Epstein Equal Pay

Improved Essays
Richard A. Epstein’s article “The problem with ‘Equal Pay’: a competitive labor market will make short work of pay gaps” was the first article that I chose. I found this article on the Opposing Viewpoints in Context database. I chose to discuss this article first because it connects to my question the strongest and makes a lot of excellent points on the gender pay gap. The author talks a lot about how the gender pay gap is mistaken for being because of discrimination against women. Epstein also gives many reasons of the pay gap that are not due to discrimination. In “The problem with ‘Equal pay’: a competitive labor market will make short work of pay gaps” Epstein points out,
A far better explanation is that these statistical studies cannot
…show more content…
This article was also found on the Opposing Viewpoints in Context database. I chose to do this article next because it for the most part goes along the same lines as the article I just talked about, while my third article for the most part counters these two. Andrew Biggs’ article is mainly about how the pay gap would be more accurate if information like education and experience were taken as part of the data that was put into the pay gap. It also makes a lot of points on why the gender pay gap is not solely based on discrimination, much like the first article I went over talked about. I feel like this article makes a lot of very good points and clearly points out some obvious reasons as to why the gender pay gap isn’t only based on discrimination. He even points out that, “Among never-married individuals without children, for example, the pay gap is actually negative—in this group, women earn more than men, because they have better educational qualifications” (Biggs). Later in the article, Biggs goes on to talk about how women that are married and have children are more likely to pick jobs with better benefits than jobs with better pay. This makes it seem like the pay gap is bigger, but in reality, if the benefits are added in with all the other factors that are not added in, the pay gap practically disappears …show more content…
I chose this one last because it counters the articles previous to it and brings in a different view. This article is mainly about bringing awareness to the true reasons of the gender pay gap and how gender stereotypes affect the pay gap. In the article, Lips mentions that “Gender-specific specialization was associated with strong gender-specific socialization and occupational segregation. While females were taught to behave in a cooperative, selfless, and nurturing way, males were taught to behave in a competitive and selfish way” (Lips 936). With this said, it is obvious why men are more likely to ask for a higher pay, while women are less likely to because they feel uncomfortable with it. This is due to how men and women grew up with stereotypes. Women are supposed to feel okay with making less than men because of this problem. The article then goes on to talk about how women believe that they should make less than a man. They even paid themselves less than men did in a survey (Lips 937). These things are again due to how each gender grew up. When children are growing up I feel like they are immediately taught how to act depending on their gender. Girls are supposed to have good manners while boys aren’t really taught as much to be

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    The only explanation for male dominated occupations being higher paying is the employers. The employers enable the wage gap. Companies value a man’s work more than a woman’s. It is not just one article who claims that because England states: “For example, if secretaries are paid less than janitors, it may be because employers tend to pay a job filled with men more than one filled with women” (913). The gender wage gap continues to exist because of the way companies run.…

    • 1740 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The natural difference schema is an explanation for unequal outcomes, such as gender inequality in an attempt to create a cognitive map to make sense of the world. It tries to get us to believe that men and women are biologically different from birth and therefore men are born superior to women. This then allows for society to treat men and women differently in the workplace, because the natural difference schema guides their interactions and behaviors with other individuals. The natural difference schema is very strong and almost impossible to challenge. We would think that a transgender male or female would challenge this idea of the gender binary and the schema, but instead we forget people’s past.…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though women imply their desired pay, they avoid asking directly and are more likely to take “no” as a response. Females generally set lower ambitions for themselves as compared to males “and are satisfied with less; they believe lower pay is fair.” Scholars argue that this is possibly due to the fact that women are more inclined to compare their salary to other women, instead of men. Also, society has put emphasis on the idea that females should not exhibit bold behaviour, such as negotiation, because it is interpreted as being rude. However, females should view negotiation as a professional matter, rather than a personal…

    • 1055 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ogranizationally, by looking at Bem’s studies, the male’s emphasis on heiracrchy and dominance, especially compared to women, can explain why men tend to be “valued” over women in general. Bem also points out how when discussing differences between males and females in social science, it is focused on social aspects (socialization and situatinoal constraint), psychodynamic conflict, and identity construction. Social aspects are something the culture, or meso/macro level, does to the individual. Shame resiliance theory states that the shame a woman feels is a product of social and cultural expectations, which are mostly impossible to meet. All of this can be tied into my example of the wage gap, while at the same time discussing how women’s developmental models can be seen by economic forces as well.…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It strikes me that employers tried to incorporate or adjust benefit plans between males and females because women tend to ‘contribute more’ due to their average lifespan being larger. The Supreme Court ruled this requirement to be illegal. That’s right, the average of a women’s lifespan impacted employers enough to attempt to make a difference in benefits plans. Yet, women are still being jipped and paid lower than men, while doing the same job. This is unequal, and unfair.…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In connection to biological differences of men and woman, “males score higher than females on most measures of direct competitiveness, and competition tends to be a more positive experience for males than it is for females. Thus, what I understood from this was that men like to compete more than women. Men and women have different tastes and talents interest, and because of this there is also discrimination. “Gender discrimination comes from years ago. However, despite improvements, female scientists continue to face discrimination, unequal pay and funding disparities” this article shows how there still some discrimination in the workplace.…

    • 1033 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Another example is the fact the women have less access to job positions in contrary to men, and women are also being discriminated from certain job positions. This is another example of how social construction of gender leads to superiority of men over women. In order to solve this problem, it is very important to challenge the social construction of gender and gender discrimination. There is several different actions that can be taken in order to change the social construction of gender, but the two most important in my belief are equalizing wages between men and women, and providing equal access to job position for men and women. Equal wages for men and women would make women less financially dependent on men, and therefore it would take away some power from men.…

    • 1332 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Essay On Gender Pay

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Creating this divide in the pay between the two sexes causes damage to both men and women, and should have become a thing of the past long ago. Women being paid less is simply objectifying, it leads only to further discrimination of all people, it perpetuates the stereotype that men are superior to women, and it leads men to believe these things to be true. The rights of women have come a long way, but there is farther still they must go. There may come a day when it finally rings true that all people are created equal and treated as such, or this could simply be a pipe dream of the common folk. Only time will truly tell if equality can truly be achieved.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Unfair Pay Research Paper

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Employer is one thing to blame since they think that a woman’s occupation in not as complicated or imperative as a man’s job. Another thing is the way the government sets wages up. There has always been a sense of inequality when it comes to genders wages in the government and it is no secret as expressed in the statistics. There is no doubt that is discrimination is coming from leaders who believe in superiority among genders and control through segregation. They oppress one sex while making it easier for the other to succeed and excel…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Praxis And Feminism

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The patriarchy is maintained, “by the weapons of sexism: economics, violence and homophobia,” (Pharr 83). Probably one of the most prominent ways in which the patriarchy controls women economically is through the gender wage gap, the systematic economic system in which women are payed less simply because of their gender, even though they do the same, and if not more, amount of work than men (Launius and Hassel 49-50). Moreover, it is actually proven…

    • 1453 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays