Examples Of Gaunilos Argument

Decent Essays
prove it by just stating that is it something that exits in your mind. You have to be able to prove that it physically does exist. The fact that it is in your mind is not sufficient proof. Gaunilos argument is somewhat the same to Immanuel Kants. Conceiving the idea of God cannot in any way be thought to genuinely lead to conceving the idea that “God exists”. He provides a great example of the 100-dollar bill. The one 100-dollar bill does not change how much in quantity it is even if in your mind you think of the 100-dollar bill being more than 100 dollars.

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Have you ever desired for a short, reasonable response that will please both the brain and the soul? In the pursuit of basic human rights, numerous individuals have searched for this fulfillment in religion. Webster defines religious as one`s belief in God, as well as rules used to worship a God. Since the beginning of time, religion was questioned, and it`s origin; consequently, they headed toward the sea to find some answers. Although we are not able to confirm the existence of God, we can provide proof of the power of religion.…

    • 829 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Background & Audience Relevance: I know most of y’all cringed at the idea of pennies being exchanged for a 5 dollar bill despite it being the same amount of money. Speaker Credibility: To me, making this deal would have been the most amazing thing that’s ever happened to me, but to you, despite the fact that the face value of your money stayed the same, because of their lack of value and since almost nobody wants pennies your possible spending money would have decreased. Thesis: Unfortunately, just like pennies…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gaunilo gives us the example of the greatest possible island called “the Lost Island.” He applies Anselm’s argument to “the greatest possible island” to prove the existence of this island, by using the same style of reasoning which Anselm uses to prove the existence of God. If the ontological argument works, then, the Lost Island argument works too since the two arguments have the same logical form. Given the Lost Island argument, Gaunilo criticizes the ontological argument by demonstrating this approach can be used to prove a lot of seemingly fool ideas, for example, “the greatest possible…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “If you say, Well, I just think how much could have been done with twenty thousand dollars, you sound thoughtful, sensible, you know, reasonable, rational, someone you really want on your side. However, if you were to point out, But a young attending physician makes one hundred thousand dollars, not twenty, and that’s five times what it cost to try to save a boy’s life—that just makes you sound like an asshole. Same world, same numbers, same figures, same currency.” This quote really stuck out to me as we can connect to a variety of things.…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This same logic can be applied to a Five-Dollar Bill. The US government says that the note is worth Five-Dollars. It can be covered in dirt, marker, or a moustache and a silly hat drawn on Abraham Lincoln, it is still worth Five Dollars. However, if you split that bill in half, you don’t have two “two-fifty” bills, you have a broken Five Dollar Bill that is worth nothing. There is no…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This leads us to Anselm’s conclusion that God exists. Gaunilo of Marmoutier criticizes this argument and…

    • 1868 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    2.2.8 Norman Malcolm Malcolm expanded on Anselm’s second argument, where most saw the second argument as a rephrasing of the first, Malcolm saw it as an entirely different argument. He believes that Anselm’s second argument is actually an argument that it is greater to exist necessarily rather than contingently, so it becomes a part of the concept that the greatest conceivable being would exist necessarily rather than contingently. This would free the argument from one of Kant’s critiques; the critique that existence isn’t a valid predicate, using this new argument, existence actually adds something to our concept of what God is rather than just being a statement on whether he exists. The crux of the argument is whether or not there exists a unique being that must exist necessarily rather than contingently, everything we know is contingent on something else, for example, you are contingent on your parents.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Defining something as large and complex as God is something hard to process. So for our purposes, we will call God the GCB or greatest conceivable being. A GCB can be agreed upon as a being who is omniscient, omnipotent, omnipresent, and omnibenevolent, meaning all-knowing, able to do anything, able to be everywhere at the same time, and all-loving. For thousands of years, people have debated the idea of a GCB. This debate has led to countless wars and many deaths.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In review of the three arguments related to the Proof for the Existence of a god, I found all three arguments to be very convincing, opinionating and interesting. These arguments appeared to be based on personal opinions, while convincing the reader to their beliefs from either a religious view, logical view or natural purpose view. The concept they all appeared to have in common was that they all believed god did exist, which I found to be very enlightening. My impression of each argument would be in the following comments.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anselm proves this wrong by saying that, this logic can only be applied to the maximally perfect God. First of all, the description given is not enough to prove is perfectness; the island can be faced with temporal, environmental and other consequences, unlike the concept of God. Also, there can be only one maximally perfect concept, that of God, hence that is the only concept this reasoning for existence can be applied…

    • 979 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Are Pennies Worthless

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages

    You might think that the penny is worth something because of how long we’ve had it. Maybe you even think that pennies are good because if you save enough of them you can make a few bucks, and if that wasn’t your opinion I would say that was wrong. Sure, there are some pennies that are worth something but those are far and in between. The majority of pennies are only going…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The year 1862-1863 proved to be a major year for the history of United States of America. With the Emancipation Proclamation signed by Abraham Lincoln, the status of slavery within the country is hence abolished. Historians argue whether the abolition of slavery is a direct connection to what Lincoln did. Some argue that it was from the pressure of slaves themselves.…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Existence of God This argument about the existence of God, better known as the cosmological argument, begins with the late philosopher Aristotle. Similar to a modern day natural scientist, he believed that we could ascertain more about the world and the very fundamental nature of things within our world just by observing and recording. In many ways Aristotle resemble a modern day artist, a person who goes through life experiencing and watching all different types of energy that’s around, visually records this information and help others by spreading this knowledge to the mass. Aristotle too, would look and study the world and its patterns that were around him in order to gain insight into his world.…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The philosopher René Descartes expresses his belief that he has proven the existence of God beginning in Meditation III. By this time in his meditations, Descartes has concluded that the only thing he can be sure of is that he exists and is a thinking thing. Through this thinking, he concludes that he knows nothing for certain. Descartes begins considering the existence of God by examining the contents of his mind. It is through his innate idea of God that Descartes concludes that God exists, and through God’s existence his understanding of the material world as a whole is concluded.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Does God Exist Essay

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the vast study of philosophy, a particular question has baffled even the most intelligent minds. This question is, “Does God exist?” Philosophers have considered the answer to this question for centuries, each coming up with their own argument and reasons behind their thinking. A platform of debate often used is Antony Flew’s parable of the two explorers, who find a garden so beautiful, that one of the explorers is positive that there must be a gardener tending to it, even if he can’t be detected in any way. The other explorer is not so easily convinced that a gardener exists at all.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays