Humor In The Brothers Menaechmus

Decent Essays
This essay will discuss this particular definition of farce a broad, physical, visual comedy, whose effects are theatrical and intended solely to entertain and its pertinence to the play The Brothers Menaechmus. The numerous ways in which the text moves beyond simple farce to much deeper issues of Roman culture, satire and the art of theatre. All emphasising it’s various forms which move beyond farce and to a much more thoughtful work.

The sentiment that The Brother’s Menaechmus is a farce ignores the deeper messages of a text not only written to entertain but comment on the fibre of Roman society. We shall begin at the ending to make sense of this “Yes and if there’s any bidder for the thing-his wife will go” (130). This ‘happy’ conclusion
…show more content…
What is interpreted as madness is a purely social construct within Victorian times Homosexuality was inclusive of madness now such a view seems bizarre and such was the case in ancient Roman period. What constitutes madness is inevitably questioned within this scene. The Dionystic religious fervour “Bacchus! Yo-he, Bacchus, in what forest do you/ bid me hunt?” (113). He pretends to be overcome with and furthermore the imagining of Homeric intervention in the form of Apollo such ideals of madness are seen in myths of Peleus and Orpheus. These were traditionally women known as Bacchae but in this case take the form of a man. This depiction of the archetypal mad women simultaneously comments on society while contrastingly depicting a man within the same parameters of madness or what might be termed hysteria in a Freudian psychoanalytical framework this interplay between binary opposites stresses the complexity on the surface of what may appear to be a simple farce. Plautus humour never solely works on one level of comedy rather concurrently works on both a physical and mental, social level. Blending these two humours of physical and satire to varying degrees throughout the play. One example of this is “My master will reward his slave for 'thinking with his back '-and thinking twice” Messenio comments on the very quality of good and bad in his soliloquy on slavery which like many of the others speeches within the play reflects Roman ideals within the Greek setting of Epidamnus. Menaechmus comments on the patron client relationship of society depicting the hierarchical nature while also emphasising the mutual obligations of the dynamic. Comments on what real marriage or love is noted throughout a play saturated in social commentary in a play

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Is it Catullus' own irony coming to light here in the invocation of concordia, which will be all-too-absent from the marriage, or is it ironic prophecy on the part of the Parcae? It is hard to imagine the latter, given the triple reference we have already seen to their truth, and the refrain’s reminder that they are not just foretelling the events they sing of, but actively spinning them right then and there. Why go to such great lengths to highlight the truth of their song, only to have them present such a patent untruth? On the other hand, if the irony is Catullus' own gloss on the Parcae’s words, why has he abandoned the task of faithfully recording their veridicum oraclum?…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    While the majority of Bacon’s “Idols” that “beset” our minds and lead to error are present in Plautus’ play, Double Bind, the Idols of the theater is the most prevalent “Idol” with regards to how male characters both discuss and engage with female characters. The Idols of the theater are used as methods for understanding, which are dramatized (in that they are generalizations or stereotypes), unreal, and are made up or false, all of which ultimately lead to some form of error. Double Bind plays into the stereotypes of women as inherently less than men as they are considered idiotic and stupid, promiscuous, and crazy. This connects to the Idols of the theater because the male characters only see the predominant female characters, such as Dovey and Loveykins, in terms of generalizations or stereotypes of their gender. Male characters in Double Bind, such as Clueless One, Clueless Two, Antiquides, Smug, and Diddley not only discuss females as a generalized form of error, but they also engage with the females in a manner…

    • 1602 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hippolytus Myths

    • 1308 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Myth uses the medium of a story to describe the activities of the gods and larger than life humans, emphasising interpersonal relationships. These stories were neither singular nor static but evolved with different versions and were manipulated to highlight different values and ideologies. I agree with the statement and will argue that the myths of Hippolytus and the foundation myths of Roman were used by ancient societies to bind its members into a cohesive unit. This essay will explore the ways in which myth were used to bring members of an ancient society together by instigating and reinforcing civic identity and pride. Explore how the role of myths defined and unified the elite.…

    • 1308 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Introduction: Even though Shakespearean plays have existed for centuries, bringing forth both enjoyment for audiences and discussion for literary thinkers, and having been analysed, scrutinised and their very essence explored. This essay will attempt to create a vivid and fascinating exploration of Hamlet and the Taming of the Shrew, for emphasis the purpose of this essay is to traverse in the depiction of Shakespearean women. Chiefly the performance of these female characters on stage whilst using Judith Butler’s Queer theory as a basic theoretical framework. This essay will also attempt to address Shakespearean misogyny and answering the age old question of How far is Shakespeare's depiction of the female characters a result of Renaissance culture or his own personal beliefs.…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Judgment is a main theme in the play King Oedipus by Sophocles, and throughout the play, this theme comes up repeatedly. Sophocles might also be said to be using this idea of judgment to reflect upon the society, of Sophocles, and even that of the modern day reader. This paper will show the 3 elements of judgment that is illustrated by the play and the various angles Sophocles attempts to address using King Oedipus as the tool. The idea of judgment in the play is first portrayed as being a premature and faulty conclusion.…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Titus Andronicus is full of characters that are complex and confusing. These two passages however help decipher the two ways characters present themselves: as victims who cannot make sense of their situations or characters who present themselves as victims who have made sense of their situations. This is important because it shows how the characters control the tone of the play. Titus’ speech in act three creates a gloomy, tragic tone, which is part of a tragic play’s characteristics: the hero experiencing anagnorisis.…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Analytical Comparison of The Comedy of Errors by William Shakespeare and The Parent Trap by Nancy Meyers How has comic concerns and comic techniques developed and changed over time? As society innovates, the humor associated with that society innovates as well. This exploration illustrates the extent on which narratives, comic techniques, characters, and thematic concerns have changed with the passage of time by comparing The Comedy of Errors by William Shakespeare (pre-20th century) and The Parent Trap directed by Nancy Meyers (post 20th century). In both examples, the entire plotline of the play is based on an extremely improbable and absurd set of circumstances heightening the opportunity for humor and detaching any conception of realism…

    • 1906 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Midsummer’s Nightmare Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream suggests that its relationships are happy ones, but this suggestion is complicated. In fact, the interplay between each of the couples indicates a nefarious quality present in all these relationships.…

    • 1302 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Theme Of Arrogance In Oedipus

    • 1630 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 6 Works Cited

    Prior to the plays setting “Oedipus goes to Delphi where he asks the oracle who his true parents are. To this the god responds that he will kill his father and marry his mother.” (Hogan P. 19) Determined not to allow the prophecy to come true Oedipus runs away from his home in Corinth. During Oedipus’ travel, he encounters a small group of men “where three roads meet”. Oedipus first displays his arrogance by not peacefully resolving the confrontation he encountered, knowing that the prophet prophesied Oedipus killing his own father.…

    • 1630 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 6 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Titus Livius and The Early History of Rome Roman history is subjective to those who study it and write about the rise and the fall of the Roman Empire. One ancient historian named Titus Livius, who was born in either 59 B.C. or 64 B.C. , had written a series of books titled History of Rome. Not much is known about Titus Livius in his younger years except that he had lived in the city of Padua, which had suffered greatly in Rome’s Civil War. His books are split into several different decades of Rome’s rich history. The first series he wrote in History of Rome are broken down in five separate book(s) titled: “Rome under the Kings”, “The Beginning of the Republic”, “The Patricians at Bay”, “War and Politics”, and lastly “The Capture of Rome”.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are many great examples of this throughout the entirety of the play. Almost every decision Marcus Brutus makes during the play has an affect on him later on. For example, when he has the opportunity to kill Antony along with Caesar, he doesn’t seize it. Brutus said, “ For antony is but a lim of Caesar, let’s be sacrificers, but not butchers… and in the spirit of men there is no blood.” (II.i.165-168).…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The author of this article presents to the reader an overview of Shakespearian theme utilized in the story Othello. He categorizes all the emotions revealed in the story into two main themes; love and pity. The writer further argues specific scenarios in the play where these themes can be distinguished. Likewise, he brings awareness to the symbols that 'prove ' the themes of love and pity. For example, the handkerchief and the wedding bedsheets, hold a much deeper meaning in this play then simply a piece of cloth.…

    • 1094 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stripped down to its most basic structure, a classical tragedy centers on characters who bring about their own destruction by way of their tragic flaws. Classical tragedy is most commonly associated with ancient Greek plays, but the genre set forth by the Greeks stands the test of time quite well; after all, any person from any time and place can relate to the possibility of ruining his own life through foolish and flawed actions. Perhaps, then, it is no surprise that Renaissance author William Shakespeare himself followed in the footsteps of ancient Greek playwrights such as Euripides. Certainly, though many changes took place between Euripides’ time and Shakespeare’s, human nature was not among them. Just as human nature can be altruistic and noble, it can also prove greedy, lustful, and murderous.…

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Euripides 's Medea is an overly dramatized anti-feminist play that borders on portraying prejudices against women as outlandish comedy. To modern readers like the ones in our Gender and Sexuality class at Lick, Medea can come across as comic, but this reaction does not mean that our society is “post-sexist”; there are definitely still many people who agree with the prejudices the play presents. But although Medea can come across as stereotypical in that Medea is the overly-emotional woman and Jason is the overly-logical man, the ancient play still exposes gender roles in a way that is recognizable today; we laugh at the ridiculousness because we are still familiar with such absurd sexism in modern society. Medea’s responses to Jason’s actions…

    • 1312 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Masculinity In Lysistrata

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Comparative Analysis in Lysistrata Lines 507-520 & 360-369 I will argue that these two passages are a commentary on the state of masculinity in this play. These two passages reveal the fragility of masculinity. This fragility is revealed through their tendency for violence and aggression, poor decision-making abilities and absolute refusal to be questioned about their decisions. Aristophanes uses these passages to remark on how instead of men being the stronger sex, their fragile masculinity ultimately makes them inferior to women. When the Councilor attempts to end the women’s siege on the Acropolis, Lysistrata confronts him on the damage men have inflicted to the society through the war.…

    • 1156 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays