Rhetorical Analysis Of Coca Cola Company Vs Grove Press

Improved Essays
Back in 1970, there was a small conflict between the Coca-Cola company and Grove Press because the book publishing company was being accused of using the slogan “It’s the real thing,” a phrase Coca-Cola had been using for approximately 27 years, as advertisement for one of their books. The issue here was that the beverage corporation thought this would cause some sort of confusion to the public, even though the two products were not related in any way. Several rhetorical strategies are used throughout the two letters between Ira C. Herbert of the Coca-Cola company and Richard Seaver of Grove Press, but it was the latter who made a better use of them by presenting a more convincing argument.
In the first letter exchanged by the two companies, we have an executive of the Coca-Cola company, Mr. Herbert, claiming the slogan belong to them and that Grove Press should cease making used of it to advertise the book Diary of a Harlem Schoolteacher by Jim Haskins. He mentions the purpose behind this is for there to be no misunderstandings, and refusing to agree to his request would “dilute the distinctiveness” and “diminish its effectiveness”
…show more content…
If Herbert had made a better use of rhetorical devices, he would’ve more than likely gotten away with what he wanted, but since he had the confidence of being backed up by one of the biggest companies, he simply assumed there was no way the book publishing company would refuse to accept his request of making them stop using a slogan Coca-Cola thought only they could use. It might’ve been the simplicity and lack of effectiveness of the first letter that gave Grove Press the opportunity of coming up with a greater comeback, just by using the right rhetorical strategies and knowing how to apply them to a letter that the Coca-Cola company might never

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The exchange of letters between Richard Seaver and Ira Herbert is a short conversation on the right to a slogan for advertising. Mr Herbert from Coca-Cola expressed his wish that Grove Press would discontinue their use of "It's the real thing" since Coke had used it long before Grove Press. Seaver's response was a sarcastic explanation of steps that will be taken and methods to avoid confusion. Because of the tone presented in Seaver's response , Herbert's letter appears much better written and more appropriate for the situation.…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout, his letter Seaver addresses it toward Herbert. Seaver purpose about his letter was to express the situation and misunderstanding that took place with Coke slogan. The part that Seaver mostly focused on is how many people would get confused by the…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He also in a way combined the rhetorical strategies of ethos and sarcasm when he states how sympathetic they are towards them using Coca-Cola's slogan and how they had no intention or idea that they had already been using the slogan. Another is how Seaver mocks Herbert over the topic of confusion that would be caused because of both companies using similar slogans. Seaver's use of sarcasm comes into an, even more, effect when he gets to the point on how people could mistakenly buy a book instead of a Coca-Cola because of the confusion caused from the advertisement of both companies. Seaver's letter was more persuasive since it was able to counter-argue all the points made in Herbert's letter and to an extent even mock Herbert at the same time which was a great way to keep the letter interesting to readers as they…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    After reading the rhetorical analysis, Essay about the Coca-Cola commercial, "Anthem" I gave the student a B. In my opinion, the student exhibited her ability to adhere to the guidelines of the assignment. The essay was effective at showcasing a commercial created within the past 3 years, identifying the year aired, reaching her intended target audience (high school students), as well as, ensuring that the commercial was within the acceptable time limitation of 30-60 seconds. For those reasons, I gave the student a full 20 in the criteria for genre/audience. Concerning the criteria for focus, I gave the student 16/20 because I feel that the student was effective in maintaining the main idea of the essay, however, did not maintain the stance of each paragraph. For example, the paragraph meant to touch base on the influence of American culture provided examples of elements within the American culture such as sharing stories, sharing smiles, sharing exciting parts of life but did not elaborate on what makes them unique and influential in American society.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Rubin begins with a good example of Academic writing which is brief facts on the history of the Coca-Cola Company’s rise to the eminence throughout that small amount of information given. She points out the sturdy alliances of Coca-Cola with American Patriotism. Which would have existed in the average audience’s minds? By doing this she puts, the ad in the context of a freshly post-World War II America. “Just a few years after World War II and at the beginning of the Korean War, the setting clearly reflects the idea that Americans experienced increased industrialization and urbanization as a result of World War II” (Rubin 248).…

    • 946 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Rubin states “We can learn a great deal about the prevailing culture by looking closely at the deliberate ways a company crafts an ad to particular audiences” (246). Although both Hill and Rubin presents their evidence through visuals, Rubin largely relies on her factual evidence of the ad rather than through making unverified claims like Hill. These facts include her knowledge and research of the time period that the Coca-Cola ad was created in; she analyzes the problems of the society in that time period and makes a logical judgement of how the ad was portrayed to affect the Coca-Cola audience. Rubin writes, “By placing the servicemen so prominently, Coca-Cola emphasizes their important role in society” (249). This example of Rubin’s evidence corresponds with the current situation of America being that they were in war in this time period.…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Nike was founded in late 1960s and since it has been the leading sport selling product in America with its slogan “just do it”. Nike has thousands of advertisement, but this one stands out to me. To me it represent that Nike does not only make one pair of shoes for specific sport,but for all of them. The advertisement is trying to show consumers how yes, their product maybe expensive, but you will not only be using it for one sport or hobby. Sports is a big thing in the american culture, but to play a sport you need the equipment.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He further addresses the issue that using particular words, can disguise the true meanings visually, verbally, or both (79). Sanders also points out that words have so much power in influencing peoples’ choices, that numerous companies are willing to invest money into advertising alone since it works so well in promoting consumerism (80). In extreme cases, words can even mask life and death situations (81-82). Example. Moreover, he tries to persuade people to analyze the labels and slogans of products we encounter or use: “We can insist that torture is torture, murder is murder, poison is poison.…

    • 1104 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Advertisements have been the driving force for companies to get people to buy the product that the company is selling. For example, the “Share a Coke” Coca-Cola commercial has been one of the most successful commercials that the Coca-Cola company has made. The commercial is success because the commercial uses appeals to persuade the audience to buy their Coca-Cola sodas. Appeals have certain aspects such as credibility or proof of a certain subject, the use of logic, or emotions according to the essay, “Advertising’s Fifteen Basic Appeals” by Jib Fowles. Furthermore, the “Share a Coke” Coca-Cola commercial has been successful due to appeals from “Advertising’s Fifteen Basic Appeals” by Jib Fowles; examples of the appeals include pathos and the need of affiliation are what the Coca-Cola commercial “Share a Coke” influenced the audience into buying the Coca-Cola sodas.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Beyoncé Style Jambalaya: Lemonade Beyoncé’s visual album Lemonade goes beyond the supposed emotional turmoil of her marriage with Jay-z. Throughout the album and film, Beyoncé touches on subjects of social injustices and black culture while also incorporating various genres and other successful celebrities. Through Beyoncé’s visual album “Lemonade”, Beyoncé does what any Beyoncé fan (or observer) would expect her to do, she performs greatly to her equally as great music. But not only is “Lemonade” a musical masterpiece, but also a firm demonstration of how Beyoncé is an Unapologetic Black Woman and feminist. Emotional Turmoil: Beyoncé begins her album with a prologue “praying to catch” Jay-z “whispering” along with “praying” he’ll actually…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Coca Cola uses absolutely all existing means for communication on a massive scale for their products to reach an indeterminate public and integrated into a…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This advertisement intrigued me because of its focus on the subject of war bonds, a subject that I had never seen before on an advertisement in our modern society, where war bonds are not prevalent. The big, black, bold letters at the top of the advertisement, “Buy United States War Bonds and Stamps” stood out to me and instantly caught my attention, and the Coca-Cola bottle cap next to the words also made me wonder, “Why is a product like Coca-Cola on an advertisement for war bonds?” The advertisement also attempts to appeal to the common citizen, talking about how life is changing in everyone’s daily lives because of the war and consistently using plural pronouns such as “we” and pronouns directed at the reader like “you.” It’s almost as…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction For my rhetorical analysis assignment, I analyzed “Apple Style Guide” by Apple Inc. This style guide is intended for use by writers, editors, and developers as a reference to writing style, usage and Apple product terminology. Writers and editors should pay close attention to this guide as it can help them become familiar with topics involved in creating high-quality, dependable materials and documents.…

    • 2537 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Commercials are a part of our everyday life. They are on television, radio, in magazines, and in newspapers. They pay large amounts of money for a prime-time spot on the most popular programs on TV like the Super Bowl. Commercial designers work tremendously hard to surpass one another for the most creative and exciting commercials on television to gain consumer recognition. Nike is a brand that is popular with athletes of all kinds and also with the general public both athletic and non-athletic.…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Trademark Law

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Essentially, similarity was to be determined from an angle of the consumer of the products in question and involved the application of the test that was imperfectly recollected. The court ruled out possibility of material similarity between Coca-Cola’s three registered trademarks and the Pepsi Company’s Carolina bottle and their combination sign which clearly distinguished the Pepsi Company’s offering in the market, it followed that no issuance of confusion or deception would come up whatsoever[9]. Moreover, PepsiCo’s argument that the use of other elements inherent in their sign, along with the ‘Carolina bottle’ distinguishes their distinctive marks entirely . It was found by the fullcourt, that the alleged marks are not capable of so nearly resembling the other trade mark and poses no real or tangible danger of deception or confusion…

    • 1458 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays