The Danger Of Telling Poor Kids Analysis

Decent Essays
In "The Danger of Telling Poor Kids That College Is the Key to Social Mobility" posted on The Atlantic on January 16, 2014, writer and teacher Andrew Simmons states his thoughts and ideas about higher education to the impoverished population and why it isn 't for poor kids. He recently had a high school student write an essay about what she wants to do with her future. She had been told, rather preached to, that if she, "made good grades and a ticket to a good college would lead to a good job, one that would guarantee her financial independence"(para. 2). He acknowledges the fact that "they don 't mean to suggest that there is no other point to higher education" (para 3), but he also argues the fact that they are told to go to college it 'll …show more content…
He says from one of his students, that “She’d been encouraged to think of college foremost as a path to socioeconomic mobility.” (para 2). He argues, this is not true for everyone. He is correct. In paragraph 3 it says, “Administrators, counselors, and teachers repeat again and again that a college degree will alleviate economic hardship”, it misleads many to believe that they won’t make it, or be successful, without a college degree, even though this is not what they mean at all. Another point that he makes is that, “most attend state schools” (para 5), but also he acknowledges the fact that most, “don’t necessarily understand its significance” (para 5). Kids will go to college due to the fact they are told to not because they want to and or have a reason to. They are just doing as they were taught to do by their teachers, counselors, and administrators as they progressed through high school. Students also don’t know what they will be facing when they choose a career, they don’t have an understanding of its inner workings. Andrew Simons declares, “Students hear that being a doctor is great because doctors make money, enjoy respect and have a great life. They don’t hear that being a doctor is great because doctors possess the expertise to do great things.” (para 9). I know in many ways college is good, for some, but college is not for everyone and it is dangerous to tell those who do not need to hear

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    He reiterates “Not every young person is suited to four years of college. They may be bright and ambitious but they won’t get much out of it. They’d rather be doing something else, like making money or painting murals. They feel compelled to go to college because they’ve been told over and over that a college degree is necessary.” Although this may seem trivial, it is in fact crucial because there many individuals out there that aspire to become things--such as chefs, mechanics, or cosmetologists, but do not need to attend a 4 year institution for those careers. In my experience with friends and…

    • 1093 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    All throughout high school you 're pressured by your guidance counselors and parents to go to college because it is right path to take in life. Maybe not everyone is meant to go to college and they might have a different calling in life. There are people who have never been to college and are doing way better than people who actually received their master 's or doctoral degree. Going to college is esteemed and respected pretty much anywhere in the world. Most people go to college only for the money they’ll be getting paid or the title of being a college graduate.…

    • 1019 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I do not agree with this statement, I believe that college will help you in the long run with the job you are looking at no matter what kind of job it is. But, when Bird says “My unnerving conclusion is that students are sad because they are not needed”(Bird 430). She is correct, most high schools willnot treat you correctly in order for you to be “college ready.” Some high schools will still be asking seniors to turn in their work that was due four days ago. That is not preparing them for college at all, they need to grow up and realize they will not be treated like that in college. So, when they get to college and they are not getting babied anymore, they feel like they are “not needed.” They are not sure how to live in the real world since they have been treated like this their whole life.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When attending college, teenagers shouldn’t have to feel the pressure to go. Reasons some feel the pressure is because parents pressure them and it is the only way to get a job. Many parents agree and want all their kids to attend college right after high school putting a lot of pressure on the kids to successed and not fail. Some people argue against taking a year off or known as a gap year. Some students instead of going straight to college because of pressure they take a gap year to think about what they want to do or to work and make money.…

    • 700 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the United States of America today there seems to be this expectation that one must go to college or they are considered unsuccessful and looked down upon. There are numerous reasons I believe college is not for everyone. Every person is unique, school may not be there thing, and in my opinion, there is nothing wrong with a person going directly into the work force after high school. Also college degrees are becoming worth less and less as more people attend college and end up in careers that have nothing to do with their degree or dropping out which is ultimately wasting their own and the government’s money. A majority of kids chose to go away to college for the “social aspect” so they say, which we know just means partying and drinking.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Both Trudeau and Reeves believe that even though students attend class, some of them do not put in the additional time and effort to make the class beneficial for them. Some of these points being that some college students do not read outside of class to know what will be talked about or reviewed during the next class period. I believe many students who do not attend class and are tardy because they care could care less if they go to college and earn a degree. I think the majority of students are expected to go to college from their parents, relatives, and other people in their community when all they really want to do is have fun, make new friends, and make their own decisions without being told what to do. Some of these students who have been told what they can and cannot do throughout their lives are the students who rebel the most in college.…

    • 1424 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Many concerned parents think about their child or children’s education, but not all parents have the resources to send their child or children on to higher education. The only hard decision a child should have to make concerning college is choosing which school is best for them after high school. If a person wants to go on to college after high school, it should not have to be a difficult decision based on a nonexistence of monetary contributions. Unfortunately for most children in American families the lack of awareness of preparing for the future of the child or children in the home for continued education has caused many children to become stifled in the pursuit of a college degree. I being a college student myself understand the challenges that a student can face working towards a degree; especially if the student is a first generation college student.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Universities and High Schools push their students to educate themselves from the material that this organization has to offer. Unfortunately, some students aren 't that motivated, but if the CRF is instituted in schools, rather than missing this information, they will have been exposed to these resources many times before. Scholarships.com was able to identify the five main reasons that high school students do not continue on to college. 1) Students do not believe that they will be able to afford college. 2) They believe they make enough money at their current jobs.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    If an individual is serious about school and intends to get a degree they will use in life, the stress and long hours will be well worth it, but for a student who is not interested in college or who doesn 't need a degree for the career the individual has chosen, college is a waste of their time and money. In "What 's Wrong With Vocational Schools?" Charles Murray states "Large numbers of those who are intellectually qualified for college do not yearn for four years of college-level courses they go to college because their parents are paying for it and college is what children of their social class are supposed to do after they finish high school." Someone who does not like the idea of college but who is going anyway to please those around them can get very depressed because he/she is not pursuing what makes them happy in life. We should not let ourselves get pressured into doing something that isn 't right for us just because society says so.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I was forced into a community college when I first graduated high school because my parents said that I would not get a job without a degree and they did not want me to struggle as they did and currently do without an education. I was forced into college. It was not until I graduated did I fully believe that college was beneficial. I had teachers and counselors have a lack of faith in myself throughout high school that I personally felt that college was something I would never be able…

    • 1613 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays