Psychological Treatment, By David Barlow: Article Analysis

Good Essays
The article Psychological Treatment, by David Barlow, discusses the needs to create a more honed definition for psychological treatments such that it is separated from the broader definition that is psychotherapy. Barlow, believed that using treatments that are specified to disorders, is just as effective as providing patients with prescribed medication. The efficacy of treatments that had been proven time after time, he believes should be grounds to include them in the health care system. Barlow, believed that using medication alone does not provide any real guarantee of remission or relief of symptoms even if pharmalogical companies market their drugs as the “be-all and end-all” of solutions. For example, hormone replacement therapy was the …show more content…
Some approaches are developed for specific psychological concerns, such as depression or PTSD. The article discussed that the effective of a treatment can be tied for various factors, one of which is the clinicians experience and expertise in their treatment field. Theoretical approaches require heavy evidence to be implemented in practice, however, if left in the hands of non-psychologist one can not rely on proper administration of the treatment. Barlow states that therapist experience can aid in choosing what strategies to implement for different patients, something that a novice in the field may not be able to do. Another therapy discussed in lecture was Cognitive-Behavioral therapies, which focuses on thought processes which are seen as mediating behavior. One of the main items discussed in lecture in terms of this therapy, is that the treatment is tailored to the client. Once again, suited tailoring can be left in the hands of a novice (i.e. non therapist) or in experienced therapist that can identify key items to tailor …show more content…
Medication alone can’t be the sole answer. As Barlow exemplified HRT. HRT, believed to the solution to postmenopausal symptoms and even believed to provide additional benefits, was found to do quite the opposite of its marketed benefits. Barlow noted that as psychological interventions are proven to be effective time as after time, they are also proved to be as effective (and sometimes even more effective) than medications to specific disorders. Why administer medication, that may help the individual psychologically but ruining their organs and metabolic processes. For example, much of the marketed medications of depressions or ADHD list “suicidal thoughts and behaviors” as a main side-effect. Although, helping depression symptoms it’s creating suicidal ideation in patients, not quite the benefits expected. However, using psychological treatments that has been proven to be effective of depressive disorders does not place patient at risk of suicidal thoughts. Furthermore, what is great about including psychology treatments more intensively in the health care system is that if there is needed for the administration of medication, it can be done so as a complement to treatment. Additionally, if treatment alone does not yield the expected improvement low doses of medication can be given rather than administering higher doses. Why place patients at

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    Initially, I thought that the idea of a placebo was clever and safer process than taking drugs and medication. Regardless, reading more into the placebo is interesting to think of it being based on the person unaware of the sugar pills or false surgery being done. It is scary to think that there is a chance that you may not get better might be because the proper medication was given and a doctor chose to prescribe a placebo instead. It is always interesting to see both sides of an issue in order to better understand the true effect that this process would have on patients. In the end, the placebo effect is an interesting psychological concept that has proven to be both effective and hazardous.…

    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Benefit Of Placebo Effect

    • 1828 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Benefits of the placebo effect The placebo effect is a very interesting area of study also called the placebo response. Where the subject is given a fake prescription, an inactive substance could often help subjects ' mental state because of the fact the subject would like it to help. The thing that a substantial segment of the examinations has alike is they won 't impact someone 's well-being. A person given such an ineffectual medication does often help the subject with their cognitive. Through my research I discovered that the placebo is older than its actual creation.…

    • 1828 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The Harm-Reduction Model

    • 1063 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Methadone can be very beneficial because it allows a heroin addict to withdraw from the drug safely. Also, it can potentially safe an addicts life because when one withdraws from heroin on their own, also known as cold turkey, it can be very dangerous. “Research suggests that methadone treatment does help addicts withdraw from heroin and lead more productive lives” (McGrawHill Higher Education, 2007, Treatment Strategy). However, there is a disadvantage to consuming this drug. Methadone is known to be very addictive as well, which in turn could lead to a new dependency of this drug.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Methodological Issues EBP

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For instance, it offers a guide to the process of knowledge (in form of best evidence) transformation into practice in clinical psychology. This is a case in which best evidence is uniquely modified to fit individual cases of patients rather than generalized approaches. It all starts with unpublished data such as professional opinions and experiences to the time of systematic knowledge synthesis informing decision making. The discussion about the use of EBP and PBE in identifying treatments for psychological disorders leaves one thing: the need to bridge the gap between the known evidence on effective treatment and the information given to the consumers in routine health care. This is about coming up with an implementation of the science and practice of handling the psychological disorders.…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Not only does it exemplify the “Mind over matter” belief, in which an individual’s subjective can influence their mental procedures, however it additionally permits them to show signs of improvement without the hurtful impacts of a few medications. In my paper I will try to identify the effectiveness…

    • 1698 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Goals Of Narrative Therapy

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The therapist begins listening for spontaneous descriptions by asking questions. They listen to find exceptions to help the clients to enact preferred solutions to their life (page 337). The questions will encourage the client to consider new possibilities that have been formed. Questions in Narrative Therapy are designed as “inner talk” in working with the client about the problem. The therapist asked the client to organize the problem, and ask questions to attempt to dissolve the problem (page 386).…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This makes antidepressants an effective way to treat various forms of depression, whether it would be long term or short term. Antidepressants can boost a person’s mood so that they can get out of the depression stage. Depression is known as “the common cold of mental illness.” In psychology we use our brains to process certain behavioral activities. If one is not behaving normally it can be hard to observe the person’s actual actions due to them not being able to…

    • 1665 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    For example, a child with ADD may benefit from a stimulant and a patient who hears or sees things that are not real would likely need an antipsychotic medication. The downside of treating mental illness with medication is that almost all drugs have unwanted side effects, but if the benefits experienced outweigh the risks, it can be the best treatment method for a mental…

    • 833 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Unlike other treatments, Auricular acupuncture can pinpoint the source of unusual behaviors, the central nervous system(Soliman). By using Auricular therapy the central nervous system can be viewed in order to treat the problem directly(Soliman). For people who do not prefer to use harmful drugs as a treatment, auricular therapy can be used as the main treatment(Soliman). Auricular therapy provides a safe, effective fix. Alternative treatments for ADHD can be much more effective than medication.…

    • 1852 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A lot of antipsychotics are trial and error. They are effective but at what cost? What can we do outside of these prescriptions that will truly have a long term effect? Something that is dependent upon them and not a pill or an injection. I do not prefer antipsychotics however, when used properly (that is the right dosage and the correct medication for that particular person), they might be alright.…

    • 1643 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Decent Essays