Analysis Of The Insanity Defense

Improved Essays
Upon reflection of this entire course, coupled with a consideration of this writer’s own developing knowledge of clinical mental health counseling and art therapy, this writer feels it is imperative to recognize the humanness of every individual, regardless of his or her condition. Therefore, when this writer finds herself in a hypothetical debate with a friend who believes the insanity defense is just a clever way to get around the law, this writer would view this situation as the perfect opportunity to educate this friend and inform him or her about the details of this controversial issue.
In regards to how the legal system of the United States handles crimes committed by individuals who suffer from mental illness, specifically schizophrenia as in the assumed case of Mr. Quincy, it is crucial to consider the important reason why the insanity defense exists, to whom it should apply, and what actually happens with this defense. Ultimately, the way in which a person who suffers from mental illness is treated by the legal system poses fundamental questions of how we,
…show more content…
In keeping an optimistic attitude about the legal system of the United States and society at large, this writer believes that as society continues to take into consideration the findings of scientific research about mental illness, appreciation and acceptance of why and when the insanity defense is warranted will follow. As Hansen (2013) so eloquently argued, “we must not lose sight of a recognition that only rarely is the fundamental nature of a person so obscured by illness that their humanness and unique personality are not still the biggest part of their manner” (p. 303). It is this writer’s hope that the citizens of the United States will continue to strive for a justice system that reflects a more humanitarian

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The presence of this plea option has led to controversy in the law world; some think that the plea should be diminished while others notice its necessity. Nevertheless, there are people with mental illness in our society that commit crimes just as those without mental illness do. There should be a system that protects the rights of those with mental illness, but there is a lot of grey area with the current system in place because it is difficult to tell if the person was not in a sane state at the time the crime took place when the trial often occurs months later. Those who plea guilty by reason of insanity are required to go through an extensive psychological…

    • 1321 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Insanity Defense Papers

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages

    According to Morse and Richard, “some form of an insanity defense is a matter of fundamental fairness in a just society. It gives doctrinal expression to fundamental moral and legal principles that have been recognized by the common law for centuries and that the supreme court has repeatedly acknowledged (Morse, Richard, 488). Also, the insanity defense has been in the law since the 14th century and almost all state and federal law makers still agree on its importance today (Morse, Richard,…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many experts that have explored the idea of how the Insanity Defense could be “fixed” for the public to agree with. Richard Bonnie, a professor of public policy, law and medicine at the University of Virginia, has came to the theory that the insanity defense should not be abolished but should be narrowed. He came to the conclusion that the criteria of what qualifies for “Insanity”, by narrowing the criteria, it will help persuade the public that the insanity defense is not harmful for the overall public, but it is a healthier outcome. Another way to help the public agree is to inform the public what actually happens in these court cases, and help sort out the…

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The defense allows those who are mentally unstable to be disciplined in an apposite manner. Critics of the insanity defense may find the acquittal of mentally unstable defendants detrimental to American society and safety. However, the plea attempts to provide a commensurate punishment to that of a person’s mental state. If a person is mentally ill or “insane,” then he or she was not in the requisite state of mind at the time of the crime; therefore he or she did not willingly commit the offense; hence, his or her actions cannot be held…

    • 1956 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The insanity plea is the only way for the justice system to fairly try mentally unbalanced individuals, but tougher laws and regulations should be evaluated to prevent abuse of the plea. To improve the criminal justice system and decide whether or not an individual is insane or not, the legislation level of the criminal justice system should create and amend laws to ensure justice for the victims and to convict and reasonably punish individuals who plea insanity for the crime he or she committed and to enhance the courts capabilities of identifying those who are capable of standing trial. In reference to D.J. Jaffe’s, a co-founder of the Treatment Advocacy Center and founder of Mental Illness Policy Organization. Mr. Jaffe states, “If the cause of the crime was lack of treatment for mental illness, then the solution is to reform laws so we can sentence these individuals to mandatory long-term mental illness treatment—including medications—so they never become violent again. The sentence to treatment could be as long, or longer, than the maximum sentence that would be imposed had the person been found guilty.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article on A Crime of Insanity (Frontline, 2002), describes the whole process of determining the causes of action for individuals who have a mental illness at the time of committing heinous crimes. This article, in particular, covers the story of Ralph Tortorici, who has a history of mental disorder from as early as his adolescent years. Moreover, Ralph suffers from regular acute paranoid delusions and psychotic behavior, which prompted him to seek help from the University health facility and also from a New York state trooper. On both occasions, he complains of a government conspiracy which he feels is responsible for implanting a computer microchip on him. Having failed to secure any help from anyone, he takes matters into his own hands…

    • 882 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Conner Henman B7 Rue The Economics and Political Views of the Insanity Defense Is the insanity plea a valid defense? Word Count: 841 A The insanity defense is a defense by excuse in a criminal case, arguing that the defendant is not responsible for their actions due to an episodic or persistent psychiatric disease at the time of the criminal act.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Over time, new laws are created to help make the judgment if one is innocent or guilty based on facts and evidence. It has become more difficult to prove innocence or guilt because of certain laws. The creation of more specific and detailed laws is due to American society. The insanity defense is a specific law which has gotten harder to prove. It is a defense used in the court of law to plead not guilty due to a mental state that does not allow the accuser to know what (s)he has done.…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    ]]\ 1.Probst, Steven R. "Insanity." World Book Student, World Book, 2017, www.worldbookonline.com/student/article?id=ar277260. Accessed 5 Apr. 2017. Insanity is a legal term for any mental disease or defect severe enough to prevent someone from being legally responsible for his or her actions. Under many systems of criminal law, someone found to be insane cannot be guilty of a crime, but a defendant found not guilty by reason of insanity may still be considered dangerous.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Larry J. Siegel, P. 139). Why should an Insanity Defense not be an excuse? Pleading for Insanity should not be used…

    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For example, the insanity defense is a defense that is rarely used and rarely successful, but receives the most attention from media. In order to successfully use the insanity defense, the defendant must be judged legally insane, which consequently strips them from many of their political rights. The principle behind the insanity defense states that a person who lacks the mental capacity to form decisions based on right or wrong cannot be held legally responsible for their criminal acts. Each state varies in the legal standards that determine the sanity of defendants. Andrea Yates, was charged for capital murder in 2002 for drowning all five of her children.…

    • 283 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ethical Dilemma: The ethical dilemma of abolishing the insanity defense remains an issue when considering to strip mentally ill of the plea. The culpability, or rationality, of mentally ill offenders is often questioned when considering sentencing in U.S. courts. Is it legal to punish a person who is not mentally capable of telling right from wrong, regardless of the circumstances? Attorney’s inability to guarantee psychological defect in some cases adds to the impossibility of these situations.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The concept of free will is central to criminal justice; criminals are punished for the actions that they choose to make. When punished, the court establishes that criminals are fully aware of the crime that they are committing. However, as the justice system has become more knowledgeable in matters of the mind, the insanity defense has often been invoked as opposition to the notion of a criminal’s free will. The insanity defense argues that a criminal is not responsible for their actions if their actions are the result of psychiatric illness.…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    IN June, the Supreme Court upheld a narrow Arizona test for legal insanity, which asked simply whether mental disorder prevented the defendant from knowing right from wrong. On the other hand, legislation that has eliminated or unduly constrained the insanity defense, often in response to unpopular verdicts of not guilty by reason of insanity, is likewise off the mark. In an effort to hold most people accountable, and recognizing both the difficulty of establishing what was in the defendant's mind at the time of the crime and the defendant's incentive to lie about it, the law sought to establish strict standards for responsibility. Once we agree that there may be some small percentage of people whose moral cognition is seriously disordered, how can the law identify those people in a way that will not allow the materialism of science to expand the definitions of excusing conditions to include all criminals?…

    • 273 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The stigma of insanity acquittal is attracted in instances where the traits of the internal automatism are that of an abnormality of the mind such as in Bratty or that of some other internal factor such as in Hennessy. As consequence of social ,and most pertinent in these instances, legal tradition, it has become somewhat of a trend that once internal automatism is brought up it is more often than not going to lead down to the road of insanity. In the past where the death penality was still existant the defence of insanity was brought about as preference of defendants to being institutionalized over being hanged. In the cases of diabetic defendants such as Hennessy where the categorization of diabetes is found to be hyper-glycemic the defence will always result in that of insanity, for it will fall under the non-insane defence the diabetes must be of the hypo-gylcaemic…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays