Why Laptops In Class Are Distracting The Workforce By Timothy Handich Analysis

Good Essays
The article, “Why Laptops in Class Are Distracting America’s Future Workforce” was written by Timothy D. Snyder in 2010. His purpose in writing this article was to persuade professors against having laptops in the classroom because he feels they are a distraction. The arguments Snyder uses against laptops in classrooms are, they distract students’ attention, students miss out of the best part of American life, and he generalizes that this lack of attention will spill over into the workplace.
Snyder discusses various online chatting forums such as Skype, Gchat, or iChat that students are engaged in on their laptops during class. In addition to this, he goes on to list other online activities students engage in, such as making travel plans, reading
…show more content…
In stating another new class of freshmen is lost, he is implying the freshmen’s attention is on their laptops and not focused on learning and listening to their professors. He also stresses the importance of people learning from other people directly and claims we are losing a long tradition of this. This long tradition he speaks of is many years and generations, people listen, observe others and learn from them, without the use of the internet. He goes on to say losing this tradition of reaching others by speech is what it means to be human. In defining this phrase, as human beings, language is primarily how we exchange ideas and knowledge, give feedback, ask questions, therefore, using speech and talking, instead of googling is what it means to be human. The phrase becoming a class in the statement that laptops are barriers, preventing students from becoming a class if students don’t interact they won’t become a group with common ground and interest, they will remain separate people, not united in a common goal in a classroom. Snyder makes a lot of statements in this article, but does not have any real concrete evidence to back his ideas up. …show more content…
These positive words help the reader sway towards his argument. He states that students learning in the classroom has richness and precision they cannot get online. The use of the words richness and precision can sway the reader into thinking this is the only or best way to credibly learn. He further describes his classroom without computers as calm. In contrast, he used negative words referring to laptops in the classroom. He describes them as loud and flashy, and refers to their glow as distractions. Snyder states, “Meanwhile, we are losing a long tradition of people learning from other people” (166). Traditions are very special and passed down generations. To lose these traditions is very disheartening, therefore, using these words has a very negative emotional effect on a reader’s attitudes towards the possible loss of learning happening with laptops present. Snyder makes hasty generalizations such as that students lack the ability to pay attention. Students chose to focus on other things, such as computers, but this choice is no necessarily a lack of ability to do so. He uses the faulty cause and effect when stating that once students start researching on the internet, they follow links and go from googling a subject such as Habermas, to reading about Lady Gaga. Furthermore, using these two names in comparing, Habermas is a social philosopher,

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Phoebe Loehr English II 10 October 2014 Ms. Etelamaki Techniques of Learning At Dartmouth College an email went around the department about why a professor wanted laptops banned in classrooms, Dan Rockmore in his article “The Case for Banning Laptops in the Classroom” speaks about why he agrees with his colleague and his reasoning. I agree with Rockmore’s theory on the disadvantages of having laptops in the classroom because they can be the cause of distraction, disrespect, and non-integration. From personal experience, I agree with Dan Rockmore that laptops in the classroom should be banned because they are distracting. While in the classroom, I have caught myself multiple times on social media, online shopping, or other websites rather than…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    With online learning the parent or an in home tutor is not teaching the student, a teacher through the computer is teaching the student through email or virtual classroom, but the parent does not have to be present. A lot of people say this is another way for students to get lazy and become unfocused and fall behind in their education process. But I completely disagree, I find this as an opportunity for the student to get completely ahead if they are focused, and determined, you could graduate early and then have time to figure out what you actually want to do. I think you just have to know your student and know if they would thrive in an education environment at home. Also you need to trust your child if your student is saying they want to try online school from home, you should let them try it and if they don 't like it, they can just go back to normal school, its really not that big a deal.…

    • 1230 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    As technology increases new pieces are being used around us, more specifically, in the classrooms. Some people believe that technology such as laptops hinder our learning efficiency while other argue that they can help students. The introduction of laptops to the educational process is controversial to many teens. Even though laptops removed the book factor, they are dampening the learning process, because it creates a distraction, they are difficult to use and it only helps assist the users in finding greater ways to cheat, which is why sticking to pencil and paper is the correct way to go about learning. Students are given a laptop with enough internet access to enjoy any movie, article, game, etc.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Online education may seem like a great alternative to a traditional class, but being present in a classroom environment creates a cultivating social environment. With online learning services, students are often isolated with only a computer to interact with, which causes communication problems. Nevertheless, in a traditional educational setting, students interact with both their teacher and fellow students as well. The absence of a teacher and other students for feedback, online learning courses create confusion, frustration and anxiety because you are learning independently. The online learning classes offer litter to no face-to-face communication between student and instructor.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    It has been proven that technology is distracting as shown in the quote, “Many studies find that the use of laptops and smart phones by some students in a class room is a distraction not only to the student using the device, but to others as well” (Griffin, 5). The author, Audrey Griffin, also states in her article that the “Use of technology affects one’s ability to pay attention and comprehend the material, leading to lower test scores and grades” (5), which means that by using technology we are only creating bigger obstacles for ourselves. Technology was presented to the classroom as a way to help students learn more efficiently. If it is used correctly in the classroom, then it will become an aid to students, but if not, it will only create more distractions and challenges in today’s society. Even though home life, guidance, and technology continue to be a problem in today’s educational system, there are many resources out there that were not available in the past that make receiving an education possible.…

    • 1042 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Computers and technology can help students with their homework and research, but computers can also be a distraction to students if they are not being used properly in class. It seems that as the years go by, technology continues to have more and more of an effect on us. Advancing technology has completely taken over a student’s learning ability. Despite all the benefits we achieve through technology, it has shown significant effects, both positive and negative, in classrooms. I believe that computers should not be allowed in a classroom because students won’t get their assignments done, it is a distraction to both students and teachers, and it can also get in the way of the teacher effectively conveying the lessons to students.…

    • 1236 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    With this addiction to social media and teenagers being glued to the screens of their devices, it is difficult for students to associate with one another face to face. This addiction to technology may also cause social anxiety. Another disadvantage of technology in the classroom is the cyberbullying trap. Cyberbullying may come about in the classroom by “giving students access to anonymous accounts and endless contact avenues” (2). With the freedom of technology, there would be no way to monitor what the students are doing or punish the students doing the bullying.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A report from the Office of Intellectual freedom, says,” “The over-filtering that occurs today affects not only what teachers can teach but also how they teach.” (Batch) Teachers are responsible for students learning and if they cannot find the material they need to teach their students then Web Blockers are killing those students’ education. Teachers watch out for students’ education, but they are not the only ones when librarian Judy Gressel says, “It just got to the point that it became hard to conduct research; students could not read sites about, say, military weapons for a history paper.” (Hu) Librarians welcome research and love when kids have access to information making it a terrible and frustrating day for them when web blockers deter students from information. In the end, teacher and librarians are frusted by web blockers the deter students from information and hinder student’s…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I have a lot of common ground with the author on this subject; I too believe that students should be able to control themselves, if they can’t handle the simple task of paying attention in class and proper laptop etiquette then being in Business school is a waste because they won’t learn anything from it because they’ve always been to busy typing away on social networks to pay attention. The only new thing to me in this article is the fact that a school actually installed a switch that can terminate interact access while in class. Although I find it very childish, I also think it is incredibly fascinating that someone was able to think of that. This essay made me think that they’re will be professors’ in the future that will totally ban computer use in class further making students upset because they pay thousands of dollars every semester, so they’ll feel entitled to be able to use their computers no matter what. Although some student abuse the privilege of computer use in class,…

    • 1073 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Have you ever been connected to a school network or internet and encountered a filter? Of course you have! This makes you angry because you were trying to do an honest mans work and your websites have been blocked due to the overprotection of your superiors! According to the The American Association of School Librarians (AASL), ninety four percent of United States schools use internet filters. Students should not be required to use internet blockers because: they often restrict access to websites that can be used for academic purpose, they stop kids from learning responsibility with the web, and instead diverting the students attention away from games and other sites, it diverts their attention to learning how to get around these filters.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays