Analysis Of Judith Jarvis Thomson's A Defense Of Abortion

Improved Essays
-Judith Jarvis Thomson is a moral philosopher, who wrote A Defense of Abortion in1971. This piece of writing is still causing uproar even in the present time over the continuous argument of abortion. She is for abortion in the right circumstances, and in order to fight the people against her, she wrote this piece of writing. In this text, she states that a fetus is not a person and does not have the right to life, but in order to fight against objections towards her she agrees that a fetus is a person, only for the sake of this argument.She is saying that the usual argument against abortion is “all persons have a right to life, a fetus is a person, therefore they have right to life, therefore abortion is wrong.”. She says yes they are a life …show more content…
One objection is that no matter the circumstance you are pulling the trigger on a life. It doesn't matter the time you are stopping a life and preventing its right to life. Now that you are pregnant it is your responsibility to cherish this life and take care of it. You cannot end this life and say it is justified. Just like pulling the trigger of a gun you are not first-hand killing a person, but you are making the choice that ends in a person's death or harm.If you are okay with abortion you are okay with all murder. Another argument is that even if you don't want this child some other family could adopt this child and make the family complete. This abbey has right to happiness even if with another family. Abortion is not the answer, there is adoption. My last objection towards Thomson is that it is the woman's fault that they are pregnant they need to accept the consequences.Even with contraception, there is a small chance that you accept. By having sex you are agreeing to take the risk. Now because that risk came up doesn't mean you have the right to have an abortion. You agreed to risk now this is your

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Then she tries to terminating a fetus because they do not want to take responsibility for those consequences. If you can make an adult decision to sleep with someone then you should be responsible for the consequences whatever they may be. The consequence of having an abortion is not…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    just like any house people allowed are to do what they please to their house why should abortion be any different? However, either way, someone’s right will be taking away either the mother or the fetus. But, the fetus is of the mother therefore, you can't take away the mother's right to life because she has a right to do what she wants with her body. If the mother says to save the fetus then that is a choice that she has made which means that in this case letting the mother die is justifiable. If the mother does not give that choice in a case of an emergency then the doctors cannot make the decision to save the baby or fetus over the mother.…

    • 1308 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    She wishes to sway the ideas of those who are against abortion by challenging the arguments they give for thinking so. She is challenging the common argument those who are against abortion use by presenting situations similar yet different. She states “what I have been asking is whether or not the argument we began with, which proceeds only from the fetus’s being a person, really does establish its conclusion, I have argued that is does not.” In conclusion, I feel she brings appropriate points on the table to defend her argument. It is true that the basic argument is not an accurate argument or one that can be used for every case. She isn’t claiming that abortions are always permissible or that it is permissible to secure the death of an unborn child.…

    • 1953 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Argument On Abortion

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages

    I also hear that if a woman wants to have intercourse and does not want to get pregnant, than she should be using some type of birth control. I will argue why these statements are not true whatsoever. Most people believe that all people should accept the consequences to their actions, and that is something I believe as well. This is probably why pro-lifers argue that abortion is wrong because the women chose to have sex and now she needs to be willing to accept that child that she is now pregnant with, or the “consequence” of her actions. Often enough, though, a woman ends up pregnant even when she has taken necessary steps to not get pregnant, such as using contraceptives.…

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Christian Abortion Essay

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages

    We would all want the ability to fix a wrong act once it occurs, but unfortunately that is not how life works. People who are pro-choice (abortionists) want the ability to fix a mistake without facing any consequences. The concept that one can just have unprotected sex without any ramification is what people who are pro-choice really want. However, just like what Galatians 6:7 says, and how one will reap the consequences of his or her actions. Sadly, people always try to find a way to bypass the effects of their actions.…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Thomson and Hursthouse both have come to the conclusion that abortion is impermissible but there are acceptable situations in which abortion should be permitted. In my opinion I agree with both Thomson and Hursthouse but in the end the conclusion of Hursthouse is the view I could see making both sides of abortion acceptable. When a woman and man conceive a baby knowingly, getting an abortion will only occur in the event of a health risk or the chances of the baby living after birth will be so minimum. By choosing abortion before letting the child get to full term is less painful than carrying the baby to full term and giving themselves false hope. It is understandable that some may want to fight for that chance but there is the option of abortion.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Abortion Issues

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In such cases pro-choice supporters may feel that abortion is the answer. It seems unreasonable to various women overall, when a woman could be made to have a baby that happened out of a rape or incest. Nevertheless, the main emphasis of pro-choice is not really any these issues, it is the right to…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pro-choice also advocates that abortion is a safe procedure, it is not about how safe abortion, but about the fetus(future human) that one is terminating. The ability for women to control their body is basic rights, but when it is about a human being they are depriving a life, it is not about basic right or any kind of rights. Another opinion pro-choice members indicate is that tax dollars that fund abortion give both poor and rich women the same opportunity, the reason why some members of the pro-life community don’t want to pay tax dollars for abortion is because they are against and they do not believe in abortion. Many teenagers who give birth, tend to quit school and a grim prospect of life. Although, many do, many…

    • 1163 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    What I would like to discuss in this paper are the philosophical arguments regarding abortion. These arguments are deontological. I am going to talk about the reasons why certain pro-life parties believe Abortion is immoral and wrong. I am also going to talk about why the pro-choice parties believe abortion should not be mandated by the government, but should be a choice made by the woman. The pro-life parties believe that abortion should be illegal, generally for these reasons; the moral right to life of a person begins at conception, induced abortions are an unjust killing which violate the fetus’s right to life, and that the law should not allow such unjust violations to life.…

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although there is a varias reasons to why abortion should be illegal, the main one is that it kills innocent babies that have not yet to live their lives. “I think life is sacred, whether it’s abortion or the death penalty.” (Tim Kaine, Brainy Quotes) This is stating that all life is precious and that no one should be killed, everyone should have a chance to live. In conclusion, There is so much controversy in America about abortion and using a feminist lens I believe that most women should have the choice of whether or not they want to make a life in the stomach. I think the ultimate solution to this problem isn’t making it illegal, it’s letting people decide on their own, and let people do what they want with their bodies, just like people being transgender, and people getting abortions. There’s people that will disagree with people having abortions, and there is people that won’t, but there is also people who don’t care about how other people live their lives, and what people decide to do with their bodies, and if people really cared about the child's life, there will be no kids in places like adoption, and foster homes.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays