Essay on Critical Thinking

718 Words Nov 26th, 2013 3 Pages
CRAM Exclusive
Essay Sample
Evaluate the following argument. More specifically, identify the premises and conclusions. Determine whether the argument is deductive, or inductive (1pt). If it is deductive, determine whether it is sound, or unsound. If it is inductive, determine whether it is cogent, or uncogent (1pt). Explain your answers (2pt). 1. 84% of Liberal voters believe Dalton McGuinty has the best leadership abilities. Natalie Smith is a Liberal voter So she probably believes that Dalton McGuinty has

middle of document…

Evaluate the arguments offered in the following passages. More specifically, identify the premises (1pt), conclusion (1pt), and fallacy committed (1 pt). Explain your answers (2pt).

2. “My Professor suggested to me that I should study logic because logic, she said, teaches one how to argue. But people argue too much as it is; just watch the Jerry Springer show once and a while and you’ll see what I mean. Consequently, I do not intend to take any logic courses, and am of the opinion that logic should not be studied in University at all.”

Premise: 1) Logic teaches one how to argue
2) People argue too much as it is.

Conclusion: I do not intend to take any logic courses, and am of the opinion that logic should not be studied in University at all.

Fallacy: Equivocation

Here the arguer concludes that logic is not worthwhile to study at University, on the grounds of his professor’s claim that logic teaches one to argue, and that people argue too much as it is. The conclusion indicator ‘consequently’ identifies the conclusion, and the ‘because trick’ can be used to identify the premises. The arguer believes that logic should not be studied in University, by himself or by anyone else, because logic merely teaches one to argue and people do enough of that already.

However, the arguer has here committed the fallacy known as equivocation, since the use of the term ‘argue,’ shifts semantically over the course of the passage and argument. In
CRAM Exclusive

Related Documents

  • Essay on Critical Thinking

    Dillon Beach, CA: Foundation for Critical Thinking. Paul, R., & Elder, L. (2008). The thinker’s guide to fallacies: The art of mental trickery and manipulation. Dillon Beach, CA: Foundation for Critical Thinking. All electronic materials are available on the student website. |Week One: Developing and Establishing a Foundation for Thinking | | |Details

    Words: 3352 - Pages: 14
  • Critical Thinking Application Essay

    intellectual arrogance to take form. Furthermore, a critical thinker must be a free thinker, an independent mind that resists social pressure to conform to majority point of view. Depending on how that individual was brought up, the free mind set may prove to be very difficult. To separate and to be independent thinker requires a higher commitment to give up some important aspect of one’s traditional life in order to explore higher intellectual thinking. Some individuals may find it impossible to depart

    Words: 1024 - Pages: 5
  • Essay on Stages of Critical Thinking

    did great with my thinking and of times where I could have improved my thinking. Strategy 2: A Problem A Day Implementation Plan: I really like this one. I will decide on a problem for the day on my way into work. In my slow moments and free time I will analyze the problem at hand and develop a strategy on how to solve this problem. Strategy 3: Deal with my Egocentrism Implementation Plan: Now that I have a better understanding of what egocentric thinking is I can learn how

    Words: 996 - Pages: 4
  • Essay about Critical Thinking

    crisply--no mindless conclusions. 
 Step 5 is a reminder to check beginnings and endings to be sure the sentences have real CONTENT, and aren't just meaningless collections of words. 
 Tools of Critical Thinking 
 This part of the study guide identifies key points you should know from each chapter of CRITICAL THINKING. You should be able to recognize examples of different errors and fallacies, and also to generate your own examples, if called for. In other words, you need to go beyond memorizing a definition

    Words: 1488 - Pages: 6
  • Critical Thinking Application Essays

    model is evaluating one’s decision this phase helps the individual implement his decision, and measuring the impacts of that decision (University of Phoenix website). Within the workplace from the CEO down to the lower-level employee, use critical thinking skills to make a decision or solve a problem relating to his or her position. Harold an over the road truck driver must weigh out options, before he makes a final decision. Decisions must be made, such as fuel costs, and possible routes taken

    Words: 784 - Pages: 4
  • Applying Critical Thinking Essay

    and procedures are not followed according to the Inter-Plan Processing manual. Recently the BCBSA implemented a new process in accepting provider disputes and/or appeals on the Home side of the Blue Card department. The Home department used critical thinking when implementing the new operational process that must be followed. The first part of finding an operational process that will work with BSC systems and other processes for the new regulated process is to find the problem with the current process

    Words: 745 - Pages: 3
  • Critical Thinking Essay

    Critical thinking is a necessary pathway in improving the quality of patient care. The health care system will continue to change and expand on its' newfound technologies. Consequently, the nursing practice must continue to evolve as well. Critical thinking is a necessary tool for helping to guide nurses in making clinical decisions. Four components of critical thinking are recognizing assumptions; being aware of how assumptions shape perceptions; being able to think of and explore alternatives;

    Words: 1133 - Pages: 5
  • Critical Thinking Application Essay

    the department. I was taught how the system works what needed to be done to get the reports done but there were times that the director or manager would come to me and ask for my help in creating new and better reports. Well this is where the critical thinking came in because not only was the report for the department but for others as well. The project was to have a report that tied to what Accounts Receivables was billing out for the clients. The problem with that was that each client was billed

    Words: 933 - Pages: 4
  • Essay on Critical Thinking

    information. Employees need to ask relevant questions, listen actively, assess complex information, and engage with others in critical decision making. The success of an organization depends on the ability of members to ask relevant questions, evaluate complex information, make difficult decisions, and anticipate the outcomes of those decisions. These are all critical thinking skills. In this line of business of the LTL industry you have to be willing to react to any adversity or curve ball that is

    Words: 842 - Pages: 4
  • What Is Critical Thinking Essay

    noted in the preceding list: examine assumptions, detect hidden values, evaluate evidence, and assess conclusions. Why is critical thinking important? As a professional accountant, you will need to be able to respond to varying subject matter, complex issues, and decision-making scenarios. You will need to develop a method of analysis that combines several modes of thinking (scientific, mathematical, historical, anthropological, economic, moral, philosophical, and so on) into a coherent whole

    Words: 3393 - Pages: 14