The Holy Catholic Church

Great Essays
From humble beginnings to an oppressive doctrine, the Holy Catholic Church truly underwent change throughout the course of Medieval history. Seen in these two letters, Clericis Laicos and Unam Sanctam, are what would seem to be the culmination of all this history: the responses of Pope Boniface VIII to the continued pressures of secular rule and its jurisdiction in relation to the Church and its functioning. With the Church’s rapid increase in size and influence over the past several centuries, coupled with the Kingship’s long history of overreaching ecclesiastical authority, finally a breaking point had been reached. Here is seen, in final, Pope Boniface VIII declaration of the Church’s universal supremacy over all matters of life. The Church, …show more content…
Society was highly ritualized and salvation was thought to be acquired through one’s participation in the Church’s sacraments. To be excluded from such services, to anyone living at that time, meant certain damnation, and thus was a powerful tool instrumental in the Church’s coercion of leaders and its rise to power. This connects well back to our primary document, in particular Pope Boniface VIII’s Clericis Laicos. In the letter, he describes his infuriation over laymen, that is the Emperor and other secular rulers, and their tendency of opposition towards the clergy. Apparently, in what was of recent time, the secular rulers had been abusing their jurisdiction towards the church, taxing and overall taking advantage of it. He also expresses his dissatisfaction with members of the Church and other religiously influential people in how they would comply to such demands with so little resistance, saying that they should rather fear God’s eternal judgement concerning their afterlife than man’s temporary influence on their earthly life. This, in all, leads him to make a decree that anyone who participates in the business of these transactions, whether they be secular rulers or church officials, will be excommunicated with no hope of redemption. A particularly poignant ruling, such is a great example of the Church utilizing its religious authority to hold powerful influence of secular rulers. …show more content…
This is well illustrated in Pope Urban II’s Call to Crusade in which, by much appeal to emotion and tradition, he was successfully able to influence armies of people to embark on the First Crusade, an expedition to reclaim Jerusalem, the Holy Land, and destroy the Arabs and Turks who had supposedly been persecuting their “Christian Brothers.” Among the persuasive arguments presented to his subjects throughout the various accounts of his call, the Pope declares that it’s their duty as Christians to serve God in reclaiming the holy land and stopping the persecution; he also, in one account, states his fear that, if Jerusalem is left in enemy hands, such will lead to the emergence of the Antichrist. However, likely his most persuasive reason or promise given to the people was that those who embarked on the journey would receive pardon of their sins and, essentially, if they died, a guaranteed spot in Heaven. Papal coercion at its finest, this promise likely was the reason for the large turnout during the first Crusade. This indeed goes towards illustrating the strong religious conviction of many persons in Medieval Europe, at least conviction towards personal salvation. This in mind, such a religious atmosphere adds to the conceivable effectiveness of the threat of excommunication within society; people indeed showed a great concern for salvation and, in some sense, great gullibility as

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Throughout medieval times, variables such as wealth, gender roles and the growing concern of witchcraft challenged the authority of the Church. Because each of these themes are unique to their circumstances and elicited different if not similar responses from both those involved and those observing, it is relevant to detect and understand why these different events took place, and what became of the people who drove these actions. In chapters four, five and six of Deane’s A History of Medieval Heresy and Inquisition, each of these themes respectively was discussed in detail. The first of the previously mentioned concepts that challenged the authority of the Church is wealth. This was problematic as a good Christian was thought to have few worldly possessions and pride, however once in power, the men of the church had an abundance of these.…

    • 601 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Among the ideas that the Enlightenment brought was the idea of a secular government. The hierarchy of the Church was not in favor of this at all, the Austria was one of the first countries to push secularization. It happened when “Joseph II denounced the existing concordat and moved energetically to restrict the rights of the church, seeking to build a modern, secular state … similar attacks on Church authority put the hierarchy on the defensive, and the prestige of the papacy suffered” (130). Because of Europe’s social changes, and its changing ideals of the role of the Church in government, from an overarching, imposing role, to a nonexistent role, the Church found itself under attack, and Pius IX saw his power diminished. The idea that the Church was to lose its power did not bode well with those at the highest levels within the Catholic Church.…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book “Let's Not Forget God” Scola expresses the belief that the history of religion and freedom can be described by the treatment of heretics. She argues the mass importance that the heretics played in shaping history in religious freedoms as well the structure of power through the Middle Ages as well. She supports this by pointing out the unspoken alliance between the church and state that is prominent throughout the time, possibly even strengthened by the common repression of the heretics. Not fully intending to do so, developments such as the Protestant Reformation led to the strengthening of bond of state and religion in attempt to reestablish “religious freedom” in Europe. The roots of unity and stability built on religion…

    • 255 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Evidently, religion influenced societal views and laws as well as conceiving punishments for those who acted opposingly, therefore forming…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Vows and Contracts in the Fourth Crusade” , Thomas Madden who has analyzed personal statements from the Fourth Crusade shows that in the clergy to Crusaders, they were told “that this war is right and just, and if you have a right intention in conquering this land and bringing it into Roman obedience, those who die after confession shall have part in the indulgence granted by the pope.” Crusaders were not only convinced that their actions were right, but also if they died, the reassurance of indulgence from sinning brought them relief. The Crusaders also fought “for the honor of the Holy Roman Church and the conquest of the Holy Land.” This justification shifted the crusade to one that waged against heretics instead of just a crusade against the Greeks. Madden also include that “reclaiming Constantinople for Catholicism would become the equivalent of reclaiming Jerusalem for Christendom…” This was because if they died, they would be granted indulgence and also fulfil their vows as a Crusader.…

    • 652 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Secularization Dbq Essay

    • 1523 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the period from 1560 to 1648, it can be asserted that it was a time of confessionalization but it is also valid to claim that it was one of secularization, according to some scholars. The theory that it was an age of confessionalization- that is, the collaboration between church and state, is logical when taking into account all the religious disagreements of the time such as the French Wars of Religion and the Thirty Years’ War and all that had to happen to bring peace because matters of the church and state were so intertwined. Secularization- the practice where “religion gradually became a matter of private conscience rather than public policy” - has it merits as well since matters of religion were becoming less and less frequent when…

    • 1523 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Middle Ages Dbq

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages

    During the Middle Ages the Pope was the most powerful man in Europe, so when Pope Urban the second said that “Muslims were the enemies of God”, people were quick to agree. The Pope originally had only intended for the knights to fight the war with the Muslims, but he was so inspiring that commoners decided to fight too.(Chrisp 14) Over 20,000 people made up the People’s Crusade, which was a group of commoners who were dedicated to the crusades, and “all in all about 150,000 men, women, and children became crusaders. ”(Nicolle 28) Within the year, knights and peasants from all over Europe set off towards Jerusalem.(Chrisp 14)…

    • 1220 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Reformation Dbq

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Reformation is a crucial time period, as the events that occurred during were essential elements in the shaping of European society thereafter. Through the protests of people like Martin Luther, the Roman Catholic Church’s power was significantly weakened, and monarchies rose to be the center of government. With the church moved aside, kings and queens made decisions based on their will for their city-state, rather than the church’s ideas regarding the well-being of society. Previous to the Reformation, priests and preachers sold indulgences, that at one point had a more purposeful meaning, but had become based on collecting profit for the church, and namely, the pope.…

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Religious Toleration Dbq

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ignited at the start of the 16th century by the nailing of a candid list on the door of a small German church, the Protestant Reformation introduced the Catholic Church to new thoughts and practices that left European Christians in a state of disbelief. After many disaccording new sects cut ties with the Church, scholars and rulers had a hard time to accept the new concept being introduced to them- religious toleration. While many accepted religious toleration many regions didn’t embrace it for it caused more diversity and disunity. The concept of religious toleration was feared by many of the leaders so they adapted the concept based on their sect.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Reformation Dbq

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This document addressed the abuse of indulgences and did not directly attack the Church or the Pope. He was excommunicated after some time, but he did not stop fighting the Church (HIST…

    • 1151 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Middle Ages in Europe was a time categorized in a few different topics. Some might say that the Middle Ages was an age of faith, an age of feudalism, a dark age, or a golden age. The Middle Ages was an age of feudalism and faith because faith was based around daily life, and feudalism categorized the people into groups and the faith unified them. In the Middle Ages feudalism was the unwritten rules that determined the relationship between a lord and vassals.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    These are the showing the hypocrisy that religious institutions may be committing, and also how religious text can be used to support both just and unjust ideals. These strategies were used to support the author’s…

    • 1149 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The crux of Calvin’s “Reply to Sadoleto” focuses on the theological criticisms of Roman Catholicism and the formation of Reformation theology. Calvin argues that the Roman Catholic Church first and foremost silenced the Gospel, which led to the perversion of the four things on which the safety of the church is founded, which are doctrine, discipline, the sacraments, and ceremonies (9). In order to purify these vital elements of the church, the Catholic Church needs to change its perspective on the understanding of true faith, the true church, and the authority of the universal church. Calvin believes that having the right understanding of faith is an integral part of Christian faith and a cornerstone of the church.…

    • 1212 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Medieval Europe as a society greatly shunned deviations from cultural norms or established religious orthodoxy. From this denouncement, persecution of minority groups was commonplace, and possibly even a defining trait of European society at the time. Notably, mistreatment of Jewish communities and supposed Christian heresies were the more common forms of religious persecution. Furthermore, even Christians could be subject to persecution, if certain individuals were accused of breaking ethical standards. Likely causes to these recurring instances of persecution may have stemmed from the lack of diversity, as well as the influential religious authority of the Catholic Church.…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Martin Luther was an influential scholar in the 16th century who changed the face of the Catholic church by sparking the beginning of the Protestant Reformation. To the Christian Nobility of the German Nation is one of the first works written by Luther in 1520. The text gives the reader an insight into the life of Luther, while he exhorts and rebukes the authority and ideals of the Roman Catholic Church. Within the text, Luther challenges the three main ideals of the Church and insinuates an ecclesiastical movement. Furthermore, I agree with Luther’s approach to completely disband all the metaphorical walls that the Romanists have developed in the attempt to revolutionize Church and State.…

    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays