Why Laptops In Class Are Distracting The Workforce By Timothy Handich Analysis

Improved Essays
The article, “Why Laptops in Class Are Distracting America’s Future Workforce” was written by Timothy D. Snyder in 2010. His purpose in writing this article was to persuade professors against having laptops in the classroom because he feels they are a distraction. The arguments Snyder uses against laptops in classrooms are, they distract students’ attention, students miss out of the best part of American life, and he generalizes that this lack of attention will spill over into the workplace.
Snyder discusses various online chatting forums such as Skype, Gchat, or iChat that students are engaged in on their laptops during class. In addition to this, he goes on to list other online activities students engage in, such as making travel plans, reading
…show more content…
In stating another new class of freshmen is lost, he is implying the freshmen’s attention is on their laptops and not focused on learning and listening to their professors. He also stresses the importance of people learning from other people directly and claims we are losing a long tradition of this. This long tradition he speaks of is many years and generations, people listen, observe others and learn from them, without the use of the internet. He goes on to say losing this tradition of reaching others by speech is what it means to be human. In defining this phrase, as human beings, language is primarily how we exchange ideas and knowledge, give feedback, ask questions, therefore, using speech and talking, instead of googling is what it means to be human. The phrase becoming a class in the statement that laptops are barriers, preventing students from becoming a class if students don’t interact they won’t become a group with common ground and interest, they will remain separate people, not united in a common goal in a classroom. Snyder makes a lot of statements in this article, but does not have any real concrete evidence to back his ideas up. …show more content…
These positive words help the reader sway towards his argument. He states that students learning in the classroom has richness and precision they cannot get online. The use of the words richness and precision can sway the reader into thinking this is the only or best way to credibly learn. He further describes his classroom without computers as calm. In contrast, he used negative words referring to laptops in the classroom. He describes them as loud and flashy, and refers to their glow as distractions. Snyder states, “Meanwhile, we are losing a long tradition of people learning from other people” (166). Traditions are very special and passed down generations. To lose these traditions is very disheartening, therefore, using these words has a very negative emotional effect on a reader’s attitudes towards the possible loss of learning happening with laptops present. Snyder makes hasty generalizations such as that students lack the ability to pay attention. Students chose to focus on other things, such as computers, but this choice is no necessarily a lack of ability to do so. He uses the faulty cause and effect when stating that once students start researching on the internet, they follow links and go from googling a subject such as Habermas, to reading about Lady Gaga. Furthermore, using these two names in comparing, Habermas is a social philosopher,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In “A Technological Cloud Hangs Over Higher Education” author Keith Williams states that technology in the classroom today is totally different than the past. Because there are easier ways to get notes, PowerPoints, and lectures simply by downloading them from the internet. Whereas, before the internet, the student had to actually take notes during class. Williams asserts his statement by giving examples throughout the essay about not having to use hot projectors anymore to do lectures. Also, not having to use an actual textbook, but rather use the internet or an eBook.…

    • 2502 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Since the early 1980’s, computers have proved to be a revolutionary advancement with regards to providing an efficient environment for the American educational system. However, one should note the use of the term efficient. Although computers provide a quick solution to many educational issues, they lack in providing an academic construct for students to build upon in the future. David Gelernter argues in his essay “Unplugged: The Myth of Computers in the Classroom” why computers will do more harm than good in educating todays tomorrow. Gelernter does not merely direct his argument toward teachers and professors, but he addresses parents and caregivers as well.…

    • 1124 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Both articles “New Class(room) War: Teacher vs. Technology” by Samuel G. Freedman published in 2007 and “What is the future of technology in education?” by Matt Britland published in 2013, discuss the role of technology in schools. Freedman believes that technology is a form of distraction that teachers have to compete with, for students’ attention while Britland maintains that technology can enable students to learn and collaborate anywhere, specifically with the aid of the Cloud. Comparing both articles, Freedman’s article is stronger because he employs evidence that are more effective in supporting his main argument and his use of anecdotes makes his arguments more persuasive in illustrating the “war” that teachers have with technology in…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Education is so significant in our lives as it not only affects us directly, but also indirectly and impacts the people who are surrounding us and the people who will be born after us. Education is also provided to US citizens by the government through public schools. These public schools, intended to impart learning for any child in the country equally, has been creating a deep division in success mainly diverged by socioeconomic classes. What is wrong with the current US public education system? What could we do to fix a system that affects almost everyone in the country?…

    • 1750 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Town Hall Meeting

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Everyone in this meeting is aware that technology is everywhere. Those of you that have children realize that this generation depends heavily on technology. Students are spending more time on Snap Chat, Instagram and Facebook then actually reading a book. Also, students are using their eBooks, IPad, laptops and cell phones more than desktops. Cell phones and text messaging have allowed students to text back and forth between each other, conferring through the airwaves on exam questions.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some effects include addiction to technology and the way students remove themselves from social interactions to use their devices. As seen in both these pieces, technology has real and harmful…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Shut Off Your Screen Week According to Ritchel, “As skeptical as it sounds, video game players actually develop better visual activity.” (Ritchel). Relevant to said information, I think that our school should volunteer in the “Shut Off Your Screen Week. It is important for us to focus on school and not the technology that surrounds us.…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Are those under age thirty the dumbest generation no, because look around us all this new technology created and being used by us. Our generation has improved over the years with well improvement technology and resources. Before all this technology, everybody had to work hard to find resources and knowledge to survive. The way we all learn and get information has changed over the years with technology. When I mean technology I mean, computers, social media, phones, and internet.…

    • 410 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the article “How Google, Wikipedia Have Changed Our Lives-For Better and Worse”. Jennifer Woodard Maderazo Introduces How the internet has changed the learning aspect of students in school. It Inflicts how back then when modern technology wasn’t prevalent, students had to use books to research the questions they worked on. As of now in current times more students tend to use the internet as a more useful source than going to a library and taking the time to source/research the information. Also it Generalizes how when students began studying back then in the early ages students were more dedicated to learning about the class and relying on classroom experience.…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction The use of technology is being practiced more frequently in education then the vintage hand writing. Today, schools are more and more likely to have assignments due online. People will usually consider that technology is undoubtedly been a more convenient way to do things; however, some claim that the practice of technology has actually been beneficial. The argument is that technology such as computers are more than just an alternative, but is actually more efficient while the person is able to use the most out of his or her resources.…

    • 1258 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “It is possible for students to get so caught up in issues such as type font or audio clips that they pay less attention to the substantive content of their product….Teachers are developing strategies to make sure that students do not get distracted by some of the more enticing but less substantive features of technology” (effects of technology). The problem, today, is that with the technology the students have a toy in front of them which is taking their concentration away from the teacher and to the device that they have. The teacher should be the main focus in the room, not the computer or whatever they have. They are even losing focus on what the assignment is.…

    • 1312 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Laptops, tablets, and cell phones are essentials that many students own that are very common, however, these devices have the ability to make anything possible to the user. Sophia Harris states that “the society of today has become quite reliant on technology,” (Harris 2) in her famous article Pros and Cons of Using Technology in Your Classroom. In a way Harris is right, technology, especially cellular devices, are being used so much that students have grew so accustomed to them everywhere they go. Not every student learns and takes in information the same way, in correspondingly, one key impact technology has brought to the classroom is the wide range of independent learning for every student and their different learning…

    • 810 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critical thinking is a self-guided, self-disciplined thinking which attempt to do reason at higher level quality in a fair minded way. It allow the thinker to improve the quality of his or her thinking by skillful analyze, assess and reconstruction. But here the question is, Does technology is killing the critical thinking skills? In other words, the improved technology of the modern world had any impact on the way people think. According to my reading and research, I agree with Alfred Thompson as technology did have negative impact on the critical thinking.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ruth Starkman, while teaching a “Great Books” course in a Shanghai middle school over the summer, had come encounter with “CyberSlacking”. Starkman has taught all over the world. She has taught everything from high level college students, to primary school students in Asia. As an educator and global activist, Starkman is well aware of the benefits that technology has within schools. Starkman confesses in her article, “…I continue to allow devices for numerous reasons:…

    • 546 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Every college student has a laptop for homework, student account use, communications within a certain class, and other learning motives. Additionally, this technology is useful for professors and teachers to provide examples, create PowerPoints of information, or present informational videos to students. Overall it has created a better learning opportunity for teacher and student so it doesn’t seem like a teacher is lecturing all the time. To add to that, computers have also been the key component for people enrolled in online college. Having the opportunity to gain further education after high school might be a more affordable or comfortable fit for someone instead of a traditional college.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays