Carter V. Canada Case Study

Improved Essays
Introduction
Many children today inspire to become a doctor, yet these same doctors are also responsible for the deaths of many Canadians through medical malpractice and negligent acts (McIver & Wyndham, 2013). In addition, with the recent developments of the Carter v. Canada case, the court now allows physicians to administer lethal doses with approval from the provincial state by suspending the current prohibition on assisted suicide (2015). Luckily before this case though, not just in Canada, many juries have decided to reject the law and acquit the accused, the doctor, especially in cases of euthanasia and abortion despite evidence showing that they are guilty (R. v. Morgentaler, 1988)
It is also interesting to analyze the dynamics that exists between doctors and their patients as doctors owe a duty of care towards their patients (Bryden, 2011), unlike other professionals such as Real Estate agents who owe their
…show more content…
To answer this research question, this paper will be looking specifically at the causal factors which the patient factors in when they elect not to file a claim against their negligent doctor. To find these casual factors, the research will first study and analyze the literature review to help define the terms with incorporating ideals from Stein’s theory (2012). Then I will construct an exploratory qualitative style research and one-on-one interview to provide further explanation for why people are hesitating to file a lawsuit against their negligent doctor. The results of this paper will hopefully better aid in the understanding of why doctors are seldom criminally charge and is hoping that the results will yield positive data so that it can be used to help legislators implement future policy change to protect vulnerable

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    New York City College of Technology City University of New York Law and Ethics Case: Jeanette M. and the Phone Call Erica Rotstein October 7, 2017 Professor Bonsignore HAS 3560 -Legal Aspects of Health Care Abstract The advancement in the field of medicine over the years has led to doctors and health care providers having more responsibilities on their hands. This brings into question what should and shouldn’t be done, as well as what is morally and ethically right. However, this isn’t so cut and dry.…

    • 1877 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Tenants correctly note, a prevailing party is entitled to recover costs in any action. (Code Civ. Proc. § 1032, subd. (b).)…

    • 384 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It is clear that the utmost importance in any medical context is the relationship between the healthcare practitioner and the patient. The duty of a physician is to adhere to certain principles of medical ethics namely the principles of respect for autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice. By examining the case study involving Dr. Nancy Morrison, one can observe that these principles are often ambiguous when referring to the issue of whether she committed voluntary active euthanasia or nonvoluntary active euthanasia. Thus, the thesis will aim to exemplify that ultimately Dr. Nancy Morrison was culpable for her actions. To give some context to the issue, Paul Mills was a 65-year-old individual suffering from terminal esophageal cancer.…

    • 1467 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I will neither give a deadly drug to anybody who asked for it, nor will I make a suggestion to this effect” (Anderson, Ryan n.p.).This is a vital statement of Anderson’s writing, and a crucial piece of why this writer believes it is unethical and unprogressive for physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia to exist. Anderson believes that if the philosophy of euthanasia was put into full affect it would endanger anyone who is sick: the “weak and the venerable.” He believes that doctors and the people who decides who lives or dies such as judges have an emphatic responsibility to protect…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Richard Selzer’s “Mercy” explores the idea of a medical murder, from a morphine injection to a not so medical strangulation thought. The paranoid doctor contemplates his morals as a suffering man is on his death bed. In this doctor’s mind, there is a difference between murder for medical purposes and just plain murder. Murders, or at least the murders portrayed on TV shows, are almost…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    I asserted my own value judgments about the purpose of medicine, the physician’s role towards their profession and towards society and the purpose of capital punishment within American society. Truthfully, the justness of an action depends on the act itself and the conception of justice used. The question we have to ask ourselves within society, is whether capital punishment accomplishes anything and whether “a society in which the government actively subverts core ethical principles of medical practice is patently worse off for it” (Gawande, When law, 2006, 1221). Furthermore, we must question how just is physician participation in capital punishment if the physicians who participate choose to do so act in secrecy and how just is a punishment in which the State calls upon another body or profession to employ…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Recent stories in the news have posed this controversial question: should terminally ill patients have the right to end their own lives? Empathetic stories of terminally ill patients’ last wishes have captured attention of the media and created a controversial debate on the ethics and morals of physician assisted suicide, otherwise known as PAS. Some claim that PAS is inhumane and unethical, while others insist that it is a given right to anybody under such extreme circumstances. In his article, “Physician-Assisted Suicide Is Always Wrong,” Ryan T. Anderson attempts to convey to citizens and policymakers that legalizing PAS across the country would be a grave mistake. However, Anderson’s argument is weak due to a series of logical fallacies…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The routine practice of physician assisted suicide raises serious ethical and other concern. Legislation would undermine the patient's physical relationship and the trust necessary to sustain it; alter the medical profession role in society; and endanger the value our society places in lives of disabled, incompetent and vulnerable…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The physician has to consent to killing the patient and patient has to consent to let the physician kill him. Callahan poses a question why would anyone consent to being the victim? Callahan writes, “consenting to adult killing, like consenting to adult slavery, or degradation, is a strange route to human dignity.” Rachels argues there is no…

    • 1745 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I. Physician-assisted suicide, under various names and colloquial definitions, has been a documented ethical issue for centuries – not to mention an undocumented ethical issue since the hypothetical dawn of life. By common understanding, physician-assisted suicide is death either directly or indirectly permitted or carried out by a physician. In simple terms, an “out” is provided. For this reason, it is often associated with chronic pain or terminal illness. Suicide where the doctor in charge is directly involved is perhaps the first situation which comes to mind when one thinks of euthanasia.…

    • 2007 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    If doctors are enabled the decision to terminate a life on behalf of a unconscious patient, they would be then granted a power over society that not only breaches the Hippocratic Oath, but also empowers them to “play God”. This responsibility could then reflect upon society, altering their views and their trust within doctors and medical professionals as they could then be seen as “providers of death” (Cosic, 2003. 25) In addition to this, a doctor’s decision to terminate a life may not rely on the condition and best interests of the patient, but instead of amount of hospital beds and facilities that are…

    • 2101 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should Physician-Assisted Suicide Be Legal in Every State When it comes to the topic of physician-assisted suicide, most of will readily agree that the patient has their right to choose their form of treatment; if they chose death, then the reasoning is that they chose to die with dignity. Where this agreement usually ends, however, is on the question of, does allowing patients to die under a doctor’s care deem the death as murder. Some are convinced that it does, other maintain that allowing patients to do so in tern, breaks the Hippocratic Oath. Here in the states, we are very fortunate with every law and amendment that gives us the right to do with what we want with limits.…

    • 1619 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this essay, Steinbock tries to refute the claims about euthanasia presented by James Rachels, and tries to show how Rachel’s misinterpreted the American Medical Association 's doctrine regarding euthanasia. Steinbock states that contrary to Rachel’s interpretation, the AMA does not endorse any type of euthanasia, and that the termination of life is never the goal in a professional medical practice. Steinbock argues that Rachel 's error in his essay was the linkage of ending “extraordinary care” and passive euthanasia. Steinbock says that stoppage of extraordinary care or treatment that would prolong one 's life and creates burden for that patient is not always linked to the intention of death. Steinbock says “there can be a point (to the cessation of life-prolonging treatment) other than an endeavor to bring about the patient’s death,” Steinbock continues to provide examples where withholding treatment does not necessarily mean that this decision was made for the cession of life.…

    • 1667 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Medical Malpractice

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Medical malpractice lawsuits are increasingly becoming a common feature in the medical field in recent times. This to majority of physicians is a nightmare because most of them, or any other medical practitioners, do not anticipate a situation in their medical career where they will be sued by the same patients they swear to assist in their admission to the medical fraternity. However, despite this increased awareness of medical negligence by medical practitioners on the part of the public, there is strong evidence to suggest that most of the patients still remain uninformed on the finer details of malpractice lawsuits. It is therefore important that patients and the public in general be sensitized on a number of issues concerning medical…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Against Assisted Suicide In many countries around the world, it is legal for doctors to prescribe a medicine that can potentially end a patient’s life if the patient wishes to commit suicide. In the United States, four states -Vermont, Oregon, Washington, and Montana- are the only states which have chosen to legalize assisted suicide (Backmann par. 6). Physician assisted suicide, also called assisted suicide, has become an extremely sensitive topic that has been debated by everyone, from academic scholars to everyday people, and has become almost as controversial as abortion.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays