Compare Twelfth Night And She's The Man

Superior Essays
Twelfth Night and She’s the Man
Many people struggle in discovering who they truly are in certain situations. Some struggle with career choices, relationships, religion, and so many other things that life throws at you. The Twelfth Night by William Shakespeare is a comedic play about identity, true and false love, and adaption to new situations. This is also found in the movie based of the play called She’s the Man. In both versions a young woman named Viola makes a choice that effects many of the people around her. Even though her situation is slightly different in both film and play, it’s the choice she makes to hide her identity that brings her into many interesting, and challenging situations of making people fall in and out of love.
The
…show more content…
In the play Olivia has just lost both her father and brother, which leaves her extremely depressed and not wanting to be with anyone. Meeting Viola, or in this case Cesario, she falls deeply in love with the character. This causes issues for Viola because the comedic love triangle is formed with her right in the middle, because Orisno wants Viola to help Olivia marry him. Olivia finds Viola very compelling and attractive, she literally loves everything about him and declares it, “Thy tongue, thy face, thy limbs, actions and spirit, do give thee fivefold blazon (1.5.297-298).” Viola uses this to her advantage to convince the Duke to love her over Olivia. In the movie She’s the Man, Olivia is also in an emotional state but because she just got out of a break up and instantly falls for Sabastian for being different from most guys she’s used to. In the movie she loves that Sabastian is a lyricist, and will say anything to complement him which she awkwardly does with his usic, “Those are really good. So honest.” Olivia takes any advantage to either make Sabastian fall in love with her or make him jealous, which is comedic because she has no idea that its Viola. In the end of both the play and movie Olivia finds love with the real Sabastian, which allows Duke to finally realize that he loves …show more content…
In the Twelfth Night he’s a handsome, rich Bachelor who is very poetic and is honestly just in love with love. His first line in the play shows how he feels about love, “If music be the food of love, play on; Give me excess of it, that, surfeiting (1.1.1) His passion for love echoes to Voila and she begins to fall in love with him, which doesn’t work in her favor because he thinks she’s a man. He is head over heels in love with Olivia which bring him and Viola closer in the attempts that Viola might help Olivia fall in love with him. This leaves Viola caught in the middle of a love triangle, but not in the way she would like. Gacefully she helps Olivia with the grieving of her father and brother and shows Orisno what love is really like, not the fantasy’s that he developed in this head about Olivia. In She’s the Man, Viola has just gotten out of a bad relationship and isn’t looking for a new one. Viola realizes that Duke isn’t just all about his looks, he’s actually a really insecure, shy guy and she starts to fall in love with him. The problem, like the play, is that he thinks he’s in love with Olivia. Viola almost breaking the Sabastian character gives Duke some interesting advice, “[to Duke] What does you heart tell you? [pause] I mean... which one would you rather see NAKED!?” Viola keeps her focus in the movie, she’s dedicated to winning the soccer game but once Olivia starts pretending that she likes

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Love is an unyielding force that eventually humbles us all. In his comedies, William Shakespeare attempts to define this elusive entity in the play Twelfth Night . The Twelfth Night is a romantic comedy about a girl named Viola who has to disguise herself as a man for protection after a shipwreck where she thought she lost her brother. As the play continues Viola develops feelings for the man she works for Orsino although he is a lovesick fool for Olivia who doesn’t want a relationship because she is still mourning over her brother. Orsino asks for Viola’s help to get Olivia to choose him.…

    • 1224 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Orsino even listens to romantic music as the quote implies and enjoys the bittersweet emotions it casts about him. Thus he is not truely in love with Olivia, he is in love with love itself. At the end of the play, Orsino once again reitterates that his love is not actually true. Upon the realization that the main character, Viola, is actually a woman, he says, “Give me thy hand, and let me see thee in thy woman’s weeds.” (5.1.290-291). As soons as he realizes Cesario is actually a female, he completely forgets about his infatuation with Olivia and throws himself at Viola’s feet.…

    • 1761 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Twelfth Night is a comedic play in which humour is seen through the foolishness of love demonstrated by the characters: Olivia, Antonio, and Sebastian. Olivia, the beautiful and noble lady of Illyria, demonstrates the silliness of love when she marries Sebastian, a man she has just met minutes ago, which results in her own humorous mood swings. It seems normal for Olivia to marry Sebastian when she has mistaken…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Then when the twins find each other again they find themselves in a misunderstood situation. Romantic comedies are based on happiness with a little bit of tragedy added, but Twelfth Night is based on tragedy with some happiness added. Firstly, Shakespeare makes unrequited love a tragic sadness. Orsino is so depressed and desperate for the love of Olivia he will do anything to get over his love for her. This unrequited love differs from other romantic comedies because the characters are not usually this depressed or desperate.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Romeo is saying that he is in love with Juliet and he wishes her to know how much he loves her. This quote implies that after Romeo meets Juliet in the Capulet 's party, he forgets all about Rosaline and now he is in love with Juliet. In other words, Romeo does not take the love with Rosaline seriously at all as he falls in love with another woman instantaneously. Romeo 's falling in love with Juliet is his first impulsive action which has great influence over his death later in the play. Therefore, Romeo falling in love with Juliet expeditiously is the starting action which later affects him to…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “The act of love is largely the art of persistence,” said Albert Ellis. This concept could be brought into Shakespeare’s comedy, Twelfth Night, where the character Orsino was madly in love with the character Olivia; however, after learning that Olivia had already married Sebastian, Orsino transfers his love to Sebastian's sister, Viola, and marries her. Very similarly, although Olivia was in love with Cesario (Viola) she also then transfers her love to Sebastian after she had realized that she had married Sebastian instead of Cesario. The play does not end with a real komos moment for both Olivia and Orsino does not truly love their newlywed partner. Olivia demonstrates her deficient love due to her imperfected personality towards Sebastian…

    • 878 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    She manipulated him by leading him on throughout their relationship to benefit herself. Brett’s reaction towards Cohn’s desperation reveals how little she actually cared for him and her true motives behind their relationship. Similarly, as Gatsby pleads for Daisy’s love, she decides she loves both Tom and Gatsby at the same time. Nick narrates that Daisy was denying everything and defending both of her lovers. She, however, desperate for wealth, sacrifices her love and stays with Tom.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Spontaneity is part of love's irrationality. The marriages happen suddenly without regret. Love is uncontrollable, which is seen vastly throughout the play. Olivia falls for Viola even though she swears to only mourn her brother. The characters can’t control their love, which makes the play so…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Twelfth Night is a romantic comedy was expressed through gender, love, social ambition, and sex. Comedy is displayed in the play when the characters are drunk and almost about to pass out. They always manage to surprise us with their witty speech. In Northrop Frye’s essay of comedy, love was stopped by their fathers, but in Twelfth Night love was stopped by one person not having the same affection by their fathers. Their love faced many obstacles, but at the end they lived…

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thesis: Through the symbolism of the twins Viola and Sebastian in Shakespeare’s 12th Night, love can be seen as an unyielding force and can be found in unintentional and mysterious ways. Body Paragraph #1: Viola falls in love with Orsino, after he talks about her qualities, or being similar to a woman, of course, unknowingly that she actually is a woman. P #1: Viola masquerades as a man with the name of Cesario in order to make something of herself. She goes to work for the Duke Orsino, who is hopelessly in love with Olivia. Orsino confides in Viola, saying how “he” knows women.…

    • 1136 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays

Related Topics