Right Balance Of The Fetus Case Study

Decent Essays
What is the right balance of the fetuses “rights” and the mother’s rights of bodily integrity? Many would say the mother has sole authority to the decisions concerning her unborn fetus. Controversial issues arise once the fetus may be in potential danger. Finding the accommodating balance is both difficult and challenging.

Does the mother or the state have authority to make decisions concerning the fetus? This question is very difficult and needs evaluation and analyzing. Many individuals lean one way or the other. But which is morally correct? In the case of Tabita Bricci, her religion compromises the welfare of her baby. Bricci’s beliefs states that pregnancy should not be terminated until full term. Robertson and Schulman states, “Ethical
…show more content…
This question always comes about one way or another. Does the mother have more rights than that of a fetus? Analogies in Munson’s materials help us evaluate these types of situations and make informed, educated, morally right decisions. Robertson and Schulman state, “This balance will vary with the burdens of altering the mother’s conduct and the risk of prenatally caused harm to offspring. Depending on the balance of risk, benefits, and burdens, prenatal conduct may be discretionary, advisable, prudent, or even obligatory...” (Robertson and Schulman, p. 752). The rights of the mother should not completely be diminished because of the child’s welfare. Yet, the fetus has the right to be born healthy. We have to respect the mother’s wishes, but also the fetus’s wishes to remain healthy. Also, Minkoff and Paltrow have opinions about pregnancy and prenatal harm. The mother that is carrying the child still has rights to autonomy and control over herself. Yet, the fetus also has the right to life and right to life without harm. Minkoff and Paltrow states, “In so doing, they suggest a need to balance rights when those rights appear to conflict with each other, a potentially to subordinate the rights of the women to those of the fetus” (Minkoff and Paltrow, p. 757). Minkoff and Paltrow suggest that unborn children have rights and pregnant women have value. Altogether, there is a constant battle in finding the right “balance” of …show more content…
First we must decide if the fetus is indeed a person or not. Munson states, “The claim of the fetus as a person must be given weight and respect in deliberating about any action that would terminate its life” (Munson, p. 456). If we rule that a fetus is a person, then abortion would be a case of unjust killing (Munson, p.456). So, if a fetus is a person it, like all human beings, has the right to life and one without harm. This relates back to cases like that of Tabita Bricci. Her unborn child has wishes to be born healthy, yet Bricci’s religion alters the safety of the child. Munson states, “[I]t could be argued that, even though the fetus is not a person, it is a potential person, and thus is a significant and morally relevant property, /…/, because the fetus can become a person, abortion does present a moral problem” (Munson, p. 456). Therefore, determining the status of the fetus as a person relates to how it is view and acted

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In saying this, third parties are being allowed to speak on behalf of the fetus and out ruling the mother. This is a huge concern when it comes to pregnancy and prenatal harm. The mother that is carrying the child still has rights to autonomy and control over herself. Yet, the fetus also has the right to life and right to life without harm. Establishing a parity between the life of a fetus and the life of the mother is very difficult.…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Some people consider a fetus to be a rightful human being that should be respected, and some people are sure that during the initial stages of pregnancy, a few cells cannot be considered as a real human, and that’s why abortion should be allowed. There are some cases, when abortion should be allowed, as from the ethical points of view they might be considered…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Why should the parent who didn’t sign up the for this additional responsibility be forced to bear such responsibility? Scholars would argue that it is an issue of rights- the pregnant women’s right to not reproduce, that is, to abort a child she decides that she no longer wants, and the fetus’s right to life. An argument put forward by the DRC, Parental Attitude Argument provides some answers to the questions. The argument claims that using prenatal testing to select against some traits indicates a problematic conception of an attitude toward parenthood. For me, it raises the question of who is fit to be a parent?…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Plague Of Abortion

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages

    That is way adoption is in this world. If the mother does not want the baby, then make sure to give the baby to someone that will take care it and that will love it. Now, if the mother’s life is at stake, then I somewhat understand why the mother has to have an abortion, but I still do not agree with it. I do not know why, but I just do not agree. I just think that the child should at least be given a chance at life and the mother never knows.…

    • 1633 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Abortion Research Paper

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Women have the right to a choice when pregnant, to birth a child or to abort the fetus. To the pro-life community this is to show the other side of the table. Having an abortion is not a simple matter, a woman who has an abortion should not be considered…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is imperative to note that the beliefs of either stance on this debate have connotations attached to it. Pro-life supporters are ostracised due to the implications of considering unborn fetuses as being human and having equal rights as their mothers which then impedes on the rights of the mother to her own body. Pro-choice supporters, on the contrary, are viewed negatively for trivializing the unborn fetus because they are considered biologically dependent on the mother and therefore not considered an independent human with rights. An oversimplified perspective can differentiate pro-choice supporters as rallying for the rights of the mother while pro-life…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    What Is Abortion Ethical?

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this case, abortion is considered to be a reasonable procedure because the mother would have to be alive to keep the fetus alive. When it comes down to direct abortions, this principle brings up the moral dilemma on if the fetus has rights. Pro-life individuals believe that the fetus has rights and destroying the infant is an attack on the fetus’s rights. Then this principle is a way of proving direct abortions to be unethical because the second condition will not be verified. The agent would have to only intend the good effect and not the evil one.…

    • 1095 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    There is often a large dispute over abortion and when personhood begins. Some believe it is at fertilization, some think that it is a vague concept, and some believe that it is when the child is born. The common argument against abortion is the claim that the fetus is a person and therefore has a right to life. A philosopher, Judith Jarvis Thomson, believes that even if personhood begins at the stage of being a fetus, there are still times when it is moral to abort the fetus. She believes that personhood begins at a vague time, however she wants to prove even if the fetus is a person, she can provide times when it is still morally permissible to have an abortion.…

    • 1357 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, on the other hand pro-choice also makes a point about the physical safety of the mothers. For example what if the mother’s life was in danger if she went through with the birth? Would abortion be acceptable then? In other cases where women have experienced incest or rape, it seem almost unfair that they should have to keep the child after such a traumatic event. Every time the mother would look at her child she would be reminded of the horrifying experience.…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Essay On Abortion Issues

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages

    That she does not have to give birth just because she gets pregnant. Groups such as Human Life International (HLI), and The Christian Coalition, defend the rights of the unborn baby. The other side of this discussion, is known as pro-choice. A promoter of pro-choice encourages the woman’s right to choose and the babies’ life is secondary. The key dispute of “pro-choice advocates,” is that women ought to have the right to choose what happens to their own bodies.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays