Case Study: A Performance Appraisal Snafu Case

Decent Essays
“A Performance Appraisal Snafu” focuses on the idea that employees are compensated according to their work evaluations. At this office, located in Newport, Oregon, Marcus Singh and Jason Taft were both scored by their superior Garth Fryer on an outstanding to unsatisfactory scale for all aspects of their job. At the beginning, the employees were satisfied with their close to perfect scores, but this soon changed when Victoria Popelmill, the department director, felt as if Fryer was too lenient with his scores. He was forced to go back and change the scores, making Singh’s marks one grade lower and leaving Taft’s the same. This resulted in Taft receiving a bonus that Singh did not receive. This case brings up the discussion of pay equity and …show more content…
Currently they are operating their performance appraisals using a subjective system. Garth Fryer, the head of the Office of Research and Evaluation, allows his subordinated to provide some input on their own appraisals. This opens this process to a lot of conflict because the employees always think highly of themselves even though they may not always have the greatest performance. It can lead to the bosses using their own subjective mindset for grading their subordinates. In the example of the case, this type of process lead Victoria Popelmill, the department director, to disagree with the performance appraisals she received because they were “too lenient” through her …show more content…
They would be able to track employee’s progress and reward them when they have successfully reached these goals. In the case of “A Performance Appraisal Snafu,” Popelmill could set certain goals that correspond with the type of work they would be performing, and track the employee’s progress . This would eliminate the problems of employees feeling as if they were not rewarded accordingly because not only do the superiors know the goals, but also the employees know them as well, and have the knowledge they need in order to achieve those specific goals in order to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The case of British Columbia (Public Service Employee Relations Commission) v. BCGSEU is a case that demonstrates both, inequity and inequality. Several factors in reaching the decision have to be assessed in order to identify inequity and inequality. The first factor was stated in British Columbia (Public Service Employee Relations Commission) v. BCGSEU (1999) that “First, the employer must show that it adopted the standard for a purpose rationally connected to the performance of the job.” (para. 5). This principle deals with equality as everyone should be judged according to the same standards.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Kansas Case Law

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages

    B. Assessing the impact of the California, New York, and Massachusetts statutes on Kansas state pay equity case law With respect to the four divisions differentiating state pay equity statutes nationally, Kansas’s current pay equity statute applies to all employers, public and private, and falls into the “equal work” or “equal worth” category with twenty-one other states. Kansas’s law does not include language that would potentially broaden the scope of comparison employees bringing claims under the statute could use for support. For example, the state does not allow for comparison of “similar working conditions” — the statute only allows for equality of the employee work and environments being evaluated.…

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Lola had her case brought to her district court, “arguing that reliance on discrimination on their prior salary resulted in unequal pay and constituted unlawful discrimination on the basis of sex.” The…

    • 2994 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Following Laurie Company’s purchase of Western Company, 20 Western employees were laid off. The severance pay offered to the recently terminated were used to match the same offered to Laurie Company employees in the previous year. One of the recently terminated Western Company employees, Bill Smith, was offered 5 weeks of severance pay as compensation. He complained that his offer was not fair compared to what was offered to the Laurie Company employees. As a result, a statistician needed to develop a resolution.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Critical Reflective Essay

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Improving employee productivity and quality of work through increased engagement and motivation 3. Ensuring greater fairness to other team members and creating a positive working environment for the team’ Mary Seacole (Appraisal - What is an appraisal and why is it so important?). MARY…

    • 1669 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    A possible disadvantage of performance appraisals is that they use up a lot of time. An organization needs to take the time to prepare for the appraisal and conduct it. That means downtime for employees, resulting in lost productivity. Per the Mind Tools website, a disadvantage of the performance appraisal is that a company and the employee may have a different interpretation of an appraisal outcome. What a company may perceive as a chance to point out areas for improvement may instead result in an employee feeling that the appraisal was nothing more than a "chewing out" session, causing reduced…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    No Kid Deserted Act

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages

    evaluation driven change 2. Models based appraisal 3. Evaluation focused responsibility 4. High-stakes…

    • 1612 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The issue was whether the company abused the Equal Pay Act by paying the female worker at a lower rate of pay while she was performing generously rise to work inside a similar foundation. The interests court turned around the lower court's concede of outline judgment to the company and remanded the case. The offended party had built up an at first sight instance of pay segregation in view of sex and the company did not give adequate confirmation that the differential was clarified by a factor other than sex. Not at all like many Equal Pay Act cases, court did not take part in a broad examination of this issue. Be that as it may, it expressed that the record bolsters the conclusion that Vehar, Crosley, and Leipold performed generously meet…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    With performance appraisal, it can help benefit both the employee and Mr. Brice. Not only will it let the employees know where they stand, but also help develop employees and plan for future training programs. With compensation processes Mr. Brice may be able to give bonus to employees through training as an incentive or even reward employees for good…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Case analysis that summarizes my understanding of the culture of the Lincoln Electric Company Lincoln Electric Company is an American multinational and global manufacturer of welding products, arc welding consumables, plasma and oxy-fuel cutting equipment and robotic welding systems. John C. Lincoln founded the company in 1895 with only 200dollas as a capital investment to produce electric motors he had designed. Lincoln Electric’s business model has been listed as one of the strongest studied by the Harvard Business School and has been featured in many case studies by other business schools around the world. Since 1975, the Harvard Business School alone has written eight cases about the company. It has a worldwide network of distributors and sales offices covering more than 160 countries: in North America, Europe, Middle East, Asia and Latin America.…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    J. Ginelli, Technician talks about his relationship with their supervisor and how performance appraisals influences work motivation. He feels that the appraisals are useful as to what is expected although it only occurs every 6 months. P.J feels that he is not part of the “important” people and that if the boss knows your name it could be a good or a bad thing when it comes to work performance and promotions. He believes that a promotion would not suite him because he likes doing what he does now and if he continues to get wage raises then why bother getting a promotion. He feels that he would not be able to adapt to high tech environments and possibly lead to negative consequences.…

    • 864 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    For this assignment, I’m choosing my position, correctional counselor to describe the employee appraisal process. As many others I do agree that’s system is not perfect or even good. There are too many things that are subjective, immeasurable and difficult to compare. I agree with 70% of employees that performance process is unsatisfying. Book.…

    • 956 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    According to (Obisi. Chris , 2011) “Organizational performance and its resultant efficiency and effectiveness can only be achieved when individuals are continuously appraised and evaluated. Appraisal outcomes are analyzed to explain strengths and weaknesses and set agenda for better future performance. Organizations should stop giving less attention to the evaluation of their employees and recognize that organizational training needs can only be identified from performance appraisal outcomes”. On the other hand employee evaluations should show employees where improvement is needed.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Ideally, the appraisal should occur once per quarter, but it happens annually in most companies and it never happens in some cases (Javitch, 2016). The methods also diverse and depend on the organization’s need. However, the high CA members might have more anxiety while this evaluation is being conduct. They nervousness also contribute to the evaluation, for instance, they might not have confidence in a self-reflect appraisal that tend to give themselves a lower score than they should be. Since people with high CA have tendency to avoid communication, in this evaluation moment, they might not give any comment, discuss about the appraisal materials, sharing their difficulties at work, or even ask for help in order to improve their performance.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    For last three years, they have continuously made efforts to understand its employee’s aspirations and problems. By the help of that, it had come up with some changes in the HR practices and modified its performance ratings scale. The previous rating scale was not good enough for the employees as it was a four-grade scale. Excellent at top, very good, good and fair. Employees did not perceive ‘good’ as good, thus they revised to a five-grade scale: exceptional, star performer, high performer, performer and…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays