Similarities Between Shed Mutiy And A Hole In Texas

In both of these novels “The Caine Mutiny” and “A Hole In Texas” written by Herman Wouk, have two main characters that share similar characteristics which they developed throughout their long and difficult journeys. “All growth depends upon activity. There is no development physically or intellectually without effort, and effort means work” (Coolidge). This quote is absolutely correct and relates really well to both of the characters which are Willie keith from “The Caine Mutiny” and Guy Carpenter from “A Hole In Texas” as they handle tough and difficult situations which lead to their development and by the end it benefits them and their families. The characters in both novels experience similar changes through their relationship with women, …show more content…
Willie started his life by heavily depending on his parents especially his mom to carry him through his life. “He was not paid much. The fee was, in fact, the smallest permitted by the musicians union for a piano player. Willie didn’t really care, so long as fifty dollar bills flowed from his mother.” (Wouk 30). Although, his mom told him not to play piano in clubs anymore he still did it as a part time job when he was off duty of the ship. However, this change really quickly when Willie steps in the navy life. He figures out that he will need to work hard and make his own decisions that will benefit his family and himself. This goes the same for Guy. As his journey goes along he realizes that there will be moments in his life where he will have to take decisions himself without the help of his wife. An old friend of Carpenter named Rossiter wants to kill him for being a traitor to the Americans and swears that he would kill him or go after his family so Carpenter decides to go face him even if it will cost his life. “ Well said! That's the policy. That's what I'll do. Just get out the garlic, and keep a crucifix handy. I'm off.” (Wouk 131). He says this to Myra and she thinks that it is a risky move but Guy Carpenter knows that his family matters to him and he needs to take this decision by himself. This shows both of the characters growth of independence throughout their journey. However, this also shows taking more responsibilities means taking more risks and being courageous. Willie also becomes more courageous by experiencing the war and and takes more responsibility to handle difficult situations. At the end they become fully independent and courageous by encountering tough situations throughout their