term illness, impairment or disability with the most commonly-reported impairments being those that affect mobility, lifting, or carrying. (Department of work and pensions 2014) this essay will look at what is meant by disability to an individual and to the society, what impacts does disability have on the health and well-being of an individual and what services are available and accessibility.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mental Health and Addiction Assignment: In traditional model of mental health services, the decision making to treat a mental health client was carried out by the clinicians (Ministry of Health, 1995). Nowadays, in the contemporary mental health, the consumers are working together with the health professionals to provide a therapeutic contribution to mental health care (Mcallister & Walsh, 2004). The providers especially nurses are relying on the relationship negotiated with their clients to promote recovery approach to care, which means to work in a negotiated partnership. However, the negotiated partnership may be impossible to maintain due to some barriers.…

    • 2038 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays