John Orlando's 'Is Praise Undermining Student Motivation?'

Improved Essays
In John Orlando’s “Is Praise Undermining Student Motivation?”, he makes the claim that “students are becoming dependent on praise because it is wrapped up with their self-esteem. They start thinking that the goal of school is praise, or grades, rather than learning.” I have seen evidence supporting this claim throughout the entirety of my years spent in school. From being pushed by my parents and teachers to obtain and maintain an all-A report card, watching students being punished or excluded from activities for an insufficient GPA, being accepted into prestigious organizations that require you to maintain an exceptional GPA, to even being told by my elders that if I didn’t receive good grades I would never be accepted into a good college- these are the various situations that student’s in today 's society grow up surrounded by, leading to an extra emphasis on the importance of grades rather than actually learning.
As a senior in high school, looking back on the past eleven years I have continuously been pushed by both my parents as well as
…show more content…
Colleges denying students attendance to their universities due to low grades is yet another example of missed opportunities for learning due to the emphasis on praise. Attending college is ultimately the overall goal I have when I graduate from highschool, so I have taken my teacher’s advice to heart and always maintained my grades. After reading Orlando’s article, I have realized that his claim is completely accurate. All of this time, I have gone through school with the idea that the goal is achieving good grades in order to one day attend a good college, rather than actually striving to learn. However, it has been hard to recognize that the concept of learning is the ultimate goal when I have been accepted into prestigious organizations based off of my academic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Précis Frank Bruni’s article, “How to Survive the College Admissions Madness” (2015), criticizes American’s that emphasize that college is the most important and beneficial way to ensure a promising future. Bruni supports his position by referring to anecdotal stories of past experiences of college applicants, listing the qualifications of the applicants to make them relatable, and metaphorical comparisons to develop the author’s opinion. Bruni’s purpose is to admonish the concept of the college admission process measuring a person's worth in order to alleviate the disappointment students feel after rejection. Due to the author’s condescending tones this article is written to college bound students addressing the obsession to receive a…

    • 304 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    College is not for Everyone In the essay, “Should Everyone Go to College” by Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill, they state that telling all young people that they should advance to college no matter what is actually doing some of them a disservice. Students are expected to continue on with their education and are told that going to college is the best way to gain success later in life. In this article, Owen and Sawhill tell of how going to college does not guarantee success and they give examples of the positives and negatives of the choices they may make. Owen and Sawhill use ethos, logos, and pathos to explain how college may not be the best choice for all students.…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Students had to realize its importance for their success in life and the only way for this to occur was by accepting and succeeded through the curriculum established by these colleges. However, before they truly understood its importance, Pace makes it clear that, “They attend classes but make no effort to learn anything” (p. 11) Students were more concerned about power and status within society than in academic curriculum that would advance them further in life than ever thought of (p. 11). It was because of this that when introduced to the new curriculum, many could not pass the test and would instead result in failure. “Failure meant that their reputations as men of honor might come into question.”…

    • 1527 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We have become too politically correct and emotionally soft to gravitate towards high academic excellence. College has become an experience and a degree not an education. Edmundson’s article denounces this thoroughly even if he doesn’t provide a concrete…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Lazy A Suzanne E. Fry writes “Some students feel that success is owed to them; after all, they did not spend thousand of dollars a year not to yield results”(Fry 10). In her article, she brings out her view that relaxing grades or the lower performance needed to achieve good grades, cause the quality of education to suffer and teaches student they don 't need to work hard to succeed are completely valid; it is seen in the way student pick classes today and their time spent studying. Suzanne E. Fry in the article, Grade Inflation argues that the inflation of grades going on in higher education is harmful to all involved. Fry points out that when A’s are easier to achieve students are taught that they don 't need to work hard. She shows that…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    As time periods have changed, so have the college admissions procedure and criteria. As of today, many believe that the education system is completely flawed, with this comes along the use of standardized testing and whether it is used for the right purposes. Like those who believe the education system is flawed, educational psychologist, Joseph A. Soares at Wake Forest University believes that “we seem in danger of loosing sight of education as more than just cramming a student’s brain for an exam” (Soares 7). In his online journal entry, “The Future of College Admissions:Discussion” he argues that “our visions of admissions have been too often blinkered by numbers with dubious diagnostic value” (10). To better clarify that, Soares is describing that we have lost the true meaning and purpose behind college admissions and determining true education.…

    • 1644 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Each college student knows what it is like to constantly worry whether or not the score on the ACT is high enough to get accepted into a school or if certain AP credits will transfer to the school of choice. It’s my junior year of high school, and I had just begun looking at colleges and universities I believed would suit me personally and educationally. Each school was severely critiqued on certain elements they had to offer, such as, majors/minors, clubs and organizations, pre-professional programs, and even extracurricular activities. This was going to be the place I would ultimately spend the next four years of my life, so I needed to make the perfect decision.…

    • 1138 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He begins the article with several accounts of students begging for ways on how to improve their grade and explained how students still begged when they knew and admitted they do not deserve the grade they please. College students just aim for minimal effort; effort so low that they expect to pass by just showing up to class (Wiesenfeld). He goes onto explaining how students rarely consider the opportunity to learn. “The one thing college actually offers-a chance to learn- is considered irrelevant, even less than worthless, because of the long hours and hard work required” (Wiesenfeld). Colleges are providing chances that not everyone in America can attain, but students still do not find it a reason to go through tedious essays, projects and studying.…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Losing Is Good for You,” Ashley Merryman argues that constantly rewarding children is an all too common and toxic practice in society that needs to be stopped immediately since it degrades the true merit of winning. She insists that losing is an essential experience that is imperative to the development of children and their impressionable mentalities. Although she claims that losing is good for kids, she recognizes that people should be aware of the intellectual and emotional differences that are unique to each child before administering constructive criticism. According to Merryman, adults should stop assuring children that they are all identical winners because it drives them to underachieve, leads them to devalue the success of winning,…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although many people see this as a positive thing, the authors argue that college is not for everyone. Murray discloses that some of those that enter college to get a degree end up dropping out. He attributes this to the fact that “it remains taboo to acknowledge that college is intellectually too demanding for many young people” (251). Murray believes that young people would benefit more if guidance counselors pushed them toward something they were naturally good at as they would enjoy it far more and would excel. Similarly, Owen and Sawhill believe that “a bachelor’s degree is not a smart investment for every student in every circumstance” (222).…

    • 1040 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hannah Adams Dr. Herman Prager TX Government 14 November, 2017 College, What It Was, Is, And Should Be In Andrew Delbanco’s book, College, What It Was, Is, And Should Be, the author explains that students are no longer going to colleges to explore and discover their passions, but instead are attending just to gain an undergraduate degree. He argues that a true education helps students discover themselves. He expresses his concern that many colleges are losing their passion to help students discover themselves and their values, and those that keep up these traditions are becoming a privilege that many cannot afford.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    College in today’s society is seen as a lifestyle, experience, and a necessity. Millions upon millions of students are crushed by the false reality being spewed off by television on how life will be after high school. Young impressionable minds are brainwashed into believing that college isn’t the path to success, but instead it is luck. These young minds start to believe that they will become rich and famous while avoiding the dues of student loans. This false reality leads these students to view college in a negative light when in fact a college education is what could be setting them apart from their ideal lifestyle.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author argues that even though grades may be an important factor in acceptance, that much more is taken into account when getting accepted into college. These may include letters of recommendation, extracurriculars, job experience, and talents in arts, music, or other fields. We agree that this is a fair point made by the author. “Grades should not define one’s character” (Tyler Lee). Colleges generally look for more valuable characteristics such as work ethic, honesty, and attitude.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Colleges do exactly what Stigler had said in the article, they see our struggle as weakness. So because of those struggles, students are not able to get the education they need. Without this education they cannot move forward and have a successful life. Without a successful life it means that they did not make it to college because the tuition was too high or they could not keep up with the loans. And when they cannot keep…

    • 1706 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Within the last decade, there has been a rapid increase in requirements for students to graduate and get accepted into good colleges. In fact, Stanford, a well-known private college, has dropped its acceptance rate by nearly eight percent since 2004. With these new painstaking requisites, students have recently become pressured to succeed within their classes as well as compete with their peers for superiority. Oftentimes, this pressure stems from parents who want their children to apply to selective colleges without fear of being rejected. Although these parents naturally put pressure on their children because they want the best for their children, students do not always cope with the pressure well.…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics