Nature Vs. Nurture In Special Education

Improved Essays
I found a very interesting article in the Capella library. The article is called “Nature vs. Nurture in Special Education”. The article states that “schools are organized as if nature has already won the contest (Marks, S. U. (2009)). This is so significant with school systems today, because it is the truth. A child who has a disability is almost always put into a special education class. They are not even given the opportunity to show that they are able to learn without extra supports. School systems view these children as “not able to learn what their nondisabled peers are learning (Marks, S. U. (2009)).

School systems often use the approach of nature. They categorize students with disabilities, and often put them in rooms with
…show more content…
For children who do not have a disability, school systems favor the nurture side. Children who are in general education classrooms, are given the freedom and flexibility to learn at their own pace. They may learn similar, or very different than the rest of their class. Some students may even need much more support than others (Marks, S. U. (2009)). . With this all being said, the school district does not sort these children without disabilities, the same way they sort people with …show more content…
Just because someone has a disability, does not mean they cannot learn, or that they cannot be taught how to learn. If we use the nature side of the debate, we are not giving children with disabilities the chance to learn. Instead, we are limiting their chances to learn, and categorizing them with other children with disabilities who have higher, and lower functioning levels. Each child should be given a chance to learn in a general education classroom. If they struggle, then they should be put into a special needs classroom with other children who require the same level of support that they do. Categorizing by disability will never work. Each disability is different yes, but each person functions at a different intellectual level. We will not know what level they function at, unless we test them. When putting a child with a disability into a classroom with other children with that some disability, you are diminishing that child’s intellectual level and promoting their disability. They are not given the same opportunity to learn, because nature focuses more on someone’s

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    While it is encouraged for parents to teach some things to their child, like reading and speaking, teaching school curriculums isn’t beneficial. In the long run homeschool children will have a harder time with social interactions because they weren’t exposed to many social events as children(PBS). By homeschooling your child you are denying them the chance to blossom as their own…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Student Neglect

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Student Neglect Students all around the world earn their education through public schools and gain the necessary education needed to flourish in their future lives. However, many children are not in schools at all, but they are in their own “schools” called homeschooling. To some parents this is a justified, and encouraged, structure of education and gives the children an opportunity to discover topics that several in-school children cannot experience while sitting in a classroom. Although this may seem a substantial process to teach children, are they really getting the ultimate education? Schools are meant to teach students additional information rather than just STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) topics that cannot be taught…

    • 1390 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Although separation may be what is best for some students, it is not the case for all of them. Some special education students thrive when they are integrated into a general education classroom. According to Hill and Sukbunpant, an individualized education plan is developed for each student with a disability, which determines the least restrictive environment for that specific student (124). Once the least restrictive environment is determined, which can be a general classroom with or without an aide, a resource room, or a separate classroom, the student can attend the classes that work best for him/her. Placing a student in the least restrictive environment for them allows them to expand their education and work at a pace that is suitable for their needs.…

    • 1304 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Education should not be limited to the standards of math and languages. Once we realize the differences in intelligence of our kids, we can better prepare them for the future. I agree with everything in Ken Robinson’s speech, “Do schools kill creativity.” I believe creativity isn’t accepted in schools, and the arts are not as important as they should be. Standardized testing doesn’t include things like music and theater, and tests are written for one type of intelligence. Our education system should better prepare our children for the distant future, not just for college.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    While other children are able to participate in the learning cycle accordingly without any interference. Children who are considered to have special needs are usually separated from students who are not. Inclusion in education will get rid of the boundaries in present day life allowing both students of special needs are non-LD to learn in the same room. This paper will discuss the history of special education, the needs of the child, the struggles and the several points of view. Before introducing the history of special education, we must first understand what is LD.…

    • 1480 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Autism Research Paper

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “When working with young children with autism, some general principles are applied. Each child with autism is different, but they generally share some of the same learning characteristics such as: they tend to be visual learners, materials need to be clearly organized, and they learn best when sensory stimuli are kept to a minimum (Deris, 2013, pp. 52-56). Interaction of autistic children in the classroom can be difficult to deal with. Some autistic children lack communication skills and cannot express there needs to the teacher.…

    • 1389 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Gracey Myers Mrs. Gallos English 3 Honors 21 November 2017 Making Disabled Children Feel Important Even though there is a good chance, disabled children should be separated from the non disabled children to keep everyone on the same track.Most feel as if disabled kids need all the help and love that non disabled kids need. Disabled kids do not have a fair shot in the school system because they are not given the extra time that they need,and most disabled children are not treated fairly by anyone around them just because they are different. The first problem/issue to discuss is isolating disabled children into a separate school room for most of their school experience. They are not truly getting to live out their days in school because they are being put away from the non disabled children because of “distractions” or potentially slowing the teaching process down. It is as if the children that need extra help are a burden to teachers that are not used to them.…

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Parents that homeschool their children get to decide to some degree the curriculum their children study. When a child is homeschooled they can go at their own pace. This aspect to homeschooling can be looked at as both bad and good. When a child learns at their own pace they can thrive because they can really understand the information before moving on and they can also move faster if they understand the section. However, it can be bad when children are not pushed to their full potential.…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Many discriminate people with disabilities because they feel that the, affected the child is less than them (inferior to them.) Children with learning disabilities must be evaluated in school to prevent the advancement of the learning disability. Learning Disabilities worsen as the…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Other considerations include personalized lesson plans that cater to the needs of the child. Families of homeschooled children often believe that all children placed in one class aren’t all learning at the same pace. This often leaves children feeling insecure and left with the understanding that they’re unable to learn. Should there be a child with learning disabilities, homeschooling parents are often more suitable to alter the lesson plan to ensure that their child gets the most out of their learning as well as a positive and outlook on the educational experience. Learning issues and problematic behaviors can also be addressed quickly, helping the child reach their full…

    • 959 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays