What Does It All Doe Nagel Analysis

Superior Essays
Everyone knows the meaning of philosophy; the love of wisdom, but does everyone know that we are philosophers every day of our lives? In the book “What does it all mean?” Nagel discuses plenty of strong arguments on many topics. Some of them being, “How do we know anything?”, “Free will”, and “The meaning of life”. Nagel has discussed these three topics based on human nature, our perception, and the external world. One of the topics, “How do we know anything?” relates to what exists in one’s mind, if it even exists and whether we view ourselves to be the only thing that exist and everything being just a figment of our own reality and imagination. “Free will” is argued to be either true or false, depending on one’s beliefs about determinism, believing that any choice we make is inevitable making us question if free will even exists.
Is it all in our heads? “If you think about, it the inside of your own mind is the only thing you can be sure of.” These exact words are on the book “What
…show more content…
He calls this determinism. The fact that all our decisions are already determined therefore leaving us with no free will. He then argues that if someone were to steal something from you, can you really hold him responsible if it is true that determinism is a thing? Can you blame him for his wrongful upbringing that has led to him being tempted to steal something of yours? “Others think that it still makes sense to praise good actions and condemn bad ones, even if they were inevitable.” Nagel explains that determinism a controversial topic. If determinism was true, then why do we scold people for wrongful doing and praise others for good deeds if at the end of the day every one of their decision were already preselected and everything was supposed to happen the way it

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Determinism is a philosophical idea that attempts to place all events that occur as inevitable as they are predetermined by previous events and the laws of nature. However there are many who came to be known as indeterminists who reject the notion that free will is absent from the process that causes events to occur. Indeterminists believe that there are possible events that have different probabilities of occurring based on human beings free will. Then Chisholm’s view of the agent-casual theory presents humans as always going through a decision process when making an action that leads up to an event they work through their desires in first and second order volitions and then they act. These actions are free from previous events and cannot…

    • 1580 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    In response to the above critique, this section will explore how Nagel might defend his argument. It does not suffice to examine moral luck in hypothetical situations. Moral luck is only applicable under real circumstances and to give it a suppositious critique is degrading to Nagel’s original argument. It is also important to clarify the term “luck,” and what it means when something is affected by luck. Lastly, if we accept the critique then it is crucial we consider how to apply judgment without involving factors of luck.…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Regarding the relationship between the body and the mind, people cannot avoid two important philosophy concepts:, Physicalism, and Functionalism. Physicalism believes that the only substance exist is physical. Functionalism suggests that mental states are the internal cause of behavior.(Braddon-Mitchell&jackson p41). In this paper, I will mainly discuss four perspectives about Physicalism, Functionalism and the argument “ What is it like to be”. First, what’s Physicalism?…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Psychologically speaking, as humans, we are wired to think that we have the freedom to act and do based upon our own self judgment. For simplistic reasons, let’s assume that this “freedom” is analogous to free will which is a philosophical idea in which to act freely is to have multiple open futures and possibilities, or to be able to choose between many different choices. Determinism is the belief that every event (including action, choices, and decisions) is the inevitable result of a causal chain of events. In other words, a choice with an action (A) is the inevitable result of an earlier action of an earlier choice. This principle presents a problem for the concept of free will.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Fahrenheit 451, Bradbury shows us what happens in a society where literature is prohibited, causing some individuals to ask why things are the way they are, rather than settling. These individuals are frowned upon because they question. In this dystopian society, questions lead to revelations, which are considered a major issue. In Fahrenheit 451, the protagonist Guy Montag started off as the individual who was comfortable with the rules of society, especially because he was the one who did the damage by setting houses on fire. He describes it as “a pleasure to burn.”…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The debate of Free Will v Determinism is one that has gone on for centuries, and shall continue to go on for many to come. There are many who believe that their view is the end all, be all, correct view to hold. While not all of these thinkers are correct in their standings, Paul Holbach’s essay, “The Illusion of Free Will,” lays out a strong argument for universal determinism; man does not have any free will, and all of his actions are determined by the laws of nature. His argument is one that is accurate and strong, leaving little to criticize, despite what many believe to be proof that he is incorrect: the presence of choice and the absence of restraint. He takes these two beliefs and shows exactly why they do not denote free will, and all…

    • 2442 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas Nagel is a New York University professor and has written many things regarding the mind and moral theory. In moral luck Nagel thinks through the whole Kantian view of morality which shows that everyone is equal participants in the moral enterprise. Nagel argues that the Kantian view is too simple and doesn’t take into account the way external factors impinge upon us. Nagel brings up four different types of moral luck: constitutional luck, circumstantial luck, consequential luck which means consequences retrospectively justifies an otherwise immoral act (or fail to justify an otherwise more act), and consequential luck which the consequences affect the type or quality of blame or remorse (or moral praise). Having luck, whether it be good or bad, should impact how a person should act towards things.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bill ****** Professor Aaron ******* Philosophy 100 Creating Ourselves So many questions loom when we think about how we are what we are. Do we all know what makes us…us? Are we just the shell for something inside to control us? Are we all driven by what our minds create us to do?…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Audience: N/A 3) Thesis: Human Action is not dominated by our cognition but our free will. - Main Point of First Paragraph: He focuses on the idea of free will. Also, he provides examples that support his topic sentence; such as, the U.S and Russia's decision to continue to create nuclear defenses, knowing the…

    • 862 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The meaning of life is a highly controversial topic among humans; one that has been debated for centuries. A particular philosopher, Thomas Nagel, has a certain idea about what the meaning of life. However, I do not agree with his position. Essentially, he believed that life has no meaning and that there is no rationale that could be given to it in order to make it meaningful. Nevertheless, even if everything we do in life will be forgotten, that does not mean humans cannot find meaning in their everyday life.…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This means that we as humans have freedom to respond to our circumstances and that reaction may be different then another person who faced the exact same circumstances. With free will each person has control over their own actions and their actions are voluntary. Determinism means that behavior is caused by heredity…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction I. In this paper, I will be arguing for the following claim that we, human beings are not predetermined beings, but rather we have free will. It has long been argued that people are not free and do not have free will; that rather than having free will we live in a world that is predetermined. That our choices and actions are reflections of and happen because of a long line of other choices and action that caused the present, and thus we have a fixed future. This is just not the case.…

    • 2102 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He states “According to the hard determinist, an action is free if it is within my power to perform it and also within my power to not perform it. According to the soft determinist, an action is free if it is…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, the question always remains the same. Do we actually have free will? And how can we be certain that we are fully exercising it? For centuries, many Philosophers have argued, whether Free Will exist and as human…

    • 1101 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Free Will and Determinism have been discussed by philosophers for many years. Free will is associated with moral responsibility, and alternative actions that “could have” been taken over the one chosen. Determinism is the opposite view, and is associated with universal causation, and a lack of free will. Determinists believe that a person’s actions are inevitable, they are dictated by a person’s experiences, they believe nurture, nature, and even a person’s genes determine their future actions. Because of this determinists believe people hold no moral responsibility for their actions.…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays