Why Is Physician Assisted Suicide Always Wrong

Superior Essays
Recent stories in the news have posed this controversial question: should terminally ill patients have the right to end their own lives? Empathetic stories of terminally ill patients’ last wishes have captured attention of the media and created a controversial debate on the ethics and morals of physician assisted suicide, otherwise known as PAS. Some claim that PAS is inhumane and unethical, while others insist that it is a given right to anybody under such extreme circumstances. In his article, “Physician-Assisted Suicide Is Always Wrong,” Ryan T. Anderson attempts to convey to citizens and policymakers that legalizing PAS across the country would be a grave mistake. However, Anderson’s argument is weak due to a series of logical fallacies …show more content…
Typically, these types of patients undergo a great deal amount of physical in the remaining months of their life. In most cases, pain management and other palliative medicine to manage their symptoms is simply not enough. During times like these, there is nothing a doctor can prescribe these patients to make the pain or the presence of imminent death disappear. In Unplugged, the author expresses the stigma associated with death. “Doctors learn in medical school to assess, treat, and care. They then move into a hospital culture where a death, even among aged, is seen as a failure,” (102). In physician assisted suicide, it is imperative to realize that the patient is choosing to die with dignity and on their own terms instead of being deteriorated by sickness. Ultimately, a doctor’s main purpose is to cure their patient, but in extreme cases with no cure, there is nothing one can do except to alleviate suffering. By giving the patient the choice of death, physicians are allowing their patient to die on their own terms and with …show more content…
Currently, there are only five states in which it is legal. He argues that instead of offering patients hastened death, doctors should instead provide care and make the patient as comfortable as they can in their final months. This issue has become very controversial and many have questioned the ethics and morals behind it. While it is nobody’s ultimate wish to die, giving this alternative gives comfort to the patient that they do not have to undergo a prolonged amount of suffering. Also, a doctors’ main goal is to help and care for their patients in any and all possible ways. By giving a way out, a doctor is not “killing” their patient, but instead making them more comfortable under the harsh circumstances. However, it is important that the strict requirements for eligibility remain intact. Physician assisted suicide should only be an option for patients during unfortunate circumstances in which they have a limited amount of time left. PAS should never be an option for people who are not terminally ill, including those with depression. This would ensure that PAS is only used for the right reasons and does not threaten the weak and vulnerable. While this is a difficult decision for any patient and their family to make, physician assisted suicide is a right that any terminally ill patient should have access

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Physician Assisted Suicide (PAS), has been a moral dilemma in the hot seat since the passing of Oregon’s Death with Dignity Act in 1997. All throughout the US, states have been trying to pass acts that allow people to die with dignity using PAS, the most recent being Colorado. PAS is a conflicting topic because it causes concern if the choice is morally ethical for the patient and for the others making these decisions like, doctors, psychologist, and other family members. PAS can cause conflict among religion and personal beliefs but it should be seen as an individual 's right not a communal right. The article referenced within this paper is “The Role of and Challenge for Psychologist in Physician Assisted Suicide” written by Shara M. Johnson,…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Regarding physician assisted suicide, also known as PAS, J. David Velleman argues that a PAS policy could be harmful to patients and thus, we should not have a policy. In his work, “Against the Right to Die”, Velleman is not arguing for the morality of PAS, but rather against a PAS public policy. His argument focuses on the harm on a patient that PAS can have by adding the burden to opt for PAS. By giving more options, a PAS policy can push a patient to choose death. Without the option of PAS, Velleman says, a patient can continue to live by default.…

    • 1271 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Other factors include the desire to preserve dignity and personhood in the dying process and opposition to prolonging life by using sophisticated medical technology when it is recognized that care is futile. Closely related to self-determination is the principle of autonomy. This principle states that persons should have the right to make their own decisions about the course of their own lives whenever they can. By extension, they should also have the right to determine the course of their own dying as much as possible. The ethics of physician assisted suicide (PAS) continue to be debated.…

    • 1421 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Physician-Assisted Suicide is Always Wrong” In “Physician-Assisted Suicide is Always Wrong”, author Ryan T. Anderson uses the ethical argument to ascertain that physician-assisted suicide is always wrong. On this controversial topic, the author is appealing to a philosophy: physician assisted suicide doesn’t progress the medical community; but rather it undermines the doctor’s overwhelming ethical responsibility to treat the sick all the way until the very end. In this piece, Anderson genuinely promotes the idea that our society would genuinely put the medical community in danger, as well as possibly put the lives of terminally ill people if our nation expanded laws allowing physician-assisted suicide throughout the entire country. Anderson believes it is unethical due to the digressive impact it has on the medical community in general.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Physician-Assisted Suicide Is physician-assisted suicide, with regards to the elderly or the terminally ill just? Should we allow the assisted death of individuals based on these variables? In this paper, we will seek to expound this question as well as apply it to the ethical theory of utilitarianism. There are two doctrines that can be used to evaluate this issue on whether it is entirely ethical or unethical. On one side of the argument, physician-assisted suicide is deemed as a way of relieving the suffering of others before an inevitable death.…

    • 1675 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The United States is currently in a rut of anti-progressivism. In few areas is this reality more evident than in the popular objection to physician-assisted suicide. Physician assisted suicide, for the sake of argument, is the opportunity given to an individual suffering from terminal illness to end his own life quickly and painlessly by means of prescribed drugs. The practice provides relief for those under immense pain and suffering, but is a sensitive issue to argue in favor of, particularly because of its unwholesome connotation. However, Physician Assisted Suicide is defended by US Standards of Law and Medicine and should therefore be legal throughout the United States for patients with a terminal illness and life expectancy of 6 months or less.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Physician Assisted Suicide

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It does not include judging that a life that can be preserved is not worth preserving, overriding the opinion of the person whose life it is”. (David N. O’Steen, Ph.D. & Burke J. Balch, JD). Thus, physicians should not empower patients to consider ending their own life as it violates their role of a healer and keeping patients alive. As the availability of physician-assisted suicide increases, elderly, disabled, or depressed patients are likely to suffer from a more pressured phase to end their…

    • 1177 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    I. Physician-assisted suicide, under various names and colloquial definitions, has been a documented ethical issue for centuries – not to mention an undocumented ethical issue since the hypothetical dawn of life. By common understanding, physician-assisted suicide is death either directly or indirectly permitted or carried out by a physician. In simple terms, an “out” is provided. For this reason, it is often associated with chronic pain or terminal illness. Suicide where the doctor in charge is directly involved is perhaps the first situation which comes to mind when one thinks of euthanasia.…

    • 2007 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To Live in Pain Should patients have the right to die via physician-assisted suicide? Why would anyone want to live out the rest of their days in pain? My goal in this essay is to express my emotions on patients and their right to die via physician-assisted suicide. I support suicide via physician-assistance. There are many reasons on supporting this kind of suicide, but my main three arguments are the pain of the patient, the cost of hospital treatments to keep the patient comfortable, and lastly the emotional impact on the patient’s family.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Since 1997, Oregon was the first to pass the “Death with Dignity Act” that allows “terminally ill and mentally competent adults” (Barone, 2014. p.5) to end their lives through physician-assisted suicide (PAS). PAS is when a “patient takes his or her own life, aided by a physician who typically gives the patient for a prescription for a lethal drug” (Burdette et al, 2005. p.7). Since then physician-assisted suicide has been also legalized in Montana, Washington, New Jersey and Vermont. Physicians have an obligation to reduce pain and suffering from a patient and; therefore, must respect a patient 's decision to end life-sustaining treatment.…

    • 1863 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should Assisted Suicide be Legal? Physician assisted suicide is a controversial and still illegal practice in the United States. Many terminally ill people are in unbearable pain that medicine cannot heal. This is the sad reality of many people in the United States and most of the world.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Dignity And Suicide

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Introduction Today’s societies are developing at a faster rate than thought humanly possible with new technological and medical advancements unearthed each day. Despite such progress, however, the world today is advancing, many regions of the world still struggle with an archaic controversy that has plagued mankind for centuries. Physician assisted suicide is the doctoral practice of intentionally providing someone with the means to commit suicide. This is includes, but is not limited to, the administration of lethal drugs or the allocation of knowledge to commit suicide.…

    • 1551 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It has been a long journey of conflict on whether or not to pass the right to die legislation or not around the world. This issue is very complex. Though however, the vast majority of the population in the united states has been very lenient I’ve applied what I’ve learned from my research and the wise option would be to pass the right-to-die legislation in contemporary united states. The source that impacted me the most was called, “The Shadow Side of Assisted Suicide” by James Breslow. This article allows it readers to remind everyone that the right to physician aid in dying is not a spreading infection that will distress those who deplore it.…

    • 1439 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Euthanasia and suicide are controversial topics over the years. There have been so many arguments that either advocate or oppose the ethic of euthanasia. The two essay below are evident examples of those arguments and each has some solid points. Furthermore, I will present my response to the essay and also my point of view on this matter. Active and Passive Euthanasia…

    • 1213 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Physician-assisted suicide refers to the case in which a patient can have a physician end his/her life as painlessly and with as much dignity as possible. Currently, only Montana, Oregon, Vermont, and Washington have legalized physician-assisted suicide (Death with Dignity Center), and to be eligible, a patient must have a terminal illness from which they will die in six months or fewer (Norman-Eady, YR). For example, if someone is suffering from depression, s/he cannot simply ask a physician for assistance in committing suicide. There are many pros and cons to this procedure, but it may appear to be an attractive option for a person who wishes to put an end to unbearable pain and suffering.…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays