Should Teens Make Medical Decisions Essay

Superior Essays
Are 16 and 17 year olds capable of making medical decisions? From birth to adolescence, parents entrust their kids with responsibilities and decision making. At what age do people have the right to determine whether or not they receive medical treatment. 16 and 17 year can become Veterans but still has to have consent from a guardian to receive medical treatment. More and more juveniles are being tried as adults, but they’re not be allowed to make their own medical decisions. What are the reasons for not allowing adolescents to make medical decisions, but they 're allowed to make other critical decisions. If teenagers are allowed to refuse medical treatments, what medical treatments should they be allowed to refuse. Young adults aren’t capable of making life or death medical decisions due to the laws set for teenagers, level of maturity/puberty, and leaving the decisions for the professionals/guardians can save lives. …show more content…
Without laws, everything and everyone will be corrupt because they will act upon irrational emotions. The government, parents and professional researchers all know that minors are impulsive and that 's why laws were made for minors. Even though some teens don’t follow laws about drinking, smoking and drugs, laws about medical decisions can be enforced more. Although some decisions are permitted under circumstances, the government make sure to limit these rights in order to protect the teens. Additionally, minors aren’t mature enough to make life changing decisions with the majority of them making unintelligent decisions now. Smoking, binge drinking and drugs are the few decisions teens are making and to allow these kind of kids to make medical decisions would be unethical. Some adults even make rational and intelligent decisions so we can’t expect teens to make the right ones either. In order to protect these minors, they should not be allowed to make their own medical

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Young adults consume more alcohol than their body can handle. When college students binge drink they make poor decisions and do not realize it until the act has already been made. Of course everyone is trying to find a solution to stop binge and underage drinking, but by passing a law saying an eighteen year old can buy alcohol will only make the problem worse. Allowing an eighteen year old to buy alcohol would also lead them into a higher risk of becoming an alcoholic at such a young age. Teenage years are always the toughest and most confusing years for a young adult. They start experiencing new things and trying to find who they are. Sometimes they put themselves in the wrong crowd and lose who they are. Suicide is a dangerous effect that comes from consuming large amounts of alcohol at a young age. Teenagers go through difficult times and decide to drink to get their mind off of it. Some are not strong enough to handle it and make decisions they would not normally make if they were in their right mind set. According to Blackwell Publishing, "Among 18 to 24 year olds, 39 percent of binge drinkers admitted to criminal behavior and 60 percent to disorderly behavior" (n.p.). It has been said that alcohol is the third leading cause of death in the United States. Majority of the time when someone is caught committing a crime they are found to be drunk. Allowing more young adults to buy alcohol…

    • 1670 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A national survey showed that by the time children are in eighth grade, 27% have used alcohol; and, by the time teenagers are in twelfth grade, 66% of them had used alcohol (Gonchar). In another national survey, 54% of high schoolers say that they have access to alcohol at any time (Jacinto). This is a major problem in today’s society. Teens are choosing to break the law, and not worried about the consequences or what others think. Teenagers still find ways to access alcohol, even though it’s illegal for them to drink. The responsibilities one has when you are drinking are huge. People are not only just affecting themselves when drinking, but also they are affecting other people also (“Minimum”). Teenagers need to be educated on these side effects. Therefore the drinking age should be changed to eighteen in order to help educate teenagers the side effects of drinking, warning more effectively will help those who drink and drive, and also keeping with the most…

    • 2159 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As we all know and understand, alcohol has to be handled with responsibility and not to be misuse. Alcoholism affects so many people in the United States due to irresponsible decisions, but most legally teens who are considered adults say, once you are eighteen, you should be able to do whatever you want because you gained more civil rights by being able to vote, purchase tobacco products and join the forces so why not be allowed to purchase alcohol products and consume it.…

    • 1197 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It would be the physician’s duty to enforce these rules. In Minnesota and Louisiana physicians have to get informed consent from the minor’s parents or legal guardian (Guttmacher Institute, 2016). Going against these laws would be going against the moral rules and the standards of care.…

    • 1165 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    First off you will need to know what an adolescent is, it a young adult. To make an autonomous medical choice is to make a medical decision yourself without an adult. I believe they do and they don’t. Adolescents under 16 should not be able to make autonomous medical choices. Adolescents over 16 should be able to. I say this because when you are 16 you should be able to drive, with this being said you could drive to your doctor’s and make your decision for yourself. Being under 16 you can not drive yourself to the doctor’s, so you would have to get someone to drive you so you would already have someone there (hopefully a legal guardian) they would be able to make the decision for you. You may say I am out of my mind but here is my opinion.…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It goes without saying, children will do a lot to disobey their parents in any way. When a child or young adult drinks and it’s illegal, it engenders this rebellion that they did against their guardians. Karis Rogerson did an article on how life was different in America compared to Italy. In her article, she did not only say how it was astounding that she could no longer drink at her age, but how it was odd that even if her parents gave her some champagne on New Year’s Eve, it was illegal and they could potentially get thrown into jail for doing this. “The closer it got to my 21st birthday, the bigger of a deal it became.” Karis stated. (“ Viewpoint: Why America Should Lower the Legal Drinking Age”). Adolescents don’t have just their parents to disobey, but as Karis exclaims, just as well as any school out there, we are made to sign a paper saying that we will not partake in drinking or smoking for that fact. As teens are, it just becomes another reason to drink because it becomes another authoritative figure to…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    5.07 Case 18

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Have you ever met a person who didn’t have any parents or guardians ? Did you ever think about what might happen if something bad were to happen to them and they needed medical treatment?. You probably didn’t but that’s fine it’s not your job to worry about but this is a situation that could possibly happen so if it did what would they do? This is why I believe that the age to make your own legal medical decision should be before one turns 18 so that In the case there are no parents or guardians present a child can make their own decision.…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    government have the right to tell teens what they can and can’t do? With or without…

    • 1221 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Minor Consent And Refusal

    • 1315 Words
    • 6 Pages

    For instance, in British Columbia, the Infants Act states that a minor is anyone who is under the age of nineteen. In accordance with Section 17 of the Infants Act, a minor is able to provide an informed consent for a medical procedure that is in the best interest of the minor, as long as a medical practitioner has considered the minor capable and has exercised due diligence in explaining the proposed medical treatment. In the case of refusal of a medical treatment that is in the best interest of the minor, the medical practitioner has the right to override the decision in collaboration with the director and perform appropriate treatment interventions to preserve and sustain life. Comparing this to the province of Quebec, which has established anyone under the age of fourteen, regardless of their capability or capacity requires medical consent from a parent, guardian or the courts for any proposed medical treatment. Nevertheless, if the medical treatment is of great risk or can propose potential harm to the minor who is fourteen years or older, then parental consent is necessary. In contrast, the Consent of Minors Act in New Brunswick, states minors sixteen years or older have the exact same right to refuse and consent to a medical treatment as an adult. Since each province has various perspectives on minor consent and refusal,…

    • 1315 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 2010, there were approximately 189,000 emergency rooms visits by persons under age 21 for injuries and other conditions linked to alcohol (CDC, fact sheets). Drinking fogs thinking and erodes judgment. When you combine alcohol with teenagers’ natural risk-taking and desire to impress their friends, dangerous things happen. Each year, underage drinking contributes to the death of approximately 4,700 young people (MADD35). On December 2013, a teen in Texas received 10 years of probation for underage drunk driving. Being defined as a “killer on the road”, he killed four people during this accident and was entered into a long-term treatment facility. If people were legally allowed to drink if they are 18 and over, this situation would only get worse and worse. This makes teens irresponsible since it will probably be legal, hence making it okay to drink however much they want. Many car accidents and death are caused by reckless teens who decide to drive highly intoxicated or even a little drunk. Alcohol impairs your mental thinking and visual perceptions, causing you to see and react to things that aren’t really there. This is very dangerous for teens that are constantly on the road and also drinking casually. People who are 18 don’t have much responsibility and still don’t know right from wrong. Making it legal to drink at a young age will cause teens to revolt and use the law as an excuse to cause…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Underage drinking is a problem in the United States. Why do many teenagers drink illegally? What makes teenagers drink and commit outrageous, dangerous activities like drunk driving? What makes a teenager think its okay to break the law? High school and college parties nowadays mostly have alcoholic beverages such as beer and vodka. Most students at these parties are under 21 and if someone at the party were to get into an accident that requires medical attention especially at a high school drinking party, no one would want to call the ambulance or police because they would be scared of getting in trouble. Most teenagers don’t know what they are capable of when they drink. They don’t know the consequences of their action. The debate over the minimum legal drinking age would have people think the problem will be solved by lowering the drinking age , but that will lead to more problems. The…

    • 1934 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    United States is a free country and there are a lot of laws that are being broken by some people in our country just because they think that some laws would not help or have any effects on people’s lives. We can all agree that if we do not follow the law we can get in trouble and we can get other people in trouble as well. One of these laws is being broken every day and its bringing a lot of problems for teenagers and their parents. This law is underage drinking and there are a lot of scary stories that we hear every day about teenagers getting injured and killed for drunk driving. Even when people know drinking will cause a lot of problems, there is still a big argument about the drinking age being lowered to 18 or stay at 21. Many activities…

    • 271 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each year, thousands of young people tragically lose their lives due to alcohol poisoning and other alcohol related injuries that were unintentional ("The Medical Amnesty Initiative."). In situations where a minor is in need of emergency medical attention, studies show that the worry is more about getting into trouble and receiving a Minor in Possession/Consumption of alcohol (MIP//MIC) ticket, instead of the well being of that person. As a result, lives are put at risk. That is exactly why the medical amnesty policy was put into place, so underage drinkers could put their worries aside and do the right thing. The medical amnesty policy will change the way students and underage drinkers handle an emergency situation.…

    • 1202 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Underage drinking has been pushed to less controlled environments and having the age set at the age of adulthood gives underage drinkers less motive to drink before the legal age requirement. “18 is the age of adulthood in the United States, and adults should have the right to make their own decisions about alcohol consumption” however, it would be medically irresponsible to let them drink so early in development, the legal drinking age is now set at twenty one, which is still before full development of the body, and lowering this legal age to eighteen poses an even greater risk towards teens and young…

    • 692 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ethical dilemma I chose is the case of Cassandra C., a 17-year-old teenager who refused chemotherapy treatment to treat Hodgkin’s lymphoma. The problem that this case produces is a conflict between two ethical principles; respect for autonomy and beneficence. Respect for autonomy is respecting the individual’s rights to say no to a treatment if wanted to do so and beneficence is an ethical principle in which it directs doctors and physicians to strive to maximize the benefits and minimize the harms. When Cassandra declined further treatment, the doctors were confused on how to do their job and how to do it well. Cassandra is still legally a minor, which means that a parent has the right to decide on her behalf. What makes this case remarkable…

    • 1109 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays