Analysis Of Tecumseh And The Quest For Indian Leadership

Improved Essays
Carolyn Hook
Professor Menzing
History 117 MW 5:30 pm
July 30, 2017
Tecumseh
Looking at Tecumseh life as a warrior and leader according to the book Tecumseh and the Quest for Indian Leadership by R. David Edmunds. In the first few chapters of the book by Mr. Edmunds, he talks about the early life of Tecumseh family. Tecumseh was the fifth child more to his parents he had several brothers and sisters. In about 1774 in an attack at Point Pleasant his father Puckeshinwa was killed by the British which left a big void in the family's life. The older children and some of the tribe's people tried to help provide for the family by giving them food, and different items to help them survive, time was hard for everyone at this stage. Due to an attack
…show more content…
He would not sign a treaty if it meant they would have to concede their land, hunting areas. But the American’s kept pushing and pushing the Indians further and further off their land. The few things we did give them was diseases, hunger, and broken treaties. So Tecumseh started a war party which traveled up and down the Ohio Valley and great lakes region trying to get all the tribes and Indian people to come together and fights against the Americans to save their land and traditions. He could not find enough warriors that would fight, they all just wanted to be at peace and felt they should not fight and cause any new problems for them. They kept signing new treaties each time we would move them off their land and make promises which we never would keep. Tecumseh still could not get his fellow tribesmen to rally together to fight. But day his younger brother who they thought had drunk himself to death. He woke up and said he had a vision and that the Indians should go back to their old Indian traditions and leave all things good and bad that the whites or Americans had given them behind and he his younger brother became a medicine and holy man and together they would campaign for the Indians to come …show more content…
David Edmunds titled Tecumseh in Retrospect talks about how even the “American men who had opposed Tecumseh, had exclaimed, exhaled, gloried him.”( Edmunds pg 205) “Lewis Cass described him as a man of more enlarged views than are often found among the Indian Chiefs; a brave warrior and a skillful leader, politic in his measures and firm in his purpose.” (Edmunds pg 205) “John Johnston who had served as an Indian agent for the Shawnees, rank Tecumseh as amoung the great men of his race, who aimed at the independence of his people by a nation of all the Indians, North and South, against the encroachments of the whites. (Edmunds pg 205) “Had he appeared fifty years sooner he might have set bounds to the Anglo-Saxon race in the West” (Edmunds pg 205) Even Harrison had good to say about him he stated “ one of those uncommon geniuses, which spring up occasionally to produce revolutions and overturn the established order of things… No difficulties deter him… Wherever he goes, he makes an impression favorable to his purpose.” ( Edmunds pg 205,206) So after his death men though good about him and he became a myth and a legend of his

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Then even the things they did promise them, they did not follow through with. The author mentions “broken treaties and promises” as the reasons for many of the hardships of the Natives. Finally, many of the Sioux had enough of the broken promises and stood up for themselves. Red Cloud had been trying to see the white man’s side and had believed their word, yet even he finally saw the light. At one point, he was in a meeting when he found out the soldiers were there to open a road in the Powder Country, that was supposed to be off limits.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Tecumseh wants peace and freedom, but “where the white people are, there is no peace for them” (Tecumseh 233). His fight for peace is also one for equality with the white man so that his people will not be viewed as savages, but as an independent nation who has a right to own and live on the land of their ancestors. Using violence against those hurting innocent people and children is acceptable for a hero, but it must be humane. When he was young, Tecumseh witnessed cruelty from both whites and natives. He once observed a white man being burned at the stake and was so horrified that he severely rebuked his fellow Indians.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the book, it talks about how Tecumseh refused to take action in the negotiations of the Treaty of Greenville. He was too focused on sticking to his traditional ways, and did not want to change. For example, the Shawnees believed that the “Master of Life” had fully supplied them with enough food, and plants they would ever need. Another Shawnee tradition was the scared dances they performed for the “Master of Life” as well as the other spirits that helped them in their everyday lives. Another chapter in his book discussed one of his brothers by the name of Lalawethika.…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It is unclear why Jackson disliked the Indians so much but it can be inferred that he wanted that farm land they were taking up to go to his supporters, since they could help him become more popular throughout the country. Jackson sent military officials into the lands of the Natives to clear them out but it was the Cherokee’s story that stuck out the most. This group of Indians put up a fight when it came to getting moved west of the Mississippi but eventually gave up and took the long, dreadful trip across the Mississippi to Oklahoma. (Document 5). This trip became known as the Trail of Tears and many of the Indians did not make it to their destination because of the extreme cold, diseases, and starvation.…

    • 1238 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the “Fences,” Troy dose not fight for his own benefits because he knows soon or later he will be death. He wants his sons to learn how to fight for their rights as he says racism in the work environment, which stops improving or promotion of minority groups. This reminded me when my great grandfather lost his life because of his grandchildren, where he was treated unequally among other people because he was not from same tribe. My great grandfather was an illiterate man. He wanted to attend school, however, he could not because he was not allowed to attend at school where mostly Pashtun tribe were living, which is the biggest tribe in Afghanistan even today.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Since Polyneices wanted the crown for himself and he wanted to take it from Kreon, he left Thebes, went and made an army of his own elsewhere so that he may take the crown by force. Since he was killed in the battle and his army left, Kreon made sure no person would show his brother respect. He told them to leave the body unburied so that the birds may make a meal of the body. We don't know Kreon did anything else to disown his brother’s memory, but we can only assume he did. So, no one in the kingdom really did have any respect for Polyneices.…

    • 1354 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The war had a hard toll on a lot of the country’s involved and it was hard to see the point of this war. They were thinking it was a waste of time but nobody wanted to quit the war so they both just keep batting hoping somebody would give in from fatigue. They never expected the war to last for 20 years. For those against the war it seemed that we were just throwing solders to their death for no reason. For the people who are in favor of the war or even people who were in the war it seemed that they were betrayed somehow and they wanted to find an answer.…

    • 1114 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He was tired of independence.(pg. 34) He thought about running away to Canada just so he didn’t have to carry a rifle. Tim and his friend Erik even made a coalition against the army.(Pg. 35) They say it was a war of resistance to save their souls.(Pg. 35) The two both read poems and enjoyed them, but they wouldn’t talk about them around other people because the other soldiers were all about war.…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When Phineas returns to Devon, he says to Gene, “’there isn’t any war.’ … ‘The fat old men who don’t want us crowding them out of their job. They’ve made it all up’” (105-106). To protect himself from the reality of war, Phineas creates an illusion about the war because he understands that the injury in his leg would stop him from joining the war. However,when his best friend, Gene, has the desire to enlist without him, Phineas feels obsolete since , unlike most of the other students at Devon, he cannot enlist. Then, when Gene returns to Devon, he tells Phineas about Leper and Phineas says, “’Just dizzy war, this fake this thing with the old men making’” (148).…

    • 988 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history Native Americans have had problems with the American government and land. Andrew Jackson was not a big fan of letting the Indians keep land that interfered with the American expansion plan. The Natives thought that nobody could own land and were surprised it was being taken and they were moved. Although the Native Americans believed nobody could own land they seemed to be very angry when they were moved away from it. The natives claimed that land was sacred and cannot be owned by man and his ancestors.…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays