Petrarch's Sacred And Profane Love Analysis

Superior Essays
What does love got to do with it? Tina Turner’s iconic lyrics has continued to phrase this question to various generations, leading one to wonder how Petrarch would have answered them. For him, it appears love was the basis of everything, including life and work. Petrarch immortalized the convention of love in poetry through his vivid imagery and stunning depictions of beauty. Through his poems, he takes the reader on a journey in which they truly feel his passion for the elusive Laura and eventually his shame in his undying love for her. However, paintings depicting love in the Renaissance express a different view from Petrarch, one that is more rational, leading one to question why there is this discrepancy and what it means.

In the Canzoniere,
…show more content…
Historians argue which figure depicts the sacred; perhaps it is the clothed and modest girl on the left while naked Venus depicts profane love that sexualizes the physical body. Or, consequently, the sumptuous outfit of the woman on the left reveals a focus on worldly riches and thus is more profane, while the naked female shows a connection to nature and the Maker, thus being more sacred as well as depicting a woman’s sacred duty to reproduce. Nevertheless, they symbolize the two sides of Petrarch. One could argue that the shame Petrarch feels is a social construct, the ideas of marriage, fidelity, and peaceful love being reinforced by the church and the art rendered in this era makes Petrarch feel even more ashamed of his feelings towards the married Laura. His passionate love goes against everything being taught as his emotions seek to disrupt the balance of marriage which is valued so highly. This Renaissance art can be said to depict the most negative themes in Petrarch’s poetry, those that love leads to shame and pain, instead of focusing on the beauty and passion that true love can

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Love In The Aeneid

    • 1307 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Medea became so obsessed that when it was over, she was completely lost. This is the premise of the poem, but also relates to Euripides’ version of love. The idea that a strong love can eventually lead to hate is depressing, but Medea does just that. Euripides includes a type of love that is exclusive to this poem. That love is parental love.…

    • 1307 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    A combination of Petrarch and English sonnet conventions construct love and desire in Sir Thomas Wyatt 's “Whoso List to Hunt”. However, from Petrarch 's perspective, love is transcendent and idealizes the beloved. The poet places his love on a pedestal. Desire, on the other hand, focuses on longing and frustration. The poet 's love is unwanted and injustice (Riddell).…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    CONCLUSSION The development of a love poet, can be traced easily by subtle analysis of various strains that define different moods and shades of love. The great metaphysical poet, John Donne provides a great instance of this kind of analysis of the poem. The first phase of Donne's love poems are conspicuous for exasparation and eccentricity that owes its genesis to peculiar notion that woman is essentially unfaithful and the object of sexual pleasure only. The second phase begins with the realization of the sentimental worth of a woman and in the third phase the poet enjoys the bliss of Platonic love where body, despite lingering functionality, ceases to matter and love is manifest at spiritual level. Kamala Das, in her long career as a love…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Donne writes his poem to warn those stuck under the spell of love. The spell that love will come to aid in times of need. The brainwashing that love is all one needs in life to live happily. Donne’s speaker steps away from the typical spotlight shined on love, accomplishing a controversial yet relatable poem. Donne’s lost soul of a speaker pours his hopelessly, pessimistic attitude on paper through the usage of metaphors, personification, and…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This poem expresses great emotion in a sophisticated way as readers are challenged to configure her voice. It makes sense that this poem may possibly be for Wadsworth. He was a married man who Emily Dickinson may have had a deep affection for. This poem expresses a forbidden love, or a love that cannot be acted upon. One stanza in particular shows this sense of struggle: “They’d judge us- How- For you-served Heaven- you know, Or sought to- I could not”…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hero And Leander Analysis

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In Chaucer 's "Miller 's Prologue and Tale" and Marlowe 's "Hero and Leander," both authors build their stories around the misrepresentation of love. Nicholas and Alisoun use each other for sex and other favors, pretending it is love for their benefit. Furthermore, Leander’s love for Hero comes from conquering her, which Hero comes to deeply resents. Neither couple represents the standard idea of romance, as they all lack affection, spiritual fulfillment, and mutual respect. Without all three of these things, love will never grow, with relationships breeding lust instead.…

    • 1346 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of his poems “Love Sonnet XVII” was written about his deep love for someone. In the poem, he explains his love by using many similes and examples of imagery. For example, the poem starts out by saying “I do not love you as if you were a salt rose, or topaz or the arrow of carnations the fire shoots off.” (Neruda). Since, the poem starts out this way, with the simile, he shows that the reasons he loves this person is not for their beauty but for something stronger, something inside of them. Also, by using a simile to show this it brings more emphasis to how he loves this person.…

    • 1626 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    One of the most underlying and important themes of this play is the difficulties of love. Shakespeare touches on the fact that people fall in love with things that are beautiful to them; and will repeal things that are not. The attraction and draw to beauty might display a side of love at its most intense stage, but one of the main ideas in this play is that true love must surpass the mere external physical shell. A majority of the issues in this play arise from difficulties in romantic world, although it is not fully based on a love story. Demetrius and Lysander are both equally in love with Hermia, but she is only in love with Lysander.…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The true test of character is then revealed by how people react to these passionate feelings. This is seen in the novel between the star cross-crossed lovers doomed for their inevitable fate. Although love and hate are both feelings that can be suppressed into the depths of emotion to not be exploited, the novel Wuthering Heights…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As Don Paterson points out ‘with the Young Man he’s in the grip of a pure love, but stalked by the presence of lust’. This can be seen in each of the Fair Youth sonnets as the speaker not only fights to find a way in which to preserve the fair youths beauty but ultimately replaces the role of a wife and son in the young mans life as he proposes that his own poetry will preserve the fair youth for eternity. Paterson then looks to the Dark Lady sonnets in which the speaker is ‘in a grip of a pure lust, but stalked by the absence of love’. This is evident in the way portrays her as rugid, sexual and often times faithless. The Dark Lady sonnets are filled with sexual desire, it’s fulfillment and the ultimate shame that follows, a prime example of this can be seen in sonnet 129.…

    • 1942 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics