Richard Straub's Response To Writing

Improved Essays
Every person has their own way of following variety of steps towards reading and responding other student’s paper. In this case, Richard Straub and I bear our own differences such as him reading and helping the student’s paper like a friend and me analyze, support and comment my classmate’s paper like an Advance Placement Trainer. As for similarities we both aim for the same goal, provide sufficient amount of comments, and the way we write out the comments. Richard Straub is an Associate Professor of English at Florida State University who wrote “Responding-Really Responding-to Other Students’ Writing” sharing his ways of responding effectively towards a student’s paper to help them grow and improve in writing. I am a college …show more content…
For example, in my English Advance Placement course my teacher asks everyone to read and respond essays as if you were a trained reader who grades Advance Placement exams. My teacher insists for us to follow in the trainer footsteps because it will help us go more in depth with our thoughts on paper. Going in depth processes the mind to identify the mistakes written on the student’s paper. However, these trainers who grade Advance Placement Essays read and respond towards mistakes that are made on the student’s paper instead of offering suggestions or help the student correct their mistakes. It sounds harsh but it is a way to let the student seek for help on their writing and know what mistakes must not be made. Writing comments were also needed to sound like an Advance Placement trainer but with a bit of support. I was happy to know that I could at least support this student’s paper for them to feel proud from what they were able to accomplish on the essay. Trainer’s who grade Advance Placement exams had little expectations due to little amount of time with reading and commenting. My response towards reading and responding as an Advance Placement trainer is to pick up the paste. Time is precious and is needed to be taken seriously in order to know on what is being expected when beginning …show more content…
For the most part, our similarities such as goals, amount of comments, and the way comments are written and to praise or criticize became main points for students to learn to read and respond properly and adequately towards a student’s paper. Richard Straub’s reading is advice for students on what to do exactly when responding in order for them to manage a paper without to rely on the teacher; remember the teacher will not always be there to guide you. Writing in full statements and be serious on what you comment is what Richard Straub and I experienced with reading and responding. Small dull statements will lead the writer to nowhere near improving because he or she will be confused and not know what to do. Overall, Richard Straub experiences and mine are the same in terms on how each thing is being done and achieve the goal of helping the writer improve its

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In this article, Selfe quotes Anne Wysocki, who says “To be responsible teachers, we need to help our students (as well as ourselves) learn how different choices in visual arrangement in all texts (on and off screen) encourage different kinds of meaning making and encourage us to take up (overtly or not) various values.” She is saying that she believes that good teachers are teaching students to write for not just the page, but for all forms of writing. Education is not just about learning as much as possible. Students shouldn’t just become walking textbooks. Instead they need to be able to take what they’ve learned in the classroom, and apply it to their daily lives. This is something that multimodal writing does.…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this course we had to annotate an article over modeling in reading and writing. One of the areas that modeling needed is for guided reading. “Guided reading involves supporting students as they flexibly apply a range of strategies to processing text at graduated levels of difficulty.” (Jamison, 2011). When teachers model using a text or book this is unfamiliar to their students, it helps students learn, reading strategies, such as using context clues, letter and sound knowledge, and syntax or word structure. The goal of guided reading is for students to use these strategies independently on their way to becoming fluent, skilled readers.…

    • 1078 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The purpose of a close reading is to allow the student to “develop a deep understanding of what the author is saying and for students to figure out what is confusing and how to gain understanding (Mercado, 2015, ppt 8).” Before my professor showed me this and discussed this in class, I would’ve assumed a close reading was similar to that of a shared reading. Mercado…

    • 1128 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Red Pen Rhetoric Analysis

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Wyrick then focuses on how students should view their writing instructor as a sage. He believes that students must understand that the only way to improve their writing is by entering into “dialogue with those who have more experience writing” (5). The form of dialogue some teachers use is simply writing margin notes about the MUGS of a student’s paper, but not the actual content of the paper. While other methods of dialogue, such as conferencing, allow the student to think about the content of his or her paper, which will help him or her to develop a better academic…

    • 1491 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Reflection On English 102

    • 1124 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Finally, revising drafts and receiving feedback from my teacher and classmates has helped for the most part. While I seemed to find constructive feedback from my teacher, my classmates could have been more supportive. While reading some feedback all I would get is compliments for some people, while its flattering to be complimented, I would rather have tips on how my writing get better. Creating these writing pieces has taught me a lot about my voice and audience and has allowed me to reflect on my…

    • 1124 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    English Reflection Essay

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages

    I also used spell check and grammar check for my paper. I feedback from my classmates in two ways which were verbal feedback and writing. They constructed to inform me of what I did wrong and give me subjection of what to do. When I started to edit my paper I started to have words that could fit the story. I started to add commas in my writing in order to for my writing to make sense.…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This plan consisted of splitting the class into groups, reading aloud to them and slowly teaching them how to form a great introductory paragraph. This plan also consisted of them using peer reviewing, which required them to listen and be able to comprehend what the student was writing about in his or her argumentative paper. After the plan was implemented, I allowed a one-on-one meeting with my student to determine the progress in which he made. This allowed me to discover new ways in order to help and/or better assess my student in the future or someone who requires the same attention. Also, this experience influenced my perception of teaching greatly.…

    • 1107 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    According to Boyles (2004), “teachers talk with students to monitor their progress as well as to set goals and help them solve problems” (p.75). Teachers should conduct writing conferences in order to assess and evaluate the writing progress of their students. The purpose of writing conferences is finding the strengths and weaknesses of their writing to improve and develop the skills the student already has. Depending on the students writing the teacher facilitates interventions to improve the students writing skills. Teachers should frequently plan writing conferences to check-in on their students and the progress they have made.…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is important to re-examine the goals of the writing class. We need to know what are learners ’goals might be. For the most part, everyone learns to write at school. Writing is not a naturally simple interaction, so we have to understand the specific difficulties of L2 students. In learning a second language, the learners…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Long Grammar Effect

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Lastly, the teacher collected the student’s writing again, to re-analyze, and determine if there was any progress or if there was not. Since I am going to be a teacher, I find this strategy useful and helpful to practice in my future classroom to determine what my students are struggling on, what the best way is to present the error is, and evaluate if they grasped the concept. I think this is an effective strategy rather than the isolated teaching of grammar rules and concepts. From experience, when my teacher assigned the class to do worksheets on grammar rules or concepts I did not retain the information. Comparing that experience to the mini lessons in my Integrating Language Arts class, I think that they are more engaging and helpful.…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics