Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior, By Amy Chua

Improved Essays
There are many different understandings of how a children is grown to learn and have the knowledge to succeed academically. Several people portrait a different image of their children’s potential and ability to achieve success. In Amy Chua’s essay “Why Chinese Mothers are Superior,” she writes a memoir of how she raised her two daughters following the Chinese culture. She describes what she did to help her daughters to achieve success academically even though her method was harsh. She did what was necessary for them to be at their best which meant thinking about their future. Those thoughts about the future are counterfactual thoughts of what your options are that may happen in the future according to Alison Gopnik’s writing, “Possible Worlds: …show more content…
In Gopnik’s reading, there are people who believe that “Even when young children pretend or imagine they can’t distinguish between reality and fantasy: their fantasies, in this view, are just another kind of immediate experience. Counterfactual thought require a more demanding ability to understand the relation between reality and all the alternative to that reality”(164). Adults believe that children do not have the knowledge to tell apart what is real or fake. Only a person with experience can understand the relation between reality and fantasy is what most people think. Leading to the reason why most parents make decisions for their children because they believe they know best for them. They think for their future just as Chua has done for her daughters. Chua thinks counterfactually about the future of her daughters often because she believes “Chinese parents … know what is best for their children and therefore override all of their children’s own desires and preferences” (54). Chua wants her daughters to succeed no matter what, even if she makes every decision for them that will be beneficial to them in the future. She makes them do all the hard work until they excel in it while she thinks counterfactually about their future. Since she believes that she knows what’s best for her children by making every decision for them and, not giving them what they want but what they need to succeed. Chua believes that if she is making the decision for her daughters it would be better for them rather if they do it on their own. She does the counterfactual thinking for her daughter’s future while they do the hard work to succeed. Chua’s experience with going to a university and becoming successful she wishes for her daughter to achieve the same and to accomplish that wish she makes their decision for them. As most people believe that children don’t have the right

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    I hope to one day make her proud of the woman I have become, from the choices I have made, to the academic and athletic feats I have accomplished. Each day as my mother rises; I realize the opportunities I was given, that she wishes were present during her time. Opportunities that are stressed on me to fulfill, only for the well being of myself. At times, I never understood her constant support for things that seemed mediocre, and then I realized the reasons for the constant push; she was not so “privileged” growing up. Her youth was set with limits, from her parent to her country, limits she hoped would never interfere with the person she hoped I would one day be.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Jing- Mei’s mother tries to control her only because she knows how harsh the world is and she must direct her to a path she thinks is good for Jing-Mei. “Only two kinds of daughters, she shouted in Chinese. Those who are obedient and those who follow their own mind!” (Tan, 153) From the mother’s perspective the only way Jing-Mei can avoid pain is to be obedient to her mother. Her mother believes she knows what is best for Jing-Mei and the best way to obtain fulfilled hopes and dreams is to listen and follow her advice and…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “You have natural talent.” (828) Once her daughter had found a talent, she feels as if her daughter will have something in which no one can take from her. As the mother’s ambition rises, so do the standards for the daughter. “You could be a genius if you want to.” (828) Her mother is well meaning, but to the daughter she is overly forceful. Her mother looks back at her life in China, and wants a better life for her daughter. The exposition of “Two Kinds” is when Jing- Mei’s mother moved to the United States and had dreams of her daughter being a prodigy.…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    On to the first movie, it is clear that Leigh Anne is a strong and brave woman because she knew that motherhood is not just about taking good care of her biological kids. In fact, motherhood is also about taking good care of children not hers. Based on the discussion in the preceding section of this paper, Leigh Anne believed that as a mother, she should love her adopted child as much as she loves her biological children because there is no really different in them. This boils down to the notion that families do not have to match. Further, she knew that as a mother, she plays a vital role in shaping the future of her children.…

    • 1611 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She does wish however that she could have had a normal family life as a child but says her proudest moments in this stage of her life have been when her daughter adopted a baby and the birth of her great grandchild. . She looks forward to helping her family and living her life to the fullest. She told me that she was proud of her education and she got even though it was later in her life. She said when she was a child she believed a successful like was determined by your education and how much you can learn in a lifetime.…

    • 1087 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One can be successful if they act in a manner that best suits them. On the other hand, if they are goaded to do what they aren’t passionate about, they can’t expect an outcome. Amy Tan in her short story, “Two kinds” Mei Woo’s mother tries to forge her daughter into becoming a prodigy to outshine ordinary children. Hence, she tries to live vicariously through her daughter. Thus, there is a separation between…

    • 1275 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thesis: Superior versus Inferior Parenting Skills Being a mother of two girls my greatest wish is for both of them to be successful and happy in their lifetime. I often ask myself what is the best way to ensure that this happens. It is true that the way parents raise their children will decide how well the child grows, in particular the mothers who impact their children the most? Based on “Hanna Rosin’s” article Mother Inferior she states that some parents choose to only want their children to be happy. This article touches on many facets including how western parents are hell bent on making their children feel like winners regardless of their achievements or under performance.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Everyone has their own views on and ways of teaching their own children. Chua believes that the way her children will change into successful beings, by persistently making them work at one thing until it is mastered. She compares much of how she does with how the western parents teach their children. She makes a statement that she can tell her children that they are being lazy and everyone is getting ahead of them but the western parents have off feeling about their own life achievements. She believes this is the most successful way to have a successful child, in fact she believes she knows what’s best for her child.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mothers are doing things that children have no idea their mothers are doing for them. All throughout the movie Margaret Hall is the perfect example of an iconic mother. She is capable of constantly doing what some others cannot do which is having unconditional love for her family. Mothers are supposed to always love their children through the good and the bad. As well as constantly loving her children mothers are supposed to do whatever they have to do to make their children perfectly happy.…

    • 1348 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The method of giving this love and care might be wrong or misguided, but their intention for wanting their children to live better lives is always right. Like the quote, her family did really recognize her mother’s love until she disappeared. Dad, Chi-hon, and Hyong-Chol naturally thought mom will always be next to them and when they need her, she will be at the approachable place so they could easily get help. No one really thanked for what she had done for him or her. They just thought it was a natural and common thing for mom to do it for a family.…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays