Analysis Of Abortion By Don Marquis

Good Essays
Why is fetus not a baby?

Don Marquis sets out to prove once and for all that abortion is seriously wrong. However, in certain cases such as the form of a pregnancy that could endanger the mother’s life when the fetus is anencephalic, it can be permitted. In his argument, Marquis claims that abortion is wrong because it is wrong to kill a hermit and the loss of one’s life deprives one of all the experiences that would have established one’s future. I shall argue that although these claims seem to be successful, they still have errors. I suggest that abortion is permitted because the woman has the right to her body, the fetus is not a person and Marquis invalid argument about future of value. In country X where women are not granted political or civil rights; they receive only minimal education; and they are not permitted to make any important economic or social decisions regarding their lives. If the woman living in this country becomes pregnant with a healthy female fetus but she wants to abort it, its her decision. She desires to have an abortion because she does not want her daughter to grow up in a country in which females lead such restricted lives. According to Don Marquis, the mother’s decision is morally wrong. First of all, the fetus is healthy and when it is killed, it is deprived of all the future
…show more content…
In contrast, I think that the fetus is not a person as it lacks the mental states that many philosophers take to be necessary for personal identity. Since it is not the same as the person who will or would have that future, it is not morally wrong to abort. However, Marquis emphasizes that his argument avoids the concept of a person. Consequently, Marquis can respond that the fetus is the same organism as the body into which it will or would develop, even if it is not the same person. Marquis’s argument works just as well if he refers to the future of the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Abortion Research Paper

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Abortion is legal in the United States of America and rightly so. In other countries abortion laws are restrictive that even when a mother’s life is in jeopardy a woman does not have the choice to abort. The feeling when a doctor tells you that you are going to die because of a complication with the fetus in your womb can be devastating. The doctor claims he cannot abort the fetus because of the laws to protect life. This research paper will evaluate the reasons why abortion should be legal in every country around the world by the help of scholarly journals and testimonials of real woman on the benefiting factor of abortion.…

    • 1037 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This analogy is challenging the more extreme view held by those in opposition to abortion. This view finds abortion “impermissible even to save the mother’s life.” Imagine a woman has become pregnant and in the same day learns of a newly developed heart disease that will kill her if she carries her baby to term. The baby has a right to life, but so does the woman. Thomson brings up the argument most familiar. “Performing the abortion would be directly killing the child, whereas doing nothing would not be killing the mother, but letting her die.” The conclusion that is drawn from this scenario is that your own right to life gives you the moral right to “unplug” yourself if your life is threatened.…

    • 1953 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In other words, abortion is wrong because killing a future child stops it from growing and making a difference to their lives. The child 's mother whom is having the abortion does not know if that baby will make a change in the future, the possibilities are endless. First take a look at Marquis argument of why abortion is immortal. Marquis argument is that any living thing; human or animal, has their future taken away. He starts of the essay…

    • 792 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Abortion Argument Essay

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Mothers who abort their children do not show much love for their child. It is understandable to see why a mother would abort her child if her life is at risk, but this is at the expense of a baby, who has no part in the decision. Abortion disrespects the safety of a child, which ultimately end in death. Not only is abortion unsafe for a child, but abortion can cause health problems in a woman later on. Abortion is immoral and unsafe for a mother and her child.…

    • 875 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It should never be “lawful” to kill any innocent human being.” In this quote they are saying that it should never be lawful to kill an innocent human being but these people don’t know what situation the woman could be in and why she needs the abortion. Maybe she has health problems or was forced to have this baby. “It’s wrong for a mother to have the right to kill her children.” Most people think it’s not the mother’s choice to have the right to kill her own child while the child is in the womb. Which is completely wrong…

    • 1431 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    9. Abortion should be an option, there is no argument for it, if you think there is, then you are ignorant, we deserve to have the right to choose what happens to our own unborn child, it’s too far to say. ban abortions, that’s like saying "it’s your body, but as the government, we control what does and doesn’t come out of it" 10. "They didn 't use birth control pills at all" "they didn 't know about wrapping it up" he could have easily used a condom. Don’t blame it on the girl for getting pregnant.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In cases like this it is hard to harm the fetus. As Thomson believes, the baby doesn’t necessarily have a right to the mother’s body because the mother was wrongfully harmed and has no intentions of having a child. In a situation like this, Thomson believes that it would be okay to have an abortion as long as the fetus isn’t…

    • 1137 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Abortion is a big topic that everyone has a different view on it. Such as Thomson who believes that abortion should be a right and that women should not be denied to it because it is their body. Judith Thomson is correct in saying that a woman does not have a duty to preserve the life of her fetus even if it is her genetic child. As the supreme court stated, denying an abortion may lead stressful life and future for the mother. A woman has a right to do what she pleases with her body especially in the case of rape-induced pregnancy.…

    • 1308 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I don’t believe that Aristotle would agree that abortion would lead to Eudemonia for the child, in most cases, because it is essentially taking the child’s life away without giving the child a chance to achieve happiness. If a woman chooses abortion then her child will never have the opportunity to have virtues instilled. When speaking in terms of the mother, she will never be able to achieve Eudemonia. This is because she will never be able to be an ideal person as she has taken the life of her own child in a sense, whether there was good reason for her choice or not. Aristotle believes that people’s experiences can give them character or virtue.…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Warren’s article “Abortion Is Morally Permissible” discusses if a fetus deserves to have a right to live. She begins her argument with describing why fetuses do not deserve rights because they do not have any traits of personhood. She then points out that even throughout the entire pregnancy a fetus does not deserve rights, she ends her argument by stating that even though a fetus has the potential to become a person it should not have as much rights as a pregnant women who is already a person. Warren’s argument is thought out and has very little mistakes, but the few mistakes that are there can be pulled apart and can be used to destroy her argument. In the article “Abortion Is Morally Permissible” Warren argues that a women should be allowed…

    • 1931 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays

Related Topics