Comparison Of Descartes Views Of Mind And Body

Good Essays
COURSE -PERSPECTIVES OF KNOWLEDGE NAME - DIVYANSHU SHARMA ROLL NUMBER – 2013034
JOURNAL ON THE MIND BODY PROBLEM EMPHASISING ON DESCARTES

Descartes believed that a person or human being such as you or me is a two-part composite, of a mind and a body or to put it simple a person is just the mind but has a body. And according to him, the mind is an entirely immaterial, nonphysical thing or simply a collection of information. What unites the mind with our body is that it causally interacts with the body.
Descartes’ main arguments were these: One can doubt that their body or any other physical thing exists, One cannot doubt that their mind exists,The mind is distinct from the body.
In this journal I will be focussing on the third
…show more content…
Since new information is continuously being created by the universe, by rearranging existing matter, this is an important difference. Going back to physics; Matter and energy is conserved i.e they can neither be created nor destroyed or simply they’re a constant of the universe. Information is not conserved, we can grow our knowledge and that basically is improving our information base.
Now relating the mind body dualism with other great philosophers, I find that it coincides with Plato’s ideas that exist as pure form, although its ontology is different from that of matter. The existential status of Platonic Ideas was questioned and asked about by the ancients. On the other hand, monists see the mind-body distinction as a pure physical aspect, since the information in matter somewhat corresponds to a reorganization of the matter and we can call it sort of a subset. This was Aristotle's more practical view. For him, Plato's Ideas were just abstractions generalized from many existent
…show more content…
For Descartes, the body is a system of tiny fibres causing mechanical movements in the brain, which then in reaction to the stimuli pull on other fibres to activate the muscles or nerve impulses. This is essentially the basis of stimulus and response theory in modern physiology.
Descartes was of the belief that humans are the only dualistic creature. He placed animals in purely physical, mechanistic world, acting purely on the laws of nature.
Descartes doubted all that could be doubted in the hope of arriving at an undeniable truth. And hence was led to - I think, therefore I am. Descartes could doubt the existence of the physical world and that even his own body actually existed, but he could not doubt the idea that his mind existed because doubting is a thought process. The very act of doubting one's existence proves that one actually exists; otherwise, who is doing the doubting?
Through this process of doubting, Descartes realized that, regardless of what the physical world was really like, the mind was still whole and unchanged, and therefore separate from the physical world.
I believe that the Mind is a collection of thoughts and knowledge and it is connected to the

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    First, there are also some similarities between Zeno and the Platonists and Peripatetics. Platonists admit that being is a body, and the corporeality of the soul. Moreover, Peripatetics acknowledge that soul is the principle of life in the organic body, and is inseparable from the body. Plus, Peripatetics attack on Plato and rejected the abstractness of the form, which could be also means that the form is incorporeal. This shows that in some part, the Peripatetics admit the corporeality of the form.…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Physicalism says that ones mind or consciousness is no different from the physical system of the brain. Nagel explains, what limits us are our inability to understand what functions in the brain create the mind or consciousness.…

    • 2026 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Descartes Cognitive Body

    • 1556 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In a sweeping skeptical move, he rejected his standing beliefs and attempted to find unquestionable truths through reason. Perhaps influenced by Augustine, he arrived at “I think therefore, I am,” which he saw as establishing him as a thinking entity with a mind. He further concluded that his perceived interactions with the physical world implied a body. Descartes considered the mind to distinct from the body, not subject to death, or material qualities, for him, it was an unextended substance-less entity, possessed only by humans. The body, however, had substance and extension, it was restrained and functioned by virtue of mechanical principles.…

    • 1556 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Philosophy sheds light on many themes, one of the issues philosophy contends is the understanding how mind and body are related. Rene Descartes, a father of philosophical ideology devised “The Argument from Introspection” to attempt to answer such question. The argument from introspection explains that the mind and body are two entirely separate states and therefore cannot be identical to one another. Descartes’ rationale behind the argument is that the body is separable because it can be physically transformed such as being split in half. The mind however is indivisible because in accordance to his stance, it is not a physical property.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    So sometimes the mind can get it wrong if the body misfeeds it wrong information because it depends upon the body. The third issue is the category mistake. Rene Descartes makes the category mistake when he believed that the mind was a “thing” that held a singular value. Rene Descartes tried to look for a singular thing that would explain all mental capacities but it is actually a series of mechanical functions that make up the mind. Property Dualism realizes that the mind is an abstract concept that is created by the biological functions of the body.…

    • 2025 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The fact that we define the human body as having legs, arms, flesh, bones, organs, and a head is more than enough to agree that each of these, and more, are parts of what make up the body. We could even say that when a part of the body is separated, the body still remains a body for the fact that only a part of it was taken away. In fact in “The Philosophers Way”, Descartes’ ideas around a “non-material, immortal, conscious being” (Chaffee) is an ideal that set a precedent for philosophers to come. It is actually here that he ultimately found that this defines knowledge and self. “Cogito, ergo sum” or “I think, therefore I am” is a statement that defines Descartes’ views around the being self-aware and shining light around the fact that there is without a doubt a thinking, nonphysical entity that is the mind or consciousness.…

    • 1109 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The other is the problem of other minds- the objection to Dualism based on the undesired conclusion that if all we can be sure of is our own bodies, we can never know for certain that others even really exist. Dualism still struggles with this. However, Behaviorism dissolves this problem because again, in virtue of its physicalist foundation, it implicitly assumes a consistency among other humans that Substance dualism doubted. Because of this, minds are physically the same and only experientially different and so can be assumed to operate similarly to one another. Because of the physicalism of Behaviorism, it is able to dissolve two long existing problems of…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Concept Of Dualism

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In some ways influenced by Ludwig Wittgenstein, who thought many philosophical problems were caused by misuse of language, Ryle said the category mistake was applying properties to a non-material thing that are logically and grammatically appropriate only for a category including material things. (7) The theory of logical behaviorism maintains, as Place said, that “consciousness is a brain process” (16) or maybe more notably in the words of Ryle, the mind is “a ghost in the machine.” (17) The "ghost" factor likely comprises an individual’s internal, private thoughts that transpire in the spirit-mind. The only one to have access of those thoughts are the individual himself, and strangers cannot enter into mind 's hidden capacities. The "machine" factor comprises the physical body, which is publicly visible and strangers can certainly examine. Descartes ' error, according to Ryle, was the assumption that the human mind is private – entirely hidden from outer…

    • 1080 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    His logic is reporting that the crocophant does not exist by virtue that a person is not born with the idea of it, but the person has the idea of a supreme entity from the start of his life. This blemishes his logic because it is not necessarily true every person believed in God in his times, just like not everyone believes today. This would be assuming infants are born with an image of a divine being, but those who do not believe lose this image because how else would it explain why some people do not believe. Also, he presumes only one God exists, yet other cultures believe in multiple Gods, and they do not view their Gods as perfect. For example, the Greeks were a polytheistic culture, and the myths about their Gods did not always portray them in the best light and highlight them as blameless.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    He didn’t believe that humans had a soul or mind that’s distinct from its body. Hobbes would probably conclude that this replicants are humans too because of the mechanical similarities we both have in reasoning and physical function. A philosopher who would disagree…

    • 1809 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays