Compare Twelfth Night And She's The Man

Superior Essays
Twelfth Night and She’s the Man
Many people struggle in discovering who they truly are in certain situations. Some struggle with career choices, relationships, religion, and so many other things that life throws at you. The Twelfth Night by William Shakespeare is a comedic play about identity, true and false love, and adaption to new situations. This is also found in the movie based of the play called She’s the Man. In both versions a young woman named Viola makes a choice that effects many of the people around her. Even though her situation is slightly different in both film and play, it’s the choice she makes to hide her identity that brings her into many interesting, and challenging situations of making people fall in and out of love.
The
…show more content…
In the play Olivia has just lost both her father and brother, which leaves her extremely depressed and not wanting to be with anyone. Meeting Viola, or in this case Cesario, she falls deeply in love with the character. This causes issues for Viola because the comedic love triangle is formed with her right in the middle, because Orisno wants Viola to help Olivia marry him. Olivia finds Viola very compelling and attractive, she literally loves everything about him and declares it, “Thy tongue, thy face, thy limbs, actions and spirit, do give thee fivefold blazon (1.5.297-298).” Viola uses this to her advantage to convince the Duke to love her over Olivia. In the movie She’s the Man, Olivia is also in an emotional state but because she just got out of a break up and instantly falls for Sabastian for being different from most guys she’s used to. In the movie she loves that Sabastian is a lyricist, and will say anything to complement him which she awkwardly does with his usic, “Those are really good. So honest.” Olivia takes any advantage to either make Sabastian fall in love with her or make him jealous, which is comedic because she has no idea that its Viola. In the end of both the play and movie Olivia finds love with the real Sabastian, which allows Duke to finally realize that he loves …show more content…
In the Twelfth Night he’s a handsome, rich Bachelor who is very poetic and is honestly just in love with love. His first line in the play shows how he feels about love, “If music be the food of love, play on; Give me excess of it, that, surfeiting (1.1.1) His passion for love echoes to Voila and she begins to fall in love with him, which doesn’t work in her favor because he thinks she’s a man. He is head over heels in love with Olivia which bring him and Viola closer in the attempts that Viola might help Olivia fall in love with him. This leaves Viola caught in the middle of a love triangle, but not in the way she would like. Gacefully she helps Olivia with the grieving of her father and brother and shows Orisno what love is really like, not the fantasy’s that he developed in this head about Olivia. In She’s the Man, Viola has just gotten out of a bad relationship and isn’t looking for a new one. Viola realizes that Duke isn’t just all about his looks, he’s actually a really insecure, shy guy and she starts to fall in love with him. The problem, like the play, is that he thinks he’s in love with Olivia. Viola almost breaking the Sabastian character gives Duke some interesting advice, “[to Duke] What does you heart tell you? [pause] I mean... which one would you rather see NAKED!?” Viola keeps her focus in the movie, she’s dedicated to winning the soccer game but once Olivia starts pretending that she likes

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Viola wants to help Olivia since she has lost her brother as well, or so she thinks, and knows what Olivia is going through. The captain explains Olivia 's situation as a woman who has no man by her side Olivia then replies “O that I served that lady,”(43). Viola wants to serve Olivia to get close enough to aid in Olivia 's’ well-being. Viola (STM) wants to prove that women are equal to men when she dresses as her brother and joins the boys soccer team. The message she tries to send is that there should be equality in the way people treat both sexes because both men and women can act like each other and deserve to be accepted as such.…

    • 1185 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Olivia In Twelfth Night

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages

    She is in need of protecting herself in Illyria and thus disguises herself as a man. Viola also went with her better judgement and stayed a man until it was the right time to reveal her true identity. Viola dressing up as a man and fooling everybody into thinking so really brings out the point that what you see is not always the…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    He depicts homosexual love in Twelfth Night as the strongest and truest love, by comparing it to the fleeting love based on beauty that Orsino feels for Olivia and Olivia feels for Olivia’s brother Sebastian. In doing so, Shakespeare attacks popular beliefs against homosexuality at that time. A paradigm of such love occurs between Antonio, a sailor, and Viola’s brother, Sebastian. Antonio rescued Sebastian from the shipwreck and, while he was nursing him back to good health, fell deeply in love with him. Antonio confesses his love after bravely following Sebastian to Orsino’s court, despite having many enemies there.…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Twelfth Night’s main theme is about entertainment and love, which is only an underlying theme in She’s the Man. She’s the Man focuses more on trying to break gender roles, by showing Viola as a female soccer player who is good enough to be on the boys team when she is disguised as her brother and Duke, a sensitive jock. However, by trying to stick to the theme of entertainment as seen in the play, the movie enhanced some stereotypes about both genders. In order for women to be taken seriously in the world, they have to act as a man would and cannot have the emotions a woman would. Viola portrays this when she is disguised as her brother and only refers to women in degrading ways so that her friends will think of her as more of a man.…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Finally, the disguises and cross dressings are for different purposes. Here are the many differences I found in the play and the movie. Firstly, the characters in She’s the Man and Twelfth Night are very different. In She's the Man, Viola is portrayed as more aggressive while in Twelfth Night, she is carefree being a servant.…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In consideration of Viola portraying herself as a man named Cesario, her role-playing is very complex and requires more from her than what might be perceived. In Viola’s case, she has to maneuver being able to talk to Olivia knowing that she is the competition for Orsino’s love, as well as being able to present herself to the person she loves as a man who does not have any attraction other than that of a servant. For Viola’s manipulation of the other character’s in the play to be successful, she must be able to follow some of the same patterns as Feste, including noting the mood of Orsino or Viola, his or her type of character, and the setting that takes place when Viola performs her role as Cesario. Ultimately, Viola’s plan to end up happily with Orsino relies heavily on…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this play, Orsino originally plans to marry Olivia. Unfortunately, Olivia loves Cesario and Cesario loves Orsino. While Cesario spends a majority of her time working in Orsino’s court, she gains a noble amount of respect in a quick three months. When Sebastian unexpectedly makes his appearance in the final scene of the play, the truth behind Cesario’s identity is revealed. Orsino understands that Cesario is actually a woman, Viola, and is now able to have a relationship with her.…

    • 857 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Olivia, the beautiful and noble lady of Illyria, demonstrates the silliness of love when she marries Sebastian, a man she has just met minutes ago, which results in her own humorous mood swings. It seems normal for Olivia to marry Sebastian when she has mistaken…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    (Twelfth Night Act I.V). Olivia was unaware, but taking that first, with such a simple action as presenting her face, the gears of love had began to turn. Proof of this new love is how she had gone against her own wishes. Refusing the advances of men of any sort, which included any man seeing her face, just capitalized on the fact of Olivia beginning to fall for Viola. The irony in the whole situation is quite humorous.…

    • 1936 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Olivia Twelfth Night

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night, Olivia, a noble woman in the land of Illyria, is sought after for marriage by more people than any other character in the play. Even with multiple choices for a husband, she still ends up dissatisfied with love. Some of these men who seek her hand in marriage range from servant to nobles just like her, but not one of them can satisfy her. Even though love is one of the most central themes in the play, Olivia still cannot find a two way relationship. She can attract many people very easily but does not respond well to many of them.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In lines 35-38, Sebastian explains how his mannerisms are very similar to his own mother’s, and describes himself as full of kindness while using the word “bosom”. He features himself as a gentle and beautiful individual. Without indication of which character is which in Twelfth Night, Viola and Sebastian could be mistaken for each other easily to a reader who is unfamiliar with whose dialogue belongs to…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the play, one of the main themes is unrequited love. This always means that some would end up being unhappy as the person they love does not love them back. We see this between Sir Andrew and Olivia. Sir Andrew loves Olivia, ‘here comes the countess, heaven walks on earth’. However, Olivia does not love Sir Andrew as she loves Cesario.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Twelfth Night is a story that is written by William Shakespeare. Love is a major topic in the Twelfth Night because many major characters in the story fall in love with each other. In the story, the nature of love does not follow the guidelines of social class. Even though love does not follow these guidelines, the characters in the story still realize what social class they are associated in and it sometimes stops them from seeking out certain characters. There are a few love connections that do defy their social classes.…

    • 1342 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Disguise In Twelfth Night Analysis

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 1 Works Cited

    As Viola cannot show her love for Orsino, the only way she can express them is in her soliloquies to the audience, this contributes to the dramatic ironies. I believe dramatic irony certainly adds to the magic of Twelfth Night. The disguise also causes mistaken identity, an example of this is when Sir Andrew goes looking for Cesario, finds who he thinks is Cesario, strikes him, the person however is, Sebastian. Sebastian hits him in return, but sevenfold, and Sebastian having been in Illyria only a few days is proposed to by a beautiful lady and is hit by a man he had never seen before, "are all the people mad" Sebastian says. This is an extremely funny series of events started by the disguise of one single woman.…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    • 1 Works Cited
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cesario created a lot of stirs in multiple characters throughout the play. She/he put challenged Orison’s and Olivia’s of what they think is true romantic love for other people. Viola is the only one among the love triangle who actually gets to talk to the person she feels she loves. Viola has seen Orsario for what he truly is. She’s seen him depressed, angry, and filled with joy all having to do with Olivia and yet Viola still finds herself in love with him.…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics