Cartesian Substance Dualism

Good Essays
Dualism: Cartesian Substance Dualism
Substance dualism is the thesis that there are substances of two fundamentally and irreducibly distinct kinds in this world, namely mind and bodies. Dualism of this form contrasts with monism which is defined as all thing in the world are substances of one kind either only mind or only body. According to the Cartesian substance dualism, minds are not identical with material things, minds could exist even if no material thing existed. Mind is thought to be something that independence, it can exist if there is no other material exists or any other mind existed. Hence, there are a few of properties that defined Cartesian substance dualism which are there are substances of two fundamentally different kinds
…show more content…
For example of the properties are Charge, e = 1.6021892 x 10(-19), Magnetic Flux= 4.13089 x 10-15, Mass, m = 9.109534 x 10(-31), Magnetic Moment= 9.284832 x 10(-24), Radius, R = 3.86607 x 10(-13). They do not believe in the non-physical substance or the soul and only the body exist. They only have to look at one thing, the brain, and that’s where we’d find both mental properties and physical properties. If we fully understood the brain, we’d have enough information to also explain. They also believe that the mental properties cannot be reduced to the physical …show more content…
As from monist, they believe that the body and mind itself is made up from the same matter. Hence, one can be error in their owns mind as the mind and the brain is one. When there is something wrong or an error happen to the brain, its mean that there is same error happened to the mind which can affect our mental activities. As a dualism, they believe that mind and brain are distinct element which mind as non-physical whereas brain is a physical element. The mind and brain are exist in separate but they have interaction between two of them. Hence, if there anything goes wrong with the brain (physical), it will affect the activities of the mind as they were related to each other. But, there are also contradiction as when we through the Cartesian Dualism, we cannot agree that one can be error in one own

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Theories Of Dualism

    • 1826 Words
    • 8 Pages

    However, other emergentists, such as Thomas Henry Huxley, refused this idea and argued that even though the physical events in the brain trigger mental events, mental events do not have the ability or capacity to impact any kind of physical events, including behaviors (1874). This form of emergentism is called epiphenomenalism. More interestingly, Baruch Spinoza proposed a related dualist theory, which is known as double aspectism. According to Spinoza, the mind and body are similar to two sides of the same coin that they are different but inseparable from each other. He believed that physical events happening to the material body can be experienced as emotions and thoughts, and mental events also impact the material body.…

    • 1826 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Substance dualism considers the mind and brain to be made up of different properties and that the mind is for thinking but is not an attributional object. Descartes ideas of dualism supports this view. Property dualists believe mental properties of consciousness; such as thinking, are non-physical characteristics of physical substances. Fundamentally dualists agree that mind and matter are separate, this is based on the logical argument of Leibniz law; that if two things have different characteristics, they must be separate. The mind is believed to not be made up of physical matter, so mind and brain do not have the same physical properties and therefore according to Leibniz law the physical brain and the mind are therefore not the same.…

    • 1934 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When relating mental states to brain states, scientific technicalities prevent them from being identical as they are described with modes of presentations that cannot clearly be observed as identical. In applying this concept to the dualist argument, we can see that the current definition of introspection prevents it from being viewed as a property of a brain state.…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Is each person an immaterial soul or spirit operating a physical body? Substance Dualists Substance Dualists argue that the mind and the body are composed of different substances and that the mind is a thinking thing that lacks the usual attributes of physical objects such as size, shape, location, solidity, motion and adherence to the laws of physics. These Dualists are divided into various categories depending on how they think mind and the body are related. These categories are as follows; Interactionists: These type of Dualists believe that the mind and the body casually affect one another. Occasionalists: They argue that mind and the body do not interact though they may seem to.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Dualists Analysis

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Possible Replies of the Interactionists According to Dualists, human person: the human mind, and human organism: human body, are not one and the same thing. Human mind can not be reduced to simple physical activities, and one specific kind of the dualists, the interactionists believe that there’s a two-way causal connection between the human mind and the human organism: the human mind can affect human organism in a specific way, and vice versa. Adding to that, interactionists further illustrate that a mental action can cause a physical action, and other way around. In regard of this theory, the materialists have several refutations. One rejection is to doubt the existence of human mind i.e.…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Since the organ in this case became the receiver of all other things, it should distinguish across the matters, but restricted by the form of organ, the matters of organ is unable to recognize the circumstance other than itself. The generic and specific difference cannot be evaluated because the one form would allow only access to some particular matter. This exclusion violated the rational faculty’s property of having infinite access to all. Therefore, this possibility is rejected. The possibility that the rational faculty’s knowledge of its organ came from some other intelligible form differed from the form of organ is also refuted.…

    • 725 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When people say “it is a mental thing”, they are talking about using their mind separate from their body. People may argue that our body is dependent on the mind to function-or move, or they may think that they complement each other. Meaning that whatever the mind does, the body follows. Since I believe that they are separate, and that our mind is not physical, it would not make sense to think that they have to always work together. I believe that yes, the mind and body do complement each other well, but it does not mean that they are dependent on one another.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The other is the problem of other minds- the objection to Dualism based on the undesired conclusion that if all we can be sure of is our own bodies, we can never know for certain that others even really exist. Dualism still struggles with this. However, Behaviorism dissolves this problem because again, in virtue of its physicalist foundation, it implicitly assumes a consistency among other humans that Substance dualism doubted. Because of this, minds are physically the same and only experientially different and so can be assumed to operate similarly to one another. Because of the physicalism of Behaviorism, it is able to dissolve two long existing problems of…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Consciousness is not far from black and white because consciousness can be altered by different factors. Like one of the previous examples, consciousness can be altered when a person suffers from traumatic brain injuries. Although the consciousness is still present, which would suggest that it is different than the actual physical portions of the brain, the consciousness is so drastically different that it is almost impossible to think that consciousness and the brain are not one. Therefore, my overall stance of the relationship between the mind and the body is uncertain. In my opinion, the conscious mind goes far beyond something that science will ever be measure.…

    • 1796 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The mind cannot just be there and has no foundations. What causes the mind to be existed? The mind and the body belong to the same person, so they have to at least have some relations so that that person can function properly. If the mind and the body are not relatable, then how the body can express what the mind is experiencing. The opposing argument can be outlined as follow: P1.…

    • 905 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays