Comparison Of Love And Lust In 'Twelfth Night'

Improved Essays
The two tales depicts the female's perspective on love and lust which breaks the stereotype of women being too virtuous to express their desires. "Twelfth Night" portrays the idea of falling in love at first sight in which Viola and Olivia fall for the man of their desires. For Viola, her love for Orsino happens suddenly and with no actual reasoning, as she admits to falling in love with him after being told to woo Olivia for his sake. In Olivia's case, despite claiming to be in mourning for seven years in honor of her brother's passing away, she falls for Cesario. Not only does she love him, but she relentlessly pursues him and tries to get married to him despite Cesario's unwillingness. Considering Orsino's stand on love for men, he also …show more content…
Although she claims that her backstory is meant to illustrate her mastery over the concept of marriage, she shows the capacity to dominate men. She describes herself as 'wise' due to her experience “of five housbonde scoleying am I" (283 line 50). She presents counter-arguments to various beliefs on maidenhood subjected by men on her time, and uses her own experience and various references to enhance her claims. For the most part, the reader should not take her misquotes as a surety that she is mouthing non-sense, as this is her attempt to legitimize her claims. She copies the standard way of arguing for a cause by referencing various sources, but considers her main source, herself, to be vital and conclusive evidence. Though, she may be one representative, it does not change that her voice has credible authority over men's opinion on women. In one case, she questions if it is written in the Bible if marriage or getting remarried is sin (284 lines 65-67). However, she points out it is better “to be wedded than to brinne” (283 line 58). She uses religious beliefs to strengthen her claims of marriage being an enabler for women to embrace the joys of sex. In her opinion, she does not seek marriage explicitly to conceive, but to accept womenhood the way a woman should. Even if she is interrupted or glossed over by men, she continues on strongly in her argument, to the point that her voice cannot be ignored. She even shows she doesn’t care what the men will think by stating “[m]en may divine and glosen up and down,/ But wel I woot, withouten lie” (283 lines 26-27). Regardless if she is corrected, she knows that her statements are not lie because she has lived them and is living proof that it is possible to live as a powerful libertine woman. Thus the men allow her to finish her life story, because they are unable to stop her or defy her

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Once she draws them in to listen, she states “Take me on a date, I deserve it, babe”. She is expressing how she feels that she should get whatever she wants. She is giving the impression that women deserve things without having anything to show for it. She goes on to say “Cause if you 'll treat me right, I 'll be the perfect wife”, which shows that she will only act in response to what a man does first. If the guy pleases her then she will be a pleasing wife in return, but this shows that the man has to be worthy and he has to work to win her.…

    • 2069 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When each answer is Yes this gives women power and self-esteem compared to other ways that had been taught. In previous text it talks about God is Father and many other masculine terms used that described God, but also was in favor of men and being superior. I do not agree with the fact that God should be looked at as a women, but it helped women gain power. I refer to God as the Father and other masculine terms, but I do not feel as inferior as the women in this book talk about. I can agree with Haught in a way that God still favors us, just not in the way of referring to God as a woman.…

    • 1364 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thus, the stereotypes that she supports in her essay, are the most effective in gaining success in a male-dominated society. All in all, women should not be judged on their actions, as it is their choice to behave as they wish. Nevertheless, it is ok to have people like Levy who disagree with behaviors taken upon by others, if and only if, they continue to treat them as an equal. Raunch culture focuses not only on sex appeal but its control of the male observer. Be that it may, if a woman finds pleasure in holding such power over men with their sex appeal, then it should be their decision as to whether use it towards their benefit or not.…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Towards the end of the novel a humorous scene occurs when Mrs. Bennet completely contradicts herself while discussing how ecstatic she is about Mr. Darcy joining the family contrary to earlier where she claimed he was extremely distasteful. The scene ultimately evokes humerous feelings as well as more serious feelings revolving the actuality of the common theme throughout the novel of a mother 's unwavering desire to marry off her children. The conscious theme first appears when Mrs. Bennet forces Mr. Bennet to secure an invitation for her daughters to the Netherfield Ball in hopes of them finding love with Mr. Bingley. Second, Mrs. Bennet proceeds to prioritize the faintest possibility of marriage over the safety and health of Jane. Last, Mrs. Bennet is content with overlooking her Lydia’s wrongdoings because the child was married and therefore helped Mrs. Bennet accomplish her goal.…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Love is an unyielding force that eventually humbles us all. In his comedies, William Shakespeare attempts to define this elusive entity in the play Twelfth Night . The Twelfth Night is a romantic comedy about a girl named Viola who has to disguise herself as a man for protection after a shipwreck where she thought she lost her brother. As the play continues Viola develops feelings for the man she works for Orsino although he is a lovesick fool for Olivia who doesn’t want a relationship because she is still mourning over her brother. Orsino asks for Viola’s help to get Olivia to choose him.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Before Cecily has even met Jack’s brother Ernest she has begun to fantasize about him and created an imaginary relationship. When Algernon learns this and he is distraught by her obsession for him. He doesn’t even try to inform her about his real name because of the obsession she has with the name Ernest. She has even taken the initiative to get herself a ring and to have an engagement. Even though she is in love with Algernon she still has a superficial view on love where she is in love with the name just like Gwendolen.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Viola had in the process fallen in love with Orsino, with his noticings, and the way he talked about her. It had in turn began the turnings of a love triangle. P#2: Viola is told to be a messenger of Orsino’s love to Olivia, he tells Viola to confess his love, and how he wants nothing but here. This proves a bit complicated because Viola herself wants to Marry Orsino. After saying, “I’ll do my best/ To woo your lady…” Viola is besides herself, saying, “Yet, a barful strife--/ Whoe’er I woo, myself would be his wife.” (Twelfth Night Act I.IV).…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Though Shakespeare isn 't saying she must go out and find someone to share love and a marriage with, she still must make a decision as a beautiful woman regarding the many possible men who chase her. This still entertains the notion that men must pursue the woman they desire in order to have them, but maintains the idea that the choice ultimately lies within the woman who is being sought after. This dynamic empowers women, giving them the executive power to make this decision. This is why it is her duty to the world to pass on her attractiveness, and if she doesn 't, she is considered cruel as she wastes away beauty gifted to her by nature. This shifting of power from men to women was perhaps very controversial in the time he wrote this as it was the general consensus that men were those in power.…

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This is especially evident in her anecdote about priests who she says “have to be handsome” in order to remember “what you’ve just heard” from him (Shonagon 30). The Wife of Bath follows her long descriptive prologue which criticizes the need for female virginity with a tale that is prescriptive to prove her point about what relations between a married man and a woman ought to look like. Since these women have more than just a one-dimensional criticism of their societies, then, their intellectual foundation allows them to argue for a new value system of an aesthetic of balance within their society. Therefore, it is the value system that they present that is united, even if their…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Astell’s “A Religious Retirement” aggressively demands women to question if she is truly inferior simply because man has said so. She goes on the show that women are valuable just as women and if given the proper tools may accomplish great things in life just as men can. Cavendish begins by wanting women to become men. Change her lifestyle and adapt completely to the world he has created. She stops celebrating the beauty of women and the differences of the sexes only focusing on how they drag on the ground.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays