Ruth Macklin's Case Study

Decent Essays
Qu Yaoxian assignment 3 Reaction to Bill Moyers Interview with Ruth Macklin Ruth Macklin, professor of bioethics at Albert Einstein College of Medicine in New York, addressed a number of ethical controversies in her interview with Bill Moyer. One of the phenomenons that Bill Moyer brought up is that nowadays, many women face criminal prosecution because of their addiction to drugs and drinking during their pregnancy. Consequently, the phenomenon led to the question of whether a woman has autonomy over her unborn children and whether these women should be punished. This paper will summarize Macklin’s answer to this question and give an analysis to the answer. Macklin’s response to the question is yes, women do extend their autonomy over

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Every unborn child should have the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness in the second and third trimester. In 2010, research shows that states indicated that unborn children are considered humans under tort, property and criminal law (Roden, 2010). By these laws shown, a mother shouldn’t get to choose whether the fetus lives or dies. The unborn child is its own person and by a mother aborting her own child should be considered murder. Under law a child is supposed to be born for many different reasons, including being capable of having a legacy (Roden, 2010).…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Abortion Essay Rough Draft One half of pregnancies among American women are unintended, and four in ten of these are terminated by abortion. Abortion is a widely debated issue today, with many legal, social, and political implications. This essay discusses the ethical issues of abortion, up until the first trimester, more specifically who should be allowed to have one, whether or not the fetus has rights, the government’s place in abortion, and the level of access of abortion. Abortion should continue to be legal and readily available, and decisions made about it should be left between woman and her doctor. Abortion has been used to control reproduction throughout history.…

    • 1957 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Phil 3 Dakota Wensley Phil 3 The purpose of this paper is to analyze Judith Jarvis Thompson’s argument for the permissibility of abortion in the cases of consensual sex when contraception was used. This paper will be divided into four parts. I am going to present Thompson’s argument and analogy and present the premises and conclusion, I will then put forth the best argument against Thompson’s argument and compare the two on the basis of logic and truth, next I will attempt to speak for Thompson and try to rebuttal on her behalf, and finally I will decide which argument is better and provide reasons for my decisions.…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This question always comes about one way or another. Does the mother have more rights than that of a fetus? Analogies in Munson’s materials help us evaluate these types of situations and make informed, educated, morally right decisions. Robertson and Schulman state, “This balance will vary with the burdens of altering the mother’s conduct and the risk of prenatally caused harm to offspring. Depending on the balance of risk, benefits, and burdens, prenatal conduct may be discretionary, advisable, prudent, or even obligatory...”…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Ruth Langran Camlin was born and raised in Dublin. She worked as a primary school teacher from 2003 until 2014 after which she wrote her first book on the topic of vision. During her teaching career she spent two years at Hillsong International Leadership College in Sydney, Australia studying Worship and Creative Arts and Pastoral Leadership. Her time in Australia was a significant part of her journey, as God planted a vision within her. This vision has influenced every area of her life and has also inspired her to see others live out their God-given purpose to the full.…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the essay “Why Abortion is Immoral,” philosopher Don Marquis uses utilitarian principles to argue that “abortion is, except in rare cases, seriously immoral… [and] in the same category as killing an innocent human being” (223). However, he deliberately avoids relating his thesis to abortion in the specific contexts of rape, maternal death, and severe postpartum health complications. Thus, in my analysis of his claim, I plan on adopting Marquis’ utilitarian perspective to evaluate the permissibility of abortion in regard to these delicate scenarios. I will begin my paper by giving a brief summary of “Why Abortion is Immoral.”…

    • 1937 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Case Reflection: State Paternalism and Pregnant Women The case of “State Paternalism and Pregnant Women” is overwhelmingly fascinating as well as very controversial. In fact, this case was so controversial it went all the way to the Supreme Court before a decision was finally reached. Personally, I was unsure of where I stood on this specific issue the first time I read it but ultimately I came to agree with the supreme court’s decision that protected the right of pregnant women from being arrested due to positive drug tests that were given to the police, without the patient’s knowledge or consent. Although I find this case very intriguing, I chose this case to do a reflection on based upon the overwhelming amount of ethical questions…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Roe V. Wade Problem

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Thousands of children are in a “life or death” situation, in which their life is chosen by the mother. The mother decides, without seeing or knowing the baby, whether to keep or abort the child. Abortion has caused many outbreaks throughout history and has influenced the world that we live in today. Over time, this controversial issue has divided people. Restrictions on abortions were challenged among the sexual revolution and feminist movements of the 60’s (“Roe v. Wade (1973) para.…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jonathan Vennard PHIL 313 – Contemporary Ethical Issues Case Study #1 – CRACK: Get Sterilized, Get Cash The Project Prevention: Children Requiring a Caring Kommunity (C.R.A.C.K.) movement would be a morally permissible act from a utilitarian viewpoint because the organization’s motives are set on the principles of reducing the number of careless pregnancies, in order to reduce the number of children born into foster care or unsafe living conditions. The utilitarian perspective would support this reduction of pregnancies by substance abusers because it would provide less burden for the members of society who are law-abiding and dutiful to the communities in which they live. As shared in Morality Play, though there may be morally permissible…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Caring for Pregnant Women and Newborns the Criminal Justice Professional care throughout any women’s pregnancy is imperative. Without adequate care, a women and her unborn child can experience serious health related consequences including death. Ethical dilemmas arise from situations such as inadequate funding or resources for the care of newborns and pregnant women in the criminal justice system. Federal and state laws also require the confinement of incarcerated pregnant and laboring women. In addition to the shackling of pregnant prisoners, the ethical dilemma regarding the newborn’s well-being is prevalent.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    So the fetus has a right to life. No doubt the mother has a right to decide what shall happen in and to her body; everyone would grant that. But surely a person’s right to life is stronger and more stringent than the mother’s right to decide what happens in and to her body, and so outweighs it. So the fetus may not be killed; an abortion may not be performed.” The remainder of her paper is a series of analogies meant to challenge the basic argument mention above.…

    • 1953 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The feminist perspective believes that the decision to abort a pregnancy should be made by the pregnant woman. In her article “Abortion Through a Feminist Ethics Lense,” Susan Sherwin advocates for women taking control of their reproductive lives because they are often subordinate and unable to control their own sexuality. In terms of the fetus, feminists see it as relational to the female carrying it. Personality is valued instead of existence according to this theory (Sherwin). Abortion is an issue that directly relates to female rights, and feminists believe women should be granted the right to choose abortion if desired or…

    • 1777 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Abortion is wrong, but no one should be judged for the actions and/or decisions they make. Every human being that breathes, walks, and thinks, can decide what to do with their body. In this paper I agree with Don Marquis’s view of abortion. Abortion is wrong because it deprives the fetus from its future. In other words, abortion is wrong because killing a future child stops it from growing and making a difference to their lives.…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The hypotheticals are very interesting and mind stimulating. It is interesting to explore how these situations relate to the biomedical principles. Principles such as the respect for autonomy and beneficence are especially important in all of the hypothetical situations. The common theme in all of these hypothetical situations is abortion. In this paper, I will talk about the following hypotheticals: Abortion and Psychopathology, Sterilization of an Economically Deprived Woman and Hypothetical Number Two.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    She presents the view that the right of the mother to her bodily integrity carries greater value than the right to life of the fetus. She presents very convincing cases in instances where the pregnancy is due to violence – through rape or abuse, and a somewhat weaker argument that applies to unwanted pregnancies that occur even though reasonable precautions had been…

    • 1880 Words
    • 8 Pages
    • 1 Works Cited
    Brilliant Essays