The Political Structures Of Rome And Carthage

Improved Essays
Introduction
During the 3rd century B.C., two powers arose in the Western Mediterranean, Rome and Carthage, whose epic struggle for dominance of the region would reshape the ancient world (Morey, 1901). Rome would emerge the victor and subsequently, numerous modern governments owe Rome for the basis of their laws and organization of their systems (Noonan, n.d.). However, if Carthage had emerged the victor and our world governments had looked to Carthage for inspiration, would they be structured differently than they are today? In my learning journal entry for this unit I will briefly discuss how the governments of Carthage and Rome were structured, how they were similar and how they differed.
Discussion
Rome and Carthage, though they were bitter enemies and rivals, their political structures were remarkably parallel (Morey, 1901). Upon further review this was not unusual for the region circa 3rd century B.C. as there was a general trend in numerous states away from the monarchal system and towards that of a representative republic (Nepos & Mulligan, 2015).
However, both cities maintained a monarchal system for part of their governmental structure (Morey, 1901).
…show more content…
The Roman senate was the consultative division of government composed of ex-consuls and magistrates who served for life (Gil, 2014; Gil, 2015). Though they were officially an advisory body, they wielded vast power via their jurisdiction over the government’s finances and by the fact that all laws voted on by the other representative body, the Assembly, were first debated and considered in the senate (Encyclopedia Britannica, 2015; McManus, 2015). The Carthaginian equivalent were the Adirim or Council of Elders whose delegated powers and responsibilities were similar to the Roman senate as they advised the Suffetes in all matters (Khalaf, 2016; Morey,

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Carthaginian 's two chief magistrates, aka the Suffetes, would compare to the Consuls of the Roman government. Although Carthage and Rome had some similarities in their political system, they were different. THE CARTHAGINIAN GOVERNMENT INSTITUTION The Two Suffetes The early Carthage was under kingship, however, it was diminished during the development of the political evolution of Rome. The Carthaginian citizens met at the Popular Assembly, where they voted on policy and their government officials. In the Assembly, the citizens enjoyed the freedom of speech when voting on…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Punic War 1 vs. Punic War 2 The Punic Wars were an important part of Roman History starting in 264 BCE (Duiker). The Romans and taken over what they wanted in Italy and were on a quest to conquer the entire Mediterranean area. There were Three Punic Wars and they were between Rome and Carthage. Carthage was the location where the Phoenicians settled in 800 BCE (Duiker). The reason for the Punic Wars was the land of Sicily.…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The story of Rome begins with not Rome but the parent nation of Rome, the Etruscan kingdom. The Etruscans were in central western Italy and became a leading power in Italy in the 6th century who conquered territory down the western coast of Italy and eventually expanded up the Po river to the north. It is also notable that the Etruscans entered into conflict with the Greeks and allied with Carthage Rome 's future rival. The Etruscans kingdom did decline as the Celts began invading and settling along the Po river, this allowed a rebellion in the south of the kingdom to be successful, the rebellion of the Latin League. The Latin League centered at where the river Tiber met the Mediterranean sea, and they were a loose confederation of cities…

    • 1120 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cicero argues that the instituttions of the Roman state had been effectively torn asunder by the new party which under the Gracchi and later under other populist leaders aimed to divide Rome in two parts. Cicero claimed that after the death of Tiberius Gracchus there were “two senates in one republic and two separate people. This was clearly a departure from how things had always been done in Rome which had for the longest time a tradition of being a republic which valued working together in order to establish a well-functioning state it must have a principle of government, be it a monarchy, an aristocracy or a democracy. Cicero, using Scipio’s voice in this dialogue argues that the best government is in fact “mixed and moderated government, which is composed of the three particular forms I have before noticed.” The three kinds of government aforementioned by Cicero all have a particular attraction and are at the same point an important part of building a well functioning government. The Roman Constitution is one great example of how a mixed government can be the best way of assuring that it assures the liberty of all and the strength of the…

    • 1932 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The three main branches were the consuls/magistrates, senate, and the assembly. The Romans had two consuls who served for one year, and were elected by the assemblies. The assembly of centuries could elect magistrates. Magistrates had supreme administrative authority, which meant they could interpret and execute the laws. While in the U.S. the legislative branch passes the laws, and the executive branch can veto it.…

    • 929 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The purpose of this paper is to compare political, social, economic, cultural and military similarities and differences between the Greek and the Roman Empires. Early structure and geographical effect on politics Both Greece and Rome were had an established city-state model. However, the immensely different topographies of Greece and Rome influenced their political development. Greece is a mountainous land with many islands which did not allow for easy travel which meant that an interaction between the Greek city-states was very restricted. As a result, many of the Greek city-states to developed independently of one another.…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This were call Quadrireme so for some time Carthage is most powerful power at sea because of Quadrireme, but When Rome found an abandon Quadrireme they quickly went to work, were they copy the ship in order to fight Carthage in the Punic war’s. During March 10 241 B.C. Rome and Carthage went to war at sea with equal amount on weapons technology, there the Roman Navy Won the battle and that Won the First Punic war and made Rome number one Naval in fighting. (. (Mark Cannon , 6 Nov 2006, Engineering an Empire: Carthage.…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sqr In Ancient Rome

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Rome wanted to control hostile neighbors, wanted more resources, The Roman expansion occurred in 3 stages. The first stage occurred when Rome decided to conquer Italy, (Spielvogel, 5.2). Rome then had a conflict with Carthage and expanded into the western Mediterranean Sea. The last stage occurred when the Romans took over Hellenistic kingdoms in the eastern Mediterranean. Under Emperor Claudius, Romans conquered most of the island of Britain.…

    • 797 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction Rome and Carthage were two great rivals of the west that were almost equal in strength and resources. Rome government was mostly a mixture of democracy and republic with most of it features resembling that of ancient Greeks. On the other hand, Carthage had some similarities in her governing body as Rome when she entered conflict with Rome. In this paper, I will try to discuss the government of Rome, Carthage and how they differed, then end with a conclusion stating my view on the two governments. Government of Rome According to Unrv.com(2015), before the beginning of the first century B.C, the Roman state was designated as a republic with two consuls, or chief magistrates who were always appointed and continued even after the formation…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Written Assignment HIST 1421 Unit 5: Greek and Roman Civilization Carthage and Rome and the Punic Wars University of the People Term 5, 2016 - 2017 Instructor: B. Chambers Abstract: The essay seeks to unpack the rivalry between Carthage and Rome which played out in the epic Punic Wars of 264BC, 218BC and 149BC. For over 100 years, the mighty Roman empire and army were occupied with keeping the equally mighty armies of Carthage at bay and ensuring that their reach never extended too far or too close to Rome. Introduction: Carthage, the “other” great foreign power in the time of the Roman quests for power and influence was known as the “great commercial power” in Africa. (Morey, n.d.) Much like Rome, Carthage gained its power by conquering neighboring lands and…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays