Abstinence Vs. Comprehensive Analysis

Better Essays
Abstinence v. Comprehensive
An Analysis of the Respective Results Sex education has always been a controversial topic, especially to which it is taught. The Reagan administration passed the Adolescent Family Life Act for abstinence-only education, based on the presumption that talking about sex in school would promote sexual activities among teenagers. The President quietly passed the two-point act 1981, as the House of Representatives did not vote on it. The government coded the act under Title XX of the Public Service Health Act. The first point was to provide at least two-thirds of funds to support pregnant teenagers, while the second point’s purpose was to use the remaining one-third or less to discourage sexual acts until marriage. Lawrence
…show more content…
Leyba (2014) detailed the story of her pregnancy at 18 years old, and how the struggle of sexual “sin” consumed her for years. She wished that her teachers had completely explained virginity pledges to children choosing to accept them, because she did not fully understand what she signed over. Leyba stated that she never considered abortion because it was taught as a terrible, awful sin, not an option that could have been considered. Though she does not regret her decision to keep her child, she wished that all sex education taught about contraceptives and condoms, because she does not want her daughter to go through the same thing she had to (para. 2-5). Leyba was taught abstinence-only education in a hyper-religious Christian school. She did not understand the serious importance that contraceptive-methods held, because she was never told anything about them, except for how much they failed and that using them would make her a sinner. Though most schools are not religious like hers, most principles of abstinence-only education are based in the Christian faith. There should be a separation of education and government, because not every student believes in …show more content…
In Stanger-Hall and Hall’s (2011) study, they discussed that states with legislation coded two or three, likely mentioned that medically accurate information need not be taught, because the state legislature would rather scare some children out of sex with some scary, but inaccurate statements. This shocked the team, since teaching inaccuracies like “birth control only works sometimes” or “STDs and STIs will ruin their life” was morally wrong. Since this was most likely an impressionable moment in a teenager’s life to first learn about sex, Stanger-Hall and Hall realized that the medically wrong information would stick with the children for some time, likely to be discussed among friends and therefore spread (p. 7). Stanger-Hall and Hall thought it was unfortunate that the government decided to scare children with misinformation, opposed to informing them on their bodies to delay sexual

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Abstinence In Teens

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages

    What is hard to understand is why the parents think that if you teach them that how to use birth control, it encourages teens to have sex. That is completely wrong to educate is not to encourage. Sure, abstaining is one way to prevent having a child, but there are so many other ways to prevent it. There are so many different types of birth control…

    • 1512 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Young adults, no matter what is taught to them, will still have premarital sex. When abstinence students do decide to get intimate, they wind up in danger because their sex ed program didn’t teach them how to have sex safely. This increases the spread of STIs and the rate of pregnancy amongst teenagers, who may rely on futile rumors for safe sex advice if no proper sex education is provided. Statistically, teenage parents are much more negatively affected than older parents, which translates into an unhappy upbringing for the child. Most abstinence-only programs’ goal is to keep students from having sex until marriage.…

    • 2087 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Abstinence Only Education

    • 1558 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Within the United States of America there is a large controversial topic in debate that has been around for over one hundred years, sexual education in schools. There are two main sides within this debate where people are either for comprehensive sexual education or for abstinence only sexual education. Each type of curriculum has its own support for why it should be taught; one of these two methods has had terrible results to show for its teachings. Informing teenagers of sex can include abstinence while providing more comprehensive education. The sexual education in the United States should be based upon facts and statistics instead of a “just say no” curriculum.…

    • 1558 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Not teaching comprehensive sex-ed can lead to teen pregnancies and/or diseases. With sex-ed programs in school today they are only teaching teens not to have sex. Some argue that if people learn about sex they will become curious. According to this belief, the curiosity will lead to more teens having sex. I believe it to be the opposite.…

    • 1126 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Due to parent’s having concerns that their child will become sexually active too early, they are putting their children at risk of not being prepared for dealing with how to properly handle what is expected to happen during their teenage and young adult years. Abstinence only sexual education is believed to be the best form of sexual education by many parents, but in reality it can cause a number of negative effects on teenager’s sexual knowledge and their abstinence. Abstinence only sexual education’s main focus is to inform teenagers that they should remain abstinent until they are married. Abstinence only sex education typically does not include any type of information on the reproductive system, contraception, preventing diseases and pregnancy, or how to have sex safely. Most abstinent only programs have also been proven to be “biased”, based on religious beliefs, include false information about the effectiveness of the use contraceptives, masturbation, and abortion.…

    • 1798 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    “Don 't have sex, you will get pregnant and die!”, a well-known quote from the film comedy Mean Girls. While this quote is quite humorous, it is misleading and like many sex education courses provides an unclear message to adolescents. Young people are easily influenced by movies, and without a comprehensive sex education, they can make life changing mistakes. The way sex is massively shown in society today will not change; therefore, the form of sex education in schools must change. A comprehensive sex education teaches students complete, accurate, and age-appropriate sex education that helps them reduce their risk of HIV/AIDS, other sexually transmitted infections (STIs), and unintended pregnancy.…

    • 1611 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    When there is no parent teaching about sex, it can lead to negative impact on to the children. For example in Adolescent expectancies, parent-adolescent communication and intentions to have sexual intercourse among inner-city, middle school youth, Guilamo-Ramos had explain, “peer norms were more strongly associated with sexual behavior for adolescents who had not discussed sex or condoms with a parent”. This shows that teenagers’ knowledge about sex will come from friends’ experience, movies, or televisions because the parents are not telling them anything. Friends would be the one “educating” them about their experience such as their sex lives. If a best friend advises you something like, “you can’t get pregnant the first time you have sex”.…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    By constantly missing school, he was prevented from gaining the instruction that he deserved and needed. Part of this missed education would have been a proper sexual education. Wes Moore had a biased attitude that it was the sole responsibility of the female to prevent pregnancy, which was reflected as he questioned, “How could Alicia have let herself get pregnant? He thought maybe it was a mistake. Maybe the results would change” (Moore 99).…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While they agree on the demand to reduce teen pregnancy, they cannot agree on what program should be implemented to address this issue. Abstinence-only programs are teaching teens that “abstinence is the only method of birth control that is 100% effective” (“Does learning about birth control in school help prevent teen pregnancy?”). Followers of this program state that teaching teens about birth control would undeniably give them the consent to be sexually active. Comprehensive sex education program supporters dispute that the reason why teen pregnancy rates have dropped is due to birth control education and the fact that teens are actually using it. From the article “Impact of Sex Education On Pregnancy Examined,” the author Mary Breaden states that “students who were taught a comprehensive sex education curriculum had a 50 percent lower risk of getting pregnant or impregnating someone than students who had received an abstinence-only education or no sex education at all” (Breaden).…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    However, public schools should focus more on Sexuality/Sex education than on the Abstinence-only program. First of all the Abstinence-only program is not effective. A 2015 study show, young people ages 13-24 makeup 24 percent of new cases of HIV. Abstinence-only program is a program that teaches abstinence from sexual activity…

    • 947 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays