Stem Cell Modification

Improved Essays
Question:Can Stem Cell Modification cause unrealized consequences?
Claim: Stem Cell modification can cause unrealized consequences

Evidence 1: “While the positive therapeutic outcome was celebrated as a breakthrough in gene therapy, a serious drawback subsequently became evident. By February 2005, three children out of seventeen who had been successfully treated for X-linked SCID developed leukemia because the vector inserted near an oncogene (a cancer-causing gene), inadvertently causing it to be inappropriately expressed in the genetically-engineered lymphocyte target cell.”("U.S. Department of Health and Human Services").

This means that unexpected consequences can happen because of the modification they tried to make. 3 out of 17 means that 17% of
…show more content…
If the embryo is a human person, killing it to benefit others is a clear-cut evil. It treats a distinct human being, with his or her own inherent moral worth, as nothing more than a disposable instrument to be used for someone else’s benefit.” (“Ten Problems with Embryonic Stem Cell Research.”).
This quote explains everything that is wrong with stem cell research. Killing not born babies yet to make another baby immune to one virus. So for every embryo they kill they make a few embryos immune to cancer. If this became a normal thing there would be thousands for embryos dead, and they would just keep needing more. There are laws now to protect working on embryos but not pre embryos.Pre Embryos are embryos that are under 14 days old.

Evidence 3:”Additionally, the insights provided by cloning technology destroy the scientific and legal basis of distinguishing a pre embryo from an embryo, the popular distinction made at 14 days after conception. This is significant because this distinction determines the handling and treatment of human life less than 14 days old, which is so basic to all ESCR.”(“Moral Objections to Embryonic Stem Cell

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The ability to cure any single cell disease, the ability to further research efforts in biology and neuroscience, and the ability to cure paralysis in patients. These feats are achieved because of stem cell therapy, but a limitation exists that stumps further ability for cures. Currently, stem cell therapy only works when exactly one type of cell needs replaced; once more types are added into the mix, stem cell therapy loses its value. Further research into stem cells will grant promise that multi-celled…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    consistently advanced in ways previously believed to be impossible. Although we have accomplished many triumphs in the world of science, we have to be forever willing to take the next leap. Genetic modification and human cloning is the next big medical breakthrough and technological advancement. Genetic modification and human cloning offers the world an infinite amount possibilities, not only should the research continue but funding should be provided. In 1953 James Watson and Francis Crick completed…

    • 1474 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Genetic engineering, also called genetic modification, is the process of directly alternating an organism’s DNA in its genome using biotechnology. Genetic modification has been in practice for many years in the domestication of plants and animals, but despite its unprecedented progress, gene editing in humans, especially in embryonic stem cells, is one of the major controversies in health and science field nowadays. In the article from The Guardian, “Genetically modified human embryos should be…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays