The Shortcomings Of Multicultural Education

Superior Essays
Found in the workings of Richard Ruiz’s “Orientations of language planning, specific focus is placed on the shortcomings and strengths of language as a problem, right and resources in approaches to language planning” (Ruiz, 1984, p.15). Ruiz states that although there may be problems with a resource orientated approach to language, it could help to reshape attitudes about language and various language groups (1984). In essence, the placement of language as a resource can assist in the resolutions of the other two proposed orientations in viewing language as it can often directly impact the enhancement of language status among subordinate languages; serving as a more consistent way of viewing the role of non-English languages, easing the tensions …show more content…
As cited in Clarke and Medina (2000, p.65) Banks (1994, p. 86) contend that one of the most important aspects of becoming a multicultural teacher is the need to examine one’s own ideologies. The process of becoming multicultural starts with the personal questioning of beliefs, in which reading and writing narratives can assist teachers in creating valuable experiences for students to begin the process of becoming multicultural (Clarke and Medina, 2000, p. 65). Essentially, teachers can use the narratives of their own and students’ lives as a language resource whereby literature becomes a process of enacting critical awareness of the various narrative contexts shared, bringing thinking and theorizing together to determine a stance towards pedagogy, literacy and multiculturalism (Clarke and Medina, 2000, p.65). Furthermore, research conducted by Clarke and Medina (2000, p. 75) highlights the importance of reading and writing literacies in fostering multicultural understandings however limitations subside in the ability of teachers to eliminate stereotypes that may become present from the diversity of the students. Hence, seeing language as a resource can possess some limitations in providing useful learning opportunities if these issues are not met early on in the …show more content…
As stated in the NSW Quality Teaching framework (NSW Department of Education and Training, 2008, p.31). , teachers should possess knowledge of cultural diversity and use it to implement and program student activities. May (2008, p. 415) examines the minority group of English language learners where barriers to school success can be experienced due to current discourses embedded in school curriculums and assessment tools. In order to maximise the full potential of English language learner’s teachers can benefit from creating a classroom environment with a goal of expanding learning through the exposure to the languages and cultures that children bring with them. Williams (2005, p.343) states that teachers often struggle on how to “reconcile conflicts in regards to discourse, that are ethical and constructive, respecting students community and home identities whilst teaching students literacies that will extend beyond the school and provide cultural capital.” Language is so forth seen as a resource for providing the connections between primary discourses for literacy learners whether it be through English as a second language or second language acquisition. A great example in catering for the diverse perspectives of English language learners can be seen through an approach that

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    This annotated bibliography will give you a look into chapter 9 from the Multicultural Education textbook. It will also go in depth of two articles. The first article, African American and White Adolescents' Strategies For Managing Cultural Diversity in Predominantly White High Schools, will show you a questionnaire that was conducted to students who are White and African American. The second article, Discrimination, Ethnic Identity, and Academic Outcomes of Mexican Immigrant Children: The Importance of School Context, focuses on Mexican immigrant students and how they experience discrimination, their academic attitudes, and ethnic identity in schools. Both articles provide their statistics, and results.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This book did not really hit home for me until I went to Cesar Chaves Elementary School. I saw first hand how evident these ideas of “playing school” and holding students back from expressing their cultural identity. This belittles the student in the classroom, telling them that their culture is not as important as “white culture” creating a bigger divide between students and the administration team of schools. To help bridge that gap, students should have a safe place to practice their first learned language in some way in the classroom.…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Understanding someone’s language is a hard task because the culture is an important tool in the most difficult thing in this world. However, the major issue is that the person is still having a major time with a language because the person is not understanding the details. An overall judgement was to be confirmed that the language is to be a major problem. Amy Tan “Mother Tongue” and James Baldwin “If Black English Isn’t a Language, Then Tell Me What is?” explain the facts of language and its purposes.…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    What I learned As a Caucasian middle classed women in a town predominantly composed of individuals similar to me, I have fortunate enough to have faced very little discrimination in daily aspects of my life, including education. For this reason, I find myself at a disadvantage in terms of teaching to an increasingly diverse population. As a case in point, Glen E. Singleton, author of Courageous Conversations about Race, stated, “I don’t know what I don’t know” whilst discussing the matter of race. Put simply, I understand that I cannot possibly know everything about another culture; and I may lack the understanding, or misconstrue certain aspects from which I do know.…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The power of language can be small yet huge, despite how it change you. This power allows you to be true to yourselves and be able to become someone you are proud to be. The author, Gary Braver, for the book Exploring Language, collect essays that inspire his readers wanting to learn more about language. In his book, Gareth Cook and Christine…

    • 1176 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Assignment Heading We now talk about Englishes rather than English and multiliteracies rather than literacies Demonstrate the breadth of your understanding of the diversity of English across time, geography, culture and class and explain why it is essential for teachers in the 21st Century to be aware of ‘multi-literacies’ and language variation. Intro- 150 words Teachers of the 21st Century need to be aware of and up-to-date with the literacy demands required to teach and communicate within the everyday classroom.…

    • 1878 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This week I found both chapter 7 & chapter 8 to hold great ideas and helpful insights into becoming multicultural educators. Specifically, after reading chapter 8 I thought it would be a great benefit to a multicultural educator to be submersed in a foreign country for a short period of time before they start teaching. I think even if a future educator spent a week in a foreign country, ideally where they do not look like or speak the same language as the ethnic majority, it would greatly benefit them and their future students. As Chia-lin Huang shared in chapter 8, during her time in the United States she began to understand what the students she was instructing in Taiwan must have felt. This gave her an understanding of their feelings of inadequacy, discomfort, frustration amongst other insights.…

    • 586 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Diversity In Schools

    • 1832 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Ladson-Billings writes that culturally relevant teaching is much more in depth than just adapting school culture to the culture of the students. In reality, it can also be used to help the students understand their own culture and to help them interpret and conceptualize knowledge (Ladson-Billings, 1992). For this to work and be effective, minority cultures must be acknowledged as a vital strength and asset instead of just adapting the white Caucasian to fit the needs of all minorities (Ladson-Billings, 1992). Teachers must also recognize that culturally relevant teaching addresses the needs of minorities as a whole instead of individual empowerment (Ladson-Billings,…

    • 1832 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A few weeks ago, I stumbled upon a quote by Robert John Meehan: “Your life as a teacher begins the day you realize you are always a learner.” Throughout the course of this semester, I have learned a monumental amount and grown immensely in my journey towards a career in education, and, as the quote expresses, I have realized that part of being a teacher is continually adding to this development. I believe this ceaseless pursuit of knowledge to better ourselves as educators is an imperative aspect of this profession because for every new bit of information we acquire and the more we develop, the more our students benefit. With that in mind, each experience, whether it be good or bad, I have drawn from this course and field experience has contributed…

    • 1477 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Multicultural Education “At its best, multiculturalism is an ongoing process of questioning, revising, and struggling to create greater equity in every nook and cranny of school life... It is a fight for economic and social justice . . .. Such a perspective is not simply about explaining society; it is about changing it.” (Nieto 2) As we look into the text Affirming Diversity, we find Sonia Nietos insights and research on the struggle for equality in education.…

    • 1295 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Supporting English Language Learners There are an increasing number of non-native English speakers in schools around the United States. Schools are faced with the daunting task of providing an education that meets the needs of every student, including those who have a language barrier. According to Tom Stritikus, many linguistically diverse students fall into two categories: National Merit Scholars and high school dropouts (Laureate Education, 2009a). More must be done to ensure that ELL students fall into the National Merit Scholar category as opposed to the dropout category.…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Diversity presents both challenges and opportunities for classroom teachers. In this paper, I examine what an appropriate educational philosophy should entail in a culturally diverse classroom. Cultural Diversity Culture is a force that connections a particular group of people together through a shared historical experience. People of the same culture tend…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Course Reflection Essay

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Course Reflection and Professional Application While conducting research in this course, I came across a quote from Cesar Chavez, “We need to help students and parents cherish and preserve the ethnic and cultural diversity that nourishes and strengthens the community – and this nation”. Prior to this course, I was knowledgeable about the cultural, linguistic, and learning needs in my classroom. What I have learned is the importance of not only knowing about the diversity but being able to address it professionally and provide the best possible education for every student. I learned the importance of involving and communicating with the families of my diverse learners as well as the community. I will continue to educate myself about best…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    English endorse the cause of international communication, and this type of communication can only be recognized on the basis of mutual establishment and understanding of a language as well as culture. Therefore, all cultures should be immersed into an international common linguistic frame. But the position held by some native speakers would block this immersion because it helps only one side of the two communicative participants, which results in loss of international status of English. Widdowson argues that if reasons for persisting on Standard English are, because it pledges effective communication, then the emphasis should be logically on vocabulary rather than on grammar. Grammar can be a way to express one’s social identity.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Today English is no more territorially and culturally bound. It is internationalized. It cannot be treated as a foreign language .It ’s prominence is attributed to its dynamic and borrowing nature. It is used both as a link language and an official language.…

    • 1252 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays