Strict Vegan Diet

Improved Essays
Ben Kim, in “A Strict Vegetarian Diet is Unhealthy for Most People” discusses why a strict vegan diet is not a healthy diet for humans in the long run, which is the main claim in the article. Though the article has many opinions in it, the article has a very factual claim that is backed up by evidence, explaining the negative impacts of a strict vegan diet.

The author provided factual sub-claims as well as sub-claims of value. The sub-points relate to the main point in that they tell about the health risks of a strict vegan diet and the confusion that can be placed upon the pro-vegan organizations. The main points are that the health of people can be negatively impacted by strict vegan diets, organizations that promote strict, vegan diets
…show more content…
People go on these diets to be healthy, eating only plant-based foods, but they are depriving their bodies of the other food groups they need to consume. The author discusses how a person’s body can be deceived in the beginning of their diet because they feel better, but the person then has high risks of having health problems in the long run.

The sub-point about the pro-vegan organizations provides factual evidence along with evidence of value in that the author talks about what the organizations are doing right and wrong. The organizations that support vegan diets only give out the information that supports their cause. Most of the time, the organizations do not discuss how much they are profiting from people going on this diet, and leave out the long term health risks that can result from the diet that they are promoting. They make themselves sound by wanting to save the animals when they are hurting the humans in the
…show more content…
This author uses warrants in his article such as admitting he is human, and respecting the beliefs and health of others. The audience would accept the author’s support for fact because his words are sympathetic toward animals, but also concerned for human health. The author’s tone is warm and opening, and the author is not arrogant about what he is claiming. He does not ask the audience to just believe him, but to research and examine their health for themselves. We do not really see any problems with the author’s warrants. The author uses his tone and respect for others beliefs to gain the trust and respect of the audience. We did not see anything except for the lack of factual evidence that the author needed to change.

We only found a few problems in the source overall. The author was writing about the negative impact that a strict vegan diet can have on a person’s health, but he also included the reasons that a person becomes a vegan, which really were not that relevant to the main claim. The author also uses a lot of opinionated statements instead of providing more factual evidence and statistics. The author overall had a good article with a minimum number of

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Research Paper On Veganism

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Veganism is the lifestyle of “health and purity”, or so it is raved to be. But once one takes the strict way of life too far the situation becomes all too dangerous. Over obsessiveness within the diet from recovering patients allows for disorders to be maintained or perhaps, become even worse. Veganism is a variety of vegetarian diet that eliminates meat, eggs, dairy foodstuffs and all additional animal-derived ingredients. Many vegans as well do not eat foods that are processed using animal products, for instance refined white sugar in addition to some wines (vegetarian).…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Truth About A Strict Vegetarian Diet Proper nutrition has been debated and adapted from viewpoints of vegetarianism compared to the consumption of animal products. In "A Strict Vegetarian Diet Is Unhealthy for Most People"(Kim), Ben Kim discuses the negative effects and alternate motives behind an all vegetarian diet. By providing a alternate view of a strict vegetarian diet, Kim advocates for a diet based on personal needs. Although many people see immediate health advantages to having a strict vegetarian diet over time the body cannot compensate the loss of key nutrients only gained from animal biased products. Kim supports this point by stating "A long term, strict vegan diet is likely to lead to the development of nutritional deficiencies…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Why Is Veganism Wrong

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The vegan diet originated from spiritual values, differing than the reasons of present day people. When people make the change from eating meat to eating plants, some diet plans can become insubstantial for nutrient intake. Nutrients like proteins and vitamins convert to energy, but if the body contains less than average values of nutrients, it will produce less energy. Having less energy throughout the day is bad for the body. Some parents of children and pets convert to Veganism, but if their vegan diet pushes onto their loved ones, they can suffer from malnourishment and expensive medical bills in life.…

    • 1664 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Some examples of dieting may include a plant-based diet and fad diets. Individuals continuously strive to take part in the trend of dieting due to the positive results that follow; however, they do not recognize the negative impacts of each diet. There are many challenges that follow each specific diet. For example, the challenges of a vegetarian diet are to have enough protein and vitamin B in one 's diet as well as to not consume a multitude of processed food, carbs and sugars (Anisman-Reiner). '"The most dramatic change to the diet is being vegan rather than the raw element, because you are cutting out two huge food groups.…

    • 1465 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Do you love animals? Do you want to be healthy? If your answer to either of these questions is a solid “yes”, the vegan diet may be for you. Today, veganism is one of the most controversial and talked-about lifestyles. The vegan diet is different from a vegetarian diet because in addition to meat, it also excludes all animal byproducts including eggs, dairy, and, honey.…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As I disagree with Pollen but not all the way as he has stated the problem but honestly, it’s all up to the person to escape from the western diet. Thus, in the article “Escape from the Western Diet” by Michael Pollan, states the diet the westerners are using is that of an unhealthy one. Then to further provide it by saying it causes a health problem. There’s also the food industry and the methods they use to sell their products. As well as the theory nutritionism which is used to increase nutritional value of food, but never less it still doesn’t change a thing about whole food.…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Veganism is more than just a diet, avoiding all animal products proves a point, that it is morally wrong to use an animal for its flesh and byproducts. In the long run, the slaughtering of animals hurts the environment and does not benefit one's health. Vegetarians consider animal products to a certain degree. A vegetarian diet is not mainly based on the aspect of protecting animals, but most likely for their health issues or religious beliefs. Because the consumption of meats is greatly linked to obesity, cancer, diabetes, and other major health issues.…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Vegan Lifestyle Essay

    • 1736 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Is becoming vegan actually the best lifestyle or diet? Vegans do not eat or use any animal products. They don't eat any meat or animal products, like milk, eggs and other animal products. They think doing this will help save the environment and help stop the cruelty for animals. Vegans also may think weight loss will be automatic or will make a person healthier, but that is not the case.…

    • 1736 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Is a vegan diet really the healthiest way to eat? There is a lot of vegan controversy going around. There is a multitude of vegans claiming that eating vegan is ultimately healthier than a non-vegan diet in every way. Though in some cases this could be true, there are many downsides and overlooked aspects to a vegan diet. A vegan diet is not necessarily healthier because of possible deficiencies, unhealthy vegan lifestyle, and inconsistent data.…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dieting and health are currently in the spotlight due to the rising weight problems society is experiencing today. The often overlooked alternative of vegetarianism is beginning to transform into a popular option- but is it the correct option? The controversial topic of vegetarianism is undergoing extensive research and studies, as more experiments are conducted. While reading my paper, I ask for an open mind as I investigate nutrition, health disease, and overall life for non vegetarians and vegetarians only, not including vegans. A commonly used argument against vegetarianism includes the lack of proper nutrition.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics