Catastrophic Health Care Analysis

Great Essays
Catastrophic Care is a book written by David Goldhill about why everything we think we know about health care is wrong. He addresses many national problems in relation to health care and gives examples as to why we face them. Throughout this paper I will critique the book and discuss my opinions in comparison with David’s.
What is the hypothesis (or hypotheses) of the author(s) in the book you selected? Do the authors identify limitations or failures in our current health care “system”? If so, please discuss these limitations.
The overall purpose of David writing this book is defined within the title, to explain to everyone “why everything we think we know about health care is wrong.” As the title foreshadows, the book discusses a lot of
…show more content…
Not only is the U.S spending too much on medical care but so is each individual. He gave an example of how Becky has a job with “benefits” and although she, and most people, think that’s how she receives her health insurance, it’s not the only way. There are many other ways she is contributing to the health care pool that she is not aware of. David believes it’s impossible to determine if the increase in health care costs correlates to an increase in life span, although studies show the attribution isn’t much. Therefore, why are we spending so much if we aren’t seeing results or statistics on that’s what it takes to have a healthy country? David discusses a few sectors in which spending can be reduced and some of the major ones include waste and excess, pharmaceuticals, and overtreatment/overuse/overdiagnosis. I do believe most of these sectors can be reduced in some way to benefit our system. Most of these sectors are because our system provides an incentive for them. To relieve part of the pharmaceutical problem, we should not allow drug companies to advertise their products on T.V as this creates the problem of Americans wanting drugs that may pertain to them even if they don’t need it. Physicians are incentivized to overprescribe so they aren’t sued or because they get paid for each service. We need to tweak our legal system and reimbursement model so these don’t contribute to our problems. I do agree with David that these and many other sectors in which spending can be reduced to overall cut our medical costs which is necessary to improve our

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    It is so uncertain that even doctors and nurses can fall victim to deadly diseases. These connections are brought together to discuss one overarching theme of the book. This theme is that medicine can cause an individual to lose their own humanity. Is this a helpful or harmful thing? Well, that is solely up for the reader to…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What Is Nanny Law?

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages

    A “Nanny Law” is defined as a view that a government or itself policies are overprotective or interfering unduly with personal choice (Wikipedia Contributors). The “Nanny Law” of reform health care or Obama Care, as it’s more commonly known as, is the “Nanny Law” I chose because of my profession I can relate to the individuals who use this law. I am a health insurance agent and everyday I see individuals that are frustrated and confused about their health care. The new health care law should be repealed because of the fact that this law causes great confusion on its users just get on the webpage, the law does not provide enough coverage or benefits for individuals enrolled in the plans, and it causes more of strain on the everyday worker to…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Costly medication is sometimes prescribe by healthcare providers with no benefits to the patient’s health. This raises an ethical concern because the patients’ health is in jeopardy for taking medications that they do not need and they are now burden with the cost of that prescription drug. Often times, there is pressure on healthcare providers from the big pharmaceutical companies to sell their drugs to patients. Leonard J. Weber, a professor at the University of Detroit, talks about the ethics of the prescription drug marketing, in his book, Profits before People? Ethical Standards and the Marketing of Prescription Drugs.…

    • 806 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Free Healthcare for All Many people have discussed that they are for free healthcare in other words they believe their health care should not be paid for in the United States, yet in reality this is something that should not be pushed for. There are many reasons that healthcare should not be handed out. Free rights to health care could increase the wait time for medical services and the patience to doctor ratio will become overbearing, providing health care would decrease competition within doctors and increase in personal and economical taxes causing the government to then be able to have more say in things. If health care was free then think of how the in hospital wait time would fluctuate. With healthcare being free to everyone a person…

    • 883 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Bundled payments were supposed to get rid of incentives to over treat the patients, but they created dangerous incentives to undertreat. Physicians aren’t going to want to prescribe their patients more expensive treatments and medication if they can get away with a cheaper, but maybe less effective version because they will have to pay for it out of…

    • 1223 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Health Care System In Canada

    • 2410 Words
    • 10 Pages

    And finally, if a healthcare professional is at fault for misdiagnosis or mistreatment of a patient, there is little recourse, if any, on the side of the patient since the government has to protect itself against lawsuits and legal fights against the government may not be successful most of the time. Furthermore, in order to be able to do business, insurance companies become creative in developing individual insurance policies that may make great sense, when it comes to keeping expenses at the lowest for the government but would not be of any use for a subscriber/patient. For example, a medical insurance policy that requires the subscriber/patient to pay the first $10000.00 of his/her healthcare cost in a given year, before the health insurance would start paying. For someone who may make $30000.00 per year, this may not be suitable. Furthermore, in order to curb healthcare costs, the government has great financial resources to run epidemiological and statistical studies in order to question the frequency of the need for certain medical examinations.…

    • 2410 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    This is one of the problems that can lead to a failure of prescribing only generic salt. Doctor might perform this duty and prescribe the salt to the patient but then it is up to the chemist as to which drug will he provide the patient with. The chemist will compare the profit that he will earn from selling the branded drug or the generic drug. He will definitely be biased to sell the branded drugs because the profit margin in wholesale and retail prices of branded drugs is big. 6.3 Quality Control The generic drugs are not 100% same as the branded drugs.…

    • 1051 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people believe that assisted suicide will downgrade medical technology and corrupt medicine. Medicine could cause the patient 's treatment to prolong his/hers suffering but won’t help anyone if they are terminally ill. It’s a waste of resources which that corrupts medicine and causes a lot of loss of money for the families and patient’s. People say medicine is a tool used for healing, not for killing. They say it distorts doctor-patient relationships, and will perverse incentives for insurance powers. This is not that case-- Medicine is used for healing in only some cases.…

    • 1319 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This can lead to a greater spending on the health care system. As a result, government will have to provide less quality health care treatment in order to sustain the country’s health care budget. Which means that people will be able to access to certain service instead of full service that they could be able to get like before. As Arnold Kling, a PhD in economic from Massachusetts Institute of Technology, states that “In theory, everyone has access. In practice, however, too many people wait for care and too many people receive low-quality care.” Lastly, the primary disadvantage of free health care is lack of competition.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The best option would be to look at how other countries handle their health care. The most logical thing we can do is have health care be covered in our taxes. Even though, most of the U.S. citizens do not like to pay taxes or even want an increase in taxes. This increase would help us all by making sure everyone is insured and receives adequate health treatment. That way, it’s free, but not really we would just be financing it differently.…

    • 766 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays