An Analysis Of Against Meat By Jonathan Safran Foer

Improved Essays
Humans are omnivores, which means that they eat both plants and animals. Ultimately, the human can decide whether or not they are going to consume animal meat. I am analyzing the article “Against Meat” in the They Say I say collection of articles. Jonathan Safran Foer talks about his experiences with his struggles of becoming a vegetarian. He gives the intended audience and inside look on how making dietary choices are often difficult, and how it has positively impacted his life, as well as keeping his morals and values in check. I found this interesting because Foer and I both share some of the same views on the food industry and what we choose to put in our bodies. Humans are very uneducated on the food industry, and should research different …show more content…
Foer uses pathos to create an emotional connection with his intended audience. The use of childhood experiences is what helps shapes his reasoning to why he became a vegetarian. There is a part where he asks his babysitter why she isn’t eating any chicken and she explains that she doesn’t want to hurt anything. He includes this in the article to create an emotional appeal to hurting animals, and how eating meat is considered hurting animals. This comment made by his babysitter didn’t permanently change his eating habits, but it’s what shaped his views on the omnivorous lifestyle. Foer uses his experiences as a young child to connect with his readers that may have had similar times in their lives. “Every factory-farmed animal is, as a practice, treated in ways that would we illegal if it was a dog or a cat.” (457) Foer uses this statement to tug the emotions of pet owners buy making them think about their furry friends being treated like farm animals. The author’s use of pathos is to get his argument across by making readers appeal to the emotion used in his past life …show more content…
This is called anecdote, which is the use of short stories to illustrate a point. The short story the author tells about his experience with his babysitter is an example of Anecdote. “You know chicken is chicken, right?” (Foer 451) The author makes sure to include this quote from the babysitter because it makes the intended audience think about what they are consuming, especially young children who do not have a lot of say in what they eat. The part where he talks about having a mouth of “hurt chickens” is quite comical. This validates that kids do not realize what they are eating. Foer touches briefly on how his family impacted his transition from meat eater to vegetarian. “To remember my values, I need to lose certain tastes and find other handles for the memories that they once helped me carry.” (Foer 456) The author inserted this into this article to explain that becoming a vegetarian is not going to be easy. This is also related to how Foer was unsuccessful with the vegetarian lifestyle in his early twenties. He used this part of the article to explain how switching your dietary values aren’t just physically hard but emotionally and mentally challenging. The use of short stories in Against Meat gives the intended audience a less informal insight on Foer’s experiences on the road to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Together Against Meat Jonathan Safran Foer’s essay “Against Meat” provides the reader with information on why he became a vegetarian after years of “being a vegetarian” but eating meat once in a while; the essay starts off with his childhood memories at his grandmother’s house and her obsession with food due to the lack of it in World War II. At the age of 9 Foer had a baby sitter who he states “did not want to hurt anything” (451); that means she wouldn’t eat chicken or any animal, which triggered Foer to try becoming a vegetarian. Following the anecdotal introduction Foer speaks of his grandmother as the “Greatest Chef” (450), not particularly for how it tasted, yet Foer knew that a chef would have more than one recipe (chicken with carrots)…

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Foer establishes ethos for his readers as he describes, in ugly detail, how many of the animals are treated and killed in order to go from cage to plate. He describes a video taken of workers in one factory farm, and such a story makes the reader wonder why these animals are treated so poorly. “ …videotape taken by undercover investigators showed some workers administering daily beatings, bludgeoning pregnant sows with a wrench, and ramming an iron pole a foot deep into mother pigs’ rectums and vaginas. These things… are merely perversion”(181-182). Foer describes how pigs are treated as well as how animals around the country such as cows, turkeys, chickens, and other animals are all treated horribly to emphasize that although he is just telling a story, in reality these injustices are repeatedly occurring.…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Alina Rae Alanis Ellie Francis English 1302 February 28, 2016 Analyzing Foers’ Eating Dog As a huge dog lover and frequent volunteer at the Humane society, I know first-hand how hard it is for people to adopt companion dogs especially after most of the dogs have lived almost a full life. Although our society would most likely disagree with eating their furry friends, Jonathan Foer, does have solutions as to why we ought to consider dogs as a meat source. In an excerpt from Eating Animals, “A Case for Eating Dogs”, Foer explains why it should be more socially acceptable to eat companion animals, just like any other farm animal, despite how we morally feel about the idea. Throughout, the excerpt Foer relies less on any real factual evidence and leans more to rhetorical listening and challenging the current beliefs society holds toward the expectations and customs of eating a dog.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Inside the Workings of Mr. Rogaum Theodore Dreiser’s “Butcher Rogaum’s Door” is a short story detailing the accounts of a protective father and his young daughter in New York’s rougher part of town. Butcher Rogaum is dissected emotionally at the climax of the story. The synopsis is that even the hardest candy shell of a person can be melted down or broken from heart- wrenching experiences that affect our closest loved ones through life lessons. The main character, Rogaum’s tough love in the end breaks him down more than he did his daughter. The author, Dreiser walks us through the inner workings by using character, setting and plot.…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To show the readers that he is truly concerned about the topic he is questioning them about and not just merely asking to get a response from the readers, he uses the phrase “I’m confused” (Wallace 774) very often. By stating that he is confused he allows himself to ask further questions about the readers morals without attacking them. Foer on the other hand shows no sincerity at all he is blatant with his sarcasm, and continues to use sarcastic tone to clearly show this. For example, his statement about eating dog instead of other animals continues further when he suggests dog meat supplies “would put even the most efficient grass-based farming to shame” (Foer 606). This comparison of a “farming” (Foer 606) system of dogs, known as a human companion, to a traditional farming system, mainly consisting of animals such as cows, shows his lack of sincerity because he doesn’t truly mean that people would eat dog instead of cow.…

    • 876 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Part A: The Omnivore’s Dilemma by Michael Pollan is how our food choices affect our health greatly. Pollan’s purpose for writing the book was simple- if nothing else, inform readers about what they are putting into their bodies and possibly change their eating habits entirely. The book was published in April of 2006 and healthy eating has been a debate for many many years. People have questioned if they should be vegan, vegetarian, etc.…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While during this time of WWII, many people lived in large city and not many people lived on a farm. While this story that Louis Bromfield is writing talks about how he moved to Ohio to start up his won farm. So, he tends to focus on the point about how the animals on his farm are more equals. In the sense of how they teach and having alternative way of getting in touch with animals. Due to the fact that majority of people live in the city he try’s to connect the people living in those city to get interested in animals.…

    • 153 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Changing human diet can be a controversial topic and to change this omnivore’s mind one needs to present facts as cold as a fresh cut of meat. Marjorie Lee Garretson’s “More Pros Than Cons in a Meat-Free Life” is an essay that tries to persuade the reader to a vegan lifestyle under the guise of vegetarianism using few cited sources and trying to make the reader feel bad about the way they currently eat. “More Pros Than Cons in a Meat-Free Life” is a college level essay written by Marjorie Lee Garretson about the potential positives to vegetarian lifestyle. The essay first focuses on the health benefits of switching to vegetarianism which is done in three sentences claiming decreased cancer rates and longer life expectancy without any…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article “Why All Humans Need to Eat Meat for Health,” written by bodybuilding enthusiast Kadya Araki, talks about the benefits of eating meat and how it contributes to human body growth. She argues that meat is necessary for physical and mental health, and thus shouldn’t be cut out of a person’s diet. Araki believes that humans need to eat meat to be healthy, and claims that a meatless diet can’t provide the necessary nutrients for muscle growth and good health; however, her argument used insufficient evidence for proving that we can’t live on a vegan diet, did not account for other factors that may have had an influence on people’s health, and dismissed one of the main reasons why people choose to be vegan. Before delving deep into the…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A simple pleasure in many people’s life is a triple whopper from Burger King. Vegetarians go through their entire life without experiencing the joys of beef, bacon, chicken and various other meats. Other’s who chose the vegan life, go through the pain of consuming no milk, eggs, or any other animal product. Many vegans believe they are doing the right thing and are morally superior to people who eat meat by living a vegan lifestyle. Gary Steiner, a vegan, decided to write an article about the evils of meat eaters.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Humor here thus disregards vegetarian philosophy causing the author to seem ignorant regarding the issue. Some may argue that her using this point was to prove that becoming vegetarian is not an automatic method towards weight loss and healthy eating in an entertaining way. This, however, is trivial when considering the numerous health issues regarding meat including higher risk of heart disease, higher blood pressure, and higher cholesterol levels. “One roasted bird unleashed fifteen years’ worth of cravings” (Fraser 549). Exaggeration can be a powerful tool as it enraptures the reader into feeling the powerful emotions the author is trying to…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Forks Over Knives Analysis

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This film offers the opposition of this topic virtually no time to give their side of the story. I believe that to have a successful argument, the audience should have the right to hear both sides of the story before they start making their own ideas. Connie Diekman, food expert, was only given a small opportunity to explain why eating animal meat is important. This film also does not offer any negatives that could come from switching diets. They fail to mention how prices of these organic food might make it impossible for certain families and students to make the switch.…

    • 1029 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Vegetarianism. Ed. Amy Francis. Farmington Hills, MI: Greenhaven Press, 2015. Current Controversies.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    By having nutritionists’, doctors and university professors all explain in detail how studies and examples show obvious benefits to be living by a plant-based diet. With examples from D. Anthony Evans an inspirational cancer survivor and healthy lifestyle enthusiast, who credits changing his diet to beating cancer and saving his life and Natalie McIntosh, founder of rawfooddorlife.org and a wellness advocate and speaker, who credits not eating land animals and only eating plant-based food with curing her depression. Using examples of people whose illness has been cured by eating a plant-based diet as well as athletes and nutritionist who provide multiple reasonable instances show the logic and reason to change one’s diet. The film represents…

    • 1477 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ethical Argument In Animal Welfare

    • 1672 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited

    Many show that a major issue in animal welfare should be solved by vegetarianism and not torture animals to get their meat. As Freeman argues, “animals used for food in the United States are commonly treated like unfeeling tools of production, rather than living, feeling animals,” (Freeman 170). Many feel the need to reduce meat because of animal cruelty, and not because of the welfare of the…

    • 1672 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 10 Works Cited
    Great Essays

Related Topics